Free yourself from your filter bubbles | Joan Blades and John Gable

116,152 views ・ 2018-01-12

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
Joan Blades: Do you have politically diverse friends?
0
12948
2598
00:15
What do you talk about with them?
1
15925
1652
00:18
I'm a progressive; I live in a town full of progressives,
2
18076
2830
00:20
and 15 years ago, I didn't have any conservative friends.
3
20930
3648
00:24
Now I have a wonderful mix of friends,
4
24602
2764
00:27
and they include John.
5
27390
1387
00:29
John Gable: I am not a progressive.
6
29354
1753
00:31
I'm a Republican who grew up in a Republican family
7
31672
2879
00:34
in the conservative South,
8
34575
1281
00:35
and even worked in Republican politics, locally and at the national level.
9
35880
3680
00:39
But the last 24 years, I've been in technology
10
39584
2548
00:42
and living in a very progressive area.
11
42156
2303
00:44
So I have a lot of progressive friends,
12
44483
1900
00:46
including Joan.
13
46407
1433
00:48
JB: I was born in Berkeley, California,
14
48666
2504
00:51
a notoriously progressive college town.
15
51194
2483
00:54
And I live there now.
16
54299
1689
00:56
In 1998, six months into the Monica Lewinsky-Clinton impeachment scandal,
17
56891
5699
01:02
I helped cofound MoveOn.org with a one-sentence petition:
18
62614
4557
01:07
"Congress must immediately censure the president
19
67195
3307
01:10
and move on to pressing issues facing the nation."
20
70526
2957
01:13
Now, that was actually a very unifying petition in many ways.
21
73507
3576
01:17
You could love Clinton or hate Clinton
22
77107
2218
01:19
and agree that the best thing for the country was to move on.
23
79349
3977
01:23
As the leader of MoveOn, I saw the polarization just continue.
24
83858
4575
01:28
And I found myself wondering
25
88457
1932
01:31
why I saw things so differently
26
91557
2483
01:34
than many people in other parts of the country.
27
94064
2677
01:36
So in 2005, when I had an opportunity to get together with grassroots leaders
28
96765
6206
01:42
across the political divide,
29
102995
2207
01:45
I grabbed it.
30
105226
1466
01:47
And I became friends with a lot of people
31
107144
2706
01:49
I never had a chance to talk to before.
32
109874
3152
01:53
And that included leadership in the Christian Coalition,
33
113050
3274
01:56
often seen as on the right the way MoveOn is seen as on the left.
34
116348
4425
02:00
And this lead to me showing up on Capitol Hill
35
120797
3347
02:04
with one of the Christian Coalition leaders, my friend,
36
124168
4264
02:08
to lobby for net neutrality.
37
128456
1972
02:10
That was powerful.
38
130452
1151
02:11
We turned heads.
39
131627
1378
02:13
So this work was transformational for me.
40
133915
3692
02:17
And I found myself wondering:
41
137997
2380
02:20
How could vast numbers of people have the opportunity
42
140401
3841
02:24
to really connect with people that have very different views?
43
144266
3574
02:28
JG: I was born Oneida, Tennessee,
44
148972
2017
02:31
right across the state border from a small coal mining town,
45
151013
4662
02:35
Stearns, Kentucky.
46
155699
1317
02:37
And I lived there for the first few years of my life,
47
157040
2516
02:39
before moving to another small town, Frankfort, Kentucky.
48
159580
2744
02:42
Basically, I grew up in small-town America,
49
162348
2100
02:44
conservative at its heart.
50
164472
1384
02:46
Now, Stearns and Berkeley -- they're a little different.
51
166908
3666
02:50
(Laughter)
52
170598
2059
02:53
So in the '90s I moved out west to a progressive area
53
173543
3612
02:57
to work in technology --
54
177179
1527
02:58
worked at Microsoft, worked at Netscape.
55
178730
2072
03:00
I actually became the product manager lead for Netscape Navigator,
56
180826
3189
03:04
the first popular web browser.
57
184039
1518
03:06
Now in the early days of the internet,
58
186204
1891
03:08
we were just moved and inspired by a vision:
59
188119
3176
03:11
when we're connected to all these different people around the world
60
191319
3247
03:14
and all these different ideas,
61
194590
1518
03:16
we'll be able to make great decisions,
62
196132
1826
03:17
and we'll be able to appreciate each other
63
197982
2020
03:20
for the beautiful diversity that the whole world has to offer.
