Confessions of a recovering micromanager | Chieh Huang

183,962 views ・ 2018-12-21

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
What I'm really here to do today is talk to you about micromanagement
0
12160
3336
00:15
and what I learned about micromanagement
1
15520
2216
00:17
by being a micromanager over the last few years of my life.
2
17760
3696
00:21
But first off, what is micromanagement?
3
21480
2096
00:23
How do we really define it?
4
23600
2216
00:25
Well, I posit that it's actually taking great, wonderful, imaginative people --
5
25840
4136
00:30
like all of you --
6
30000
1216
00:31
bringing them in into an organization
7
31240
1896
00:33
and then crushing their souls --
8
33160
1576
00:34
(Laughter)
9
34760
1216
00:36
by telling them what font size to use.
10
36000
1856
00:37
In the history of mankind,
11
37880
1656
00:39
has anyone ever said this?
12
39560
1816
00:41
"John, we were never going to close that deal with Times New Roman,
13
41400
4456
00:45
but because you insisted on Helvetica --
14
45880
2856
00:48
bam!
15
48760
1376
00:50
Dotted line --
16
50160
1216
00:51
millions of dollars started to flow.
17
51400
1736
00:53
That was the missing piece!"
18
53160
1376
00:54
No one's ever said that, right?
19
54560
1496
00:56
There's actually physical manifestations that we probably see in ourselves
20
56080
3496
00:59
by being micromanaged.
21
59600
1256
01:00
Think about the most tired you've ever been in your life, right?
22
60880
3056
01:03
It probably wasn't when you stayed the latest at work,
23
63960
2576
01:06
or it wasn't when you came home from a road trip,
24
66560
2536
01:09
it was probably when you had someone looking over your shoulder,
25
69120
3496
01:12
watching your each and every move.
26
72640
2840
01:16
Kind of like my mother-in-law when she's over right?
27
76400
2456
01:18
(Laughter)
28
78880
1016
01:19
I'm like, "I got this," you know?
29
79920
1696
01:21
And so there's actually data to support this.
30
81640
2136
01:23
There was a recent study in the UK.
31
83800
1976
01:25
They took 100 hospital employees,
32
85800
2136
01:27
put an activity tracker on them
33
87960
1656
01:29
and then let them go about their next 12-hour shift all alone,
34
89640
3416
01:33
just a regular 12-hour shift.
35
93080
1976
01:35
At the end of the shift, they asked them, "Do you feel fatigued?"
36
95080
3536
01:38
And what they found was actually really interesting.
37
98640
2456
01:41
It wasn't necessarily the people who moved the most
38
101120
2416
01:43
that felt the most fatigued,
39
103560
1376
01:44
but it was the folks that didn't have control over their jobs.
40
104960
3280
01:49
So if we know that micromanagement isn't really effective,
41
109120
3336
01:52
why do we do it?
42
112480
1776
01:54
Is it that the definition is wrong?
43
114280
1696
01:56
I posited that micromanagement
44
116000
2416
01:58
is just bringing in great, wonderful, imaginative people
45
118440
3016
02:01
and then crushing their souls,
46
121480
1456
02:02
so is it that we actually want to hire --
47
122960
1976
02:04
deep down inside of us --
48
124960
1376
02:06
dull and unimaginative people?
49
126360
1840
02:09
It's one of those questions you probably don't even need to ask.
50
129080
3056
02:12
It's like, "Do you want to get your luggage stolen at the airport?"
51
132160
3176
02:15
Probably not, but I've never been asked, right?
52
135360
2216
02:17
So has anyone asked you, as a manager,
53
137600
2415
02:20
"Do you want to hire dull and unimaginative people?"
54
140039
2817
02:22
So, I don't know, this is TED, we better back it up with data.
55
142880
2936
02:25
We actually asked hundreds of people around the country --
56
145840
2736
02:28
hundreds of managers across the country --
57
148600
2000
02:30
do you want to hire dull and unimaginative people?
58
150624
2560
02:34
Alright, it's an interesting question.
59
154000
1856
02:35
Well, interesting results as well.
60
155880
1656
02:37
So, 94% said no --
61
157560
1256
02:38
(Laughter)
62
158840
1216
02:40
we don't want to hire dull and unimaginative people.
63
160080
2896
02:43
Six percent probably didn't understand the question --
64
163000
2576
02:45
(Laughter)
65
165600
1696
02:47
but, bless their hearts,
66
167320
1256
02:48
maybe they do just want to hire dull and unimaginative people.
67
168600
2936
02:51
But 94 percent said they did not, and so why do we do this still then?
68
171560
3696
02:55
Well, I posit that it's something really, really simple
69
175280
2616
02:57
that all of us deep down inside know and have actually felt.
