Juan Enriquez: A personal plea for humanity at the US-Mexico border | TED

32,786 views ・ 2019-11-01

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:14
This one's personal.
0
14048
1333
00:17
I know what it's like to have the government say,
1
17309
3287
00:20
"We're going to kill you in the morning."
2
20620
2119
00:24
I know what it's like to leave a country on six hours' notice
3
24314
3571
00:27
and land on someone's couch.
4
27909
1848
00:29
Because of that, I wrote a book
5
29781
1501
00:31
on why countries do well and why they don't.
6
31306
3000
00:35
Let me summarize 250 pages.
7
35246
2023
00:37
Countries have to be compassionate,
8
37809
1715
00:39
they have to be kind,
9
39548
1150
00:40
they have to be smart, they have to be brave.
10
40722
2476
00:43
Want to know what doesn't work?
11
43539
1522
00:45
When you govern through fear and you govern through cruelty,
12
45085
3024
00:48
it just doesn't work.
13
48133
1400
00:50
You can play Genghis Khan for a while,
14
50117
1821
00:51
you can play Stalin for a while,
15
51962
1550
00:53
you can play Pinochet for a while.
16
53536
1961
00:55
It does not work in the long run.
17
55521
2200
00:58
And it doesn't work in the long run
18
58776
1682
01:00
because to govern through fear and cruelty,
19
60482
2690
01:03
you have to create a division.
20
63196
2000
01:05
You have to take big chunks of the country and convince them
21
65855
2968
01:08
that they're not like them.
22
68847
1467
01:11
That they shouldn't associate with them,
23
71862
1914
01:13
they shouldn't talk to them.
24
73800
1388
01:15
That those people are nasty,
25
75212
1357
01:16
those people are criminals, those people are rapists.
26
76593
2641
01:20
And the country is in danger because of them.
27
80701
2563
01:24
And if you spend millions of dollars doing that in your country,
28
84551
3841
01:28
you will make enemies abroad,
29
88416
1933
01:32
and you will create divisions within.
30
92097
2467
01:35
And that has consequences.
31
95149
1733
01:37
Three quarters of the flags and the borders and the anthems
32
97355
2906
01:40
around the United Nations today,
33
100285
1547
01:41
they were not there a few decades ago.
34
101856
2229
01:45
Those lines that are there today,
35
105577
1587
01:47
those flags were created because somebody said,
36
107188
2754
01:49
"the Scotts are not like us,"
37
109966
1492
01:51
"the Welsh are not like us,"
38
111482
1341
01:52
"the Basques are not like us,"
39
112847
1441
01:54
"the northern Italians are not like us,"
40
114312
1921
01:56
"the Muslims are not like us,"
41
116257
1479
01:57
the blacks, the whites, the Christians.
42
117760
2600
02:01
You create "us versus them" ...
43
121442
1734
02:04
you destroy nations.
44
124347
1563
02:07
Part of the problem from creating us versus them
45
127173
2253
02:09
is it's hard to do.
46
129450
1267
02:12
What you have to do
47
132109
1174
02:13
is you have to make people believe absurdities.
48
133307
2598
02:17
And once people believe absurdities,
49
137096
2491
02:19
then they start to commit atrocities.
50
139611
2295
02:22
That's the dynamic of this thing.
51
142239
1595
02:23
You can't create "us versus them" --
52
143858
2067
02:26
you can't have the massacres you had in Rwanda,
53
146236
2198
02:28
you can't have the massacres you had in Yugoslavia --
54
148458
2593
02:31
unless if you create this dynamic.
55
151839
2476
02:34
Let me summarize current immigration policy.
56
154339
2293
02:36
Let's deter "Them"
57
156656
1818
02:38
by being as cruel as we can possibly be,
58
158498
3341
02:41
and let's target their children.
59
161863
2133
02:45
They are going after the children.
60
165474
2793
02:49
You have US lawyers arguing that kids do not need
61
169252
3158
02:52
soap or hugs or showers,
62
172434
2516
02:54
adult help or a release date.
63
174974
1933
02:57
Somebody gets pulled over for a broken tail light,
64
177293
2361
02:59
who's worked here for 20 years,
65
179678
2757
03:02
gets thrown into jail,
66
182459
1675
03:04
maybe for life,
67
184158
1523
03:05
with no legal representation.
68
185705
1801
03:07
The terrorists that blew up the World Trade Center get lawyers.
69
187530
3547
03:11
These kids, these parents, they don't get lawyers.