64
200026
2969
03:23
Now I also, 20 years ago, gave a speech
65
203019
1913
03:24
saying it might not work out that way,
66
204956
1832
03:27
that we might actually be trained to discriminate against each other
67
207645
3685
03:31
in new ways.
68
211354
1290
03:34
So what happened?
69
214357
1400
03:36
It's not like we just woke up one day and decided to hate each other more.
70
216233
3625
03:40
Here's what happened.
71
220532
1693
03:42
There's just too much noise -- too many people, too many ideas --
72
222249
3112
03:45
so we use technology to filter it out a little bit.
73
225385
2512
03:47
And what happens?
74
227921
1472
03:49
It lets in ideas I already agree with.
75
229417
2639
03:52
It lets in the popular ideas,
76
232080
1912
03:54
it lets in people just like me who think just like me.
77
234016
2794
03:56
That sounds kind of good, right?
78
236834
1692
03:58
Well, not necessarily,
79
238911
2156
04:01
because two very scary things happen
80
241091
2923
04:04
when we have such narrow worldviews.
81
244038
2178
04:06
First, we become more extreme in our beliefs.
82
246902
3424
04:11
Second, we become less tolerant of anybody who's different than we are.
83
251272
4637
04:18
Does this sound familiar?
84
258266
1583
04:20
Does this sound like modern America? The modern world?
85
260856
2933
04:24
Well, the good news is that technology is changing,
86
264365
2463
04:26
and it could change for the better.
87
266852
1686
04:28
And that's, in fact, why I started AllSides.com --
88
268562
2437
04:31
to create technologies and services to free us from these filter bubbles.
89
271023
3745
04:35
The very first thing we did was create technology that identifies bias,
90
275381
3572
04:38
so we could show different perspectives side by side
91
278977
3245
04:42
to free us from the filter bubbles of news media.
92
282246
3376
04:46
And then I met Joan.
93
286193
1937
04:49
JB: So I met John outside of Washington, DC,
94
289291
3369
04:52
with an idealistic group of cross-partisan bridge builders,
95
292684
5774
04:58
and we wanted to re-weave the fabric of our communities.
96
298482
3603
05:02
We believe that our differences can be a strength,
97
302109
4401
05:06
that our values can be complimentary
98
306534
2859
05:09
and that we have to overcome the fight
99
309417
2951
05:12
so that we can honor everyone's values
100
312392
2496
05:14
and not lose any of our own.
101
314912
1685
05:17
I went for this wonderful walk with John,
102
317051
2030
05:19
where I started learning about the work he was doing
103
319105
2496
05:21
to pierce the filter bubble.
104
321625
1476
05:23
It was powerful;
105
323756
1337
05:25
it was brilliant.
106
325117
1250
05:27
Living in separate narratives is not good.
107
327137
3396
05:30
We can't even have a conversation or do collaborative problem-solving
108
330907
3861
05:34
when we don't share the same facts.
109
334792
2324
05:38
JG: So one thing you take away from today
110
338605
1978
05:40
is if Joan Blades asks you to go on a walk,
111
340607
2370
05:43
go on that walk.
112
343001
1286
05:44
(Laughter)
113
344311
1109
05:45
It changed things. It really changed the way I was thinking about things.
114
345968
3496
05:49
To free ourselves from the filter bubbles,
115
349488
2094
05:51
we can't just think about information filter bubbles,
116
351606
2540
05:54
but also relationship and social filter bubbles.
117
354170
2688
05:56
You see, we human beings -- we're not nearly as smart as we think we are.
118
356882
3460
06:00
We don't generally make decisions intellectually.
119
360366
2457
06:02
We make them emotionally, intuitively,
120
362847
1907
06:04
and then we use our big old brains
121
364778
1721
06:06
to rationalize anything we want to rationalize.
122
366523
2414
06:08
We're not really like Vulcans like Mr. Spock,
123
368961
3415
06:12
we're more like bold cowboys like Captain Kirk,
124
372400
3362
06:15
or passionate idealists like Dr. McCoy.