70
177920
3736
03:01
So when we get hired into an organization --
71
181680
2096
03:03
it could be a club, it could be a law firm,
72
183800
2056
03:05
it could be a school organization, it could be anything --
73
185880
3376
03:09
no one ever jumps to the top of the totem pole, right?
74
189280
2816
03:12
You start at the very bottom.
75
192120
1816
03:13
Doing what?
76
193960
1216
03:15
Doing work.
77
195200
1216
03:16
You actually do the work, right?
78
196440
2336
03:18
And if you're really good at doing the work,
79
198800
2096
03:20
what do you get rewarded with?
80
200920
1456
03:22
More work, right?
81
202400
1216
03:23
Yeah, that's right, you guys are all great micromanagers.
82
203640
2696
03:26
(Laughter)
83
206360
1256
03:27
You do more work,
84
207640
1256
03:28
and then pretty soon, if you're really good at it,
85
208920
2376
03:31
you do a little bit of work still,
86
211320
1656
03:33
but actually, you start to manage people doing the work.
87
213000
2656
03:35
And if you're really good at that, what happens after that?
88
215680
3096
03:38
You start managing the people who manage the people doing the work,
89
218800
4496
03:43
and it's at that point in time,
90
223320
1936
03:45
you start to lose control over the output of your job.
91
225280
4136
03:49
I've actually witnessed this firsthand.
92
229440
2056
03:51
So, I started a company called Boxed in our garage,
93
231520
2416
03:53
and this was it -- I know it doesn't seem like much --
94
233960
2696
03:56
you know, there's a pressure washer in the back --
95
236680
3136
03:59
this is "living the dream."
96
239840
1776
04:01
And my wife was really proud of me when we started this,
97
241640
2656
04:04
or that's what she said, she was really proud of me --
98
244320
2576
04:06
and so she would give me a hug, and I'm pretty sure she had her phone up
99
246920
3416
04:10
and she was thinking, "Oh, is John from Harvard still single?"
100
250360
2936
04:13
It was kind of like a lemonade stand gone wrong in the beginning,
101
253320
3056
04:16
but we actually went up and said mobile commerce is going to be big,
102
256400
3216
04:19
and actually consumer packaged goods were going to change over time,
103
259640
3216
04:22
so let's take these big, bulky packs that you don't want to lug home --
104
262880
3376
04:26
so not the two-pack of Oreo cookies but the 24-pack
105
266280
2416
04:28
and not the 24-pack of toilet paper but the 48-pack --
106
268720
2976
04:31
and let's ship it to you much like a warehouse club would do
107
271720
2856
04:34
except they wouldn't ship it to you.
108
274600
1736
04:36
So that's what we basically did.
109
276360
1576
04:37
We had a really slow printer
110
277960
1416
04:39
and what we did was actually say, "OK, this printer is taking forever, man.
111
279400
3576
04:43
Let's scribble something that would delight the customer
112
283000
2656
04:45
on the back of these invoices."
113
285680
1496
04:47
So we'd say, "Hey, keep smiling," you know?
114
287200
2136
04:49
"Hey, you're awesome,"
115
289360
1576
04:50
or, "Hey, enjoy the Doritos,"
116
290960
1456
04:52
or, "We love Gatorade, too."
117
292440
1976
04:54
Stuff like that.
118
294440
1336
04:55
And so it started breaking up the monotony of the job as well
119
295800
4456
05:00
because I was picking and packing all of the boxes,
120
300280
2376
05:02
and that's all you basically do for eight, nine, 10, 12 hours a day
121
302680
3176
05:05
when you're sitting in the garage.
122
305880
1656
05:07
And so an interesting thing happened.
123
307560
1816
05:09
So we actually started to grow.
124
309400
1960
05:12
And so, you know, over the last --
125
312080
2296
05:14
actually just even 36 months after that,
126
314400
2336
05:16
we ended up selling hundreds of millions of dollars worth of stuff,
127
316760
3256
05:20
and we actually grew really, really quickly.
128
320040
2536
05:22
But during that time, my role started to change, too.
129
322600
2656
05:25
So, yes, I was the CEO in the garage;
130
325280
2496
05:27
I was picking and packing, doing all the work,
131
327800
2176
05:30
but then I graduated
132
330000
1216
05:31
to actually managing the people who picked and packed,
133
331240
2736
05:34
and then pretty soon I managed the people
134
334000
1976
05:36
who managed the people picking and packing.
135
336000
2056
05:38
And even now, I manage the C-staff who manage the departments
136
338080
3376
05:41
who manage the people who manage the people picking and packing.
137
341480
3376
05:44
And it is at that point in time, I lost control.