70
191514
3372
03:15
Governments are telling
71
195966
1199
03:17
some of the most desperate, hurt people on earth,
72
197189
2309
03:19
"I took your child, pay me 800 dollars for a DNA test before you get it back."
73
199522
3995
03:24
Three-year-olds are appearing in court.
74
204784
2324
03:27
Look, we've all watched these courtroom dramas.
75
207649
4096
03:31
And it's exciting,
76
211769
1175
03:32
because the wise judge sits up there,
77
212968
2809
03:35
and the defense lawyer attacks
78
215801
1996
03:37
and the prosecutor counterattacks,
79
217821
1962
03:39
and then you figure out how it's going to happen.
80
219807
2381
03:42
I want you to understand what is happening right now.
81
222212
3040
03:47
Prosecutor's there -- it's the tough prosecutor.
82
227220
3480
03:52
Accusing, attacking, on behalf of we the people.
83
232450
3488
03:57
The judge is up there, Judge Muckety-muck,
84
237436
2172
03:59
with his black robes,
85
239632
1748
04:02
and he's questioning the defendant
86
242381
1627
04:04
from up there.
87
244032
2134
04:07
And the defendant is three years old
88
247569
1786
04:09
and the eyes don't reach the side of the table.
89
249379
3200
04:14
The defendant does not speak the language.
90
254514
2800
04:17
The earphones for the translator have fallen off the defendant's head,
91
257911
4293
04:22
because there are no headphones for three-year-olds in US courtrooms,
92
262228
5332
04:28
because they are not supposed to defend themselves.
93
268498
2939
04:33
This makes a mockery of justice,
94
273223
1666
04:34
it makes a mockery of the prosecution system,
95
274913
2103
04:37
it makes a mockery of who we are as a nation.
96
277040
2608
04:40
These are absurdities.
97
280143
1467
04:42
These are atrocities.
98
282443
1183
04:43
This is unbelievable.
99
283650
1912
04:45
And we're looking at a bunch of statistics,
100
285586
2015
04:47
but I want you to understand,
101
287625
2334
04:49
this is happening to the housekeeper who brought up your kids.
102
289983
4299
04:55
This is happening to the gardener who took care of your house.
103
295529
3460
05:00
This is happening to the guy who washed the dishes
104
300291
2548
05:02
in the fancy restaurant you went to last week.
105
302863
2542
05:07
This is happening to the people who deliver the newspaper in the mornings.
106
307049
3486
05:10
This is your community,
107
310559
1489
05:12
these are the people who have lived side by side with you.
108
312072
4189
05:17
Treated you well,
109
317467
1166
05:18
treated you with respect,
110
318657
1199
05:19
taken care of your kids,
111
319880
1246
05:21
taken care of your grandparents.
112
321150
1579
05:22
This is Luis, this is Laura,
113
322753
2373
05:25
this is Jaime.
114
325150
1150
05:26
This isn't some abstract,
115
326918
1691
05:28
"Oh, it's happening at the border" --
116
328633
1795
05:30
this is happening in our community, right now.
117
330452
2867
05:35
And the danger in this stuff
118
335765
1349
05:37
is once you start normalizing absurdities and atrocities,
119
337138
3635
05:40
people think that those instruments are legitimate.
120
340797
2595
05:43
So you get school boards sending out letters like this:
121
343416
2970
05:46
"Dear Parent,
122
346410
1460
05:47
because your kid owes lunch money to the cafeteria,
123
347894
4150
05:52
the result may be that your child will be taken away
124
352068
2528
05:54
and put in foster care."
125
354620
1711
05:56
This is going out from school boards
126
356355
1776
05:58
because people think,
127
358155
1167
05:59
"Well, that seems to be an instrument of deterrence."
128
359346
3534
06:05
When you board an airplane,
129
365219
1920
06:08
before kids, before first class,
130
368147
3126
06:12
soldiers in uniform board.
131
372164
1972
06:15
Some of them are immigrants.
132
375981
1867
06:18
Here's a contract: join the army,
133
378545
2833
06:21
serve your term, be honorably discharged,
134
381402
2277
06:23
get citizenship.
135
383703
1150
06:26
We are rescinding those contracts
136
386243
2120
06:28
after they have been signed.
137
388387
1866
06:31
And if those soldiers are killed in action,
138
391442
2396
06:33
we are deporting their wives, and sometimes, their children.
139
393862
3937
06:37
These are the people who protect us.
140
397823
2072
06:39
These are the people that we honor.
141
399919
2333
06:42
These are the brave.
142
402617
1230
06:43
And this is how we're treating them.
143
403871
1722
06:45
These are not the people who cross the border illegally.