125
375786
3326
06:19
OK, for those of y'all who prefer the new "Star Trek" crew,
126
379504
2889
06:22
here you go.
127
382417
1152
06:23
(Laughter)
128
383593
1016
06:24
JB: Don't forget the strong women!
129
384633
1897
06:26
JG: Come on, strong women. OK.
130
386863
1463
06:28
JB: All right.
131
388350
1177
06:29
John and I are both "Star Trek" fans.
132
389551
1833
06:31
What's not to love about a future with that kind of optimism?
133
391408
4390
06:36
JG: And having a good future in mind is a big deal -- very important.
134
396495
3623
06:40
And understanding what the problem is is very important.
135
400142
2748
06:42
But we have to do something.
136
402914
1378
06:44
So what do we do?
137
404316
1183
06:45
It's actually not that hard.
138
405523
1350
06:46
We have to add diversity to our lives --
139
406897
2011
06:48
not just information, but relationship diversity.
140
408932
3317
06:52
And by diversity, I mean big "D" diversity,
141
412273
2691
06:54
not just racial and gender, which are very important,
142
414988
2865
06:57
but also ...
143
417877
1218
06:59
diversity of age, like young and old;
144
419820
2720
07:02
rural and urban;
145
422564
2199
07:04
liberal and conservative;
146
424787
2082
07:07
in the US, Democrat and Republican.
147
427428
2966
07:10
Now, one of the great examples of somebody freeing themselves
148
430418
3232
07:13
from their filter bubbles
149
433674
1243
07:14
and getting a more diverse life
150
434941
1613
07:16
is, once again, next to me -- Joan.
151
436578
2235
07:19
JB: So the question is:
152
439551
1370
07:21
Who among you has had relationships lost or harmed
153
441388
4466
07:25
due to differences in politics, religion or whatever?
154
445878
3582
07:29
Raise your hands.
155
449484
1323
07:31
Yeah.
156
451950
1158
07:33
This year I have talked to so many people
157
453132
2773
07:35
that have experienced that kind of loss.
158
455929
4304
07:41
I've seen tears well up in people's eyes as they talk about family members
159
461487
4313
07:45
from whom they're estranged.
160
465824
1539
07:48
Living Room Conversations were designed
161
468166
3698
07:51
to begin to heal political and personal differences.
162
471888
5353
07:57
They're simple conversations
163
477891
1712
07:59
where two friends with different viewpoints each invite two friends
164
479627
3619
08:04
for structured conversation,
165
484274
1616
08:05
where everyone's agreed to some simple ground rules:
166
485914
3032
08:08
curiosity, listening, respect, taking turns --
167
488970
3089
08:12
everything we learned in kindergarten, right?
168
492083
2108
08:14
Really easy.
169
494215
1275
08:16
So by the time you're talking about the topic you've agreed to talk about,
170
496017
4866
08:20
you actually have the sense that,
171
500907
1641
08:22
"You know, I kind of like this person,"
172
502572
1950
08:24
and you listen to each other differently.
173
504546
2316
08:26
That's kind of a human condition;
174
506886
1594
08:28
we listen differently to people we care about.
175
508504
2270
08:31
And then there's reflection
176
511159
1976
08:33
and possibly next steps.
177
513820
1998
08:36
This is a deep listening practice;
178
516301
2639
08:38
it's never a debate.
179
518964
1396
08:41
And that's incredibly powerful.
180
521172
2170
08:43
These conversations in our own living rooms
181
523366
4314
08:47
with people who have different viewpoints
182
527704
2693
08:50
are an incredible adventure.
183
530421
2016
08:52
We rediscover that we can respect and even love people
184
532461
3419
08:55
that are different from us.
185
535904
1734
08:58
And it's powerful.
186
538148
1767
09:01
JG: So, what are you curious about?
187
541014
2614
09:04
JB: What's the conversation you yearn to have?
188
544061
2714
09:07
JG: Let's do this together.
189
547199
1395
09:09
Together.
190
549177
1150
09:10
JB: Yes.
191
550698
1151
09:11
(Laughter)
192
551873
1023
09:12
(Applause)
193
552920
2190
09:15
JB and JG: Thank you.
194
555134
1160
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7