144
405617
2944
06:48
Once you start allowing this kind of behavior,
145
408585
3333
06:51
it normalizes into a society, and it rips the society apart.
146
411942
4492
06:57
Countries are built on the hard work and grit of immigrants;
147
417045
3091
07:00
we are all immigrants.
148
420160
1466
07:02
We just came at different times.
149
422165
2357
07:04
Fifty-five percent of this country's main businesses,
150
424546
5008
07:09
the most successful businesses in this country, the unicorns,
151
429578
3547
07:13
are built by people who came as foreign students or as immigrants,
152
433149
3952
07:17
and they're the founders or the cofounders.
153
437125
2770
07:19
Well, here's what's happened over the last three years
154
439919
2761
07:22
to the best brains in the world.
155
442704
2056
07:24
Forty-two percent of them did not get visas
156
444784
2309
07:27
or chose not to get visas.
157
447117
1928
07:29
This is how you wipe out an economy.
158
449411
2492
07:31
This isn't about kids and borders.
159
451927
2266
07:34
It's about us.
160
454863
1150
07:37
This is about who we are, who we the people are,
161
457696
2785
07:41
as a nation and as individuals.
162
461387
2066
07:44
This is not an abstract debate.
163
464601
2067
07:49
A lot of us like to think
164
469852
1840
07:52
if we had been back when Hitler was rising to power,
165
472732
3339
07:56
we would have been out in the street,
166
476095
1808
07:57
we would have opposed him, we would have stopped Mengele.
167
477927
2714
08:00
A lot of us like to think,
168
480665
1666
08:03
if we had been around during the '60s,
169
483276
1952
08:05
we would have been with the Freedom Riders.
170
485252
2103
08:07
We would have been at that bridge in Selma.
171
487379
2531
08:09
Well, guess what?
172
489934
1150
08:11
Here's your chance.
173
491661
1556
08:13
It's now.
174
493241
1341
08:14
And as you're thinking about this stuff,
175
494606
3135
08:17
it's not just the giant acts,
176
497765
1404
08:19
it's not just go and block the bridge
177
499193
2135
08:21
or chain yourself to something.
178
501352
2067
08:24
It's what you do in your daily lives.
179
504148
2603
08:26
The Harvard Art Museum just opened a show
180
506775
5143
08:31
on how artists think about immigration and building a home somewhere else.
181
511942
3514
08:35
And people come out of that show and they're pretty shaken.
182
515480
2930
08:38
There was a blank wall at the end.
183
518434
1858
08:41
And the curators did something that usually doesn't happen --
184
521658
3095
08:44
they improvised.
185
524777
1150
08:46
They drew four lines, and put in two words:
186
526554
2363
08:49
"I belong."
187
529515
1188
08:50
So you come out of this exhibit,
188
530727
1572
08:52
and you can take a picture in front of it.
189
532323
2048
08:54
I can't tell you the impact that has on people --
190
534395
2420
08:56
I watched people come out of this,
191
536839
2253
08:59
and some of them sat in front of that picture,
192
539116
2421
09:01
took a picture, and they had a great, big grin on their face,
193
541561
2929
09:04
and some people just had tears.
194
544514
2066
09:07
Some people hugged and brought in strangers,
195
547173
2063
09:09
others brought in their family.
196
549260
1737
09:13
Small acts of kindness go a long, long, long way.
197
553796
3778
09:18
There is pain going on in your community
198
558677
1944
09:20
like you cannot believe.
199
560645
1600
09:23
So next time you're with a cab driver who may be one of "Them,"
200
563025
3064
09:26
according to certain people,
201
566113
2325
09:28
give that person an extra five bucks.
202
568462
2158
09:32
Next time you see a hotel maid,
203
572025
2602
09:34
thank her and tip her double.
204
574651
1933
09:37
Next time you see your gardener,
205
577895
2388
09:40
you see your nanny,
206
580307
2024
09:42
you see somebody like this,
207
582355
1357
09:43
give them a great, big hug, and tell them they belong.
208
583736
2555
09:46
Make them feel like they belong.
209
586315
1530
09:48
It's time for big policies,
210
588856
1333
09:50
but it's also time for big acts of kindness.
211
590213
3722
09:55
Because we have to reclaim who we are,
212
595206
1904
09:57
we have to reclaim this nation.
213
597134
2067
09:59
(Voice breaking) And we cannot sit there
214
599712
2881
10:02
and watch this shit going on.
215
602617
2151
10:05
This has got to stop, it's got to stop now.
216
605791
2611
10:09
Thank you.
217
609196
1177
10:10
(Applause)
218
610397
4285
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7