138
344880
2976
05:47
So I thought, OK, we were delighting all of these customers with these notes.
139
347880
3656
05:51
They loved them, but I can't write these notes anymore,
140
351560
2616
05:54
so you know what I'm going to do?
141
354200
1616
05:55
I'm going to tell these folks how to write these notes.
142
355840
2976
05:58
What pen to use, what color to use, what you should write,
143
358840
3936
06:02
what font you should use,
144
362800
1336
06:04
don't mess up the margins,
145
364160
1496
06:05
this has to be this big, this has to be that big.
146
365680
2376
06:08
And pretty soon this goal of raising morale
147
368080
2496
06:10
by breaking up the monotony in the fulfillment center
148
370600
2536
06:13
actually became micromanagement, and people started complaining to HR.
149
373160
3306
06:16
It's like, "Dude, this CEO guy has got to get out of my hair, OK?
150
376480
3056
06:19
I know how to write a damn note."
151
379560
1616
06:21
(Laughter)
152
381200
1016
06:22
So it was at that point in time, we said, "OK, you know?
153
382240
3256
06:25
We hired these great, wonderful people,
154
385520
3176
06:28
let's give them the mission that's 'delight the customer,'
155
388720
2736
06:31
let's give them the tool to do so, and that's these notes -- have at it."
156
391480
3696
06:35
And so what we found was actually pretty startling.
157
395200
2416
06:37
Some folks actually took the notes
158
397640
1656
06:39
and actually started drawing these really ornate minimurals on them.
159
399320
3976
06:43
When folks ordered diapers, you'd get really fun notes like this:
160
403320
3616
06:46
"Say 'hi' to the baby for us!"
161
406960
1576
06:48
And you know, the next size up, if they bought a bigger size,
162
408560
2896
06:51
they'd write, "Growing up so fast."
163
411480
2336
06:53
And so people really, really took to it.
164
413840
2640
06:57
But it was at that time that it also went off the rails a few times.
165
417400
3216
07:00
And so we had someone just writing, "Thx, thx," all the time,
166
420640
2976
07:03
and it's like, "Alright, dude, my boss used to write that to me,"
167
423640
3096
07:06
so, let's not write "Thx" anymore.
168
426760
2256
07:09
But you also had interesting things on the other side.
169
429040
2616
07:11
People got a little too creative.
170
431680
1896
07:13
And so, like I said before, we sell everything in bulk:
171
433600
3616
07:17
the big packs of diapers, big packs of toilet paper,
172
437240
2456
07:19
the big packs of Doritos and Oreo cookies.
173
439720
3296
07:23
We also sell the big packs of contraception,
174
443040
3296
07:26
and so --
175
446360
1336
07:27
this is getting a little hairy.
176
447720
1696
07:29
(Laughter)
177
449440
1216
07:30
So we sell the 40-pack of condoms, right?
178
450680
3976
07:34
We're all adults in this room -- 40-pack of condoms.
179
454680
2456
07:37
So, someone ordered four 40-packs of condoms --
180
457160
3976
07:41
(Laughter)
181
461160
1216
07:42
And that's all they ordered,
182
462400
2056
07:44
so, 160 condoms,
183
464480
2096
07:46
the packer was like, "I know how to delight the customer."
184
466600
2736
07:49
(Laughter)
185
469360
1616
07:51
"This guy ..."
186
471000
1616
07:52
This is what they wrote:
187
472640
1936
07:54
[Everyone loves an optimist]
188
474600
1616
07:56
(Laughter)
189
476240
1216
07:57
(Applause)
190
477480
3616
08:01
We didn't know whether to fire him or to promote him, but he's still there.
191
481120
3576
08:04
So, "Everyone loves an optimist."
192
484720
1776
08:06
But here is where it went a little bit off the rails
193
486520
5136
08:11
and I felt a little bit conflicted in all of this.
194
491680
2976
08:14
And --
195
494680
1656
08:16
oh, there's a really bad typo --
196
496360
1576
08:17
so if there was only a red T-E-D on stage that I counted on being here,
197
497960
4696
08:22
it wouldn't be a typo, right?
198
502680
1536
08:24
(Laughter)
199
504240
1016
08:25
(Applause)
200
505280
1536
08:26
I promised you I had a really bad sense of humor,
201
506840
2296
08:29
and now I'm gratifying that.
202
509160
1376
08:30
So I told you. But I really was conflicted, right?
203
510560
2536
08:33
At this point in time, we started doing things
204
513120
2176
08:35
that actually weren't part of our core mission
205
515320
2176
08:37
and people started failing at it.
206
517520
2096
08:39
And so, I thought, should we let them fail?
207
519640
3336
08:43
Should we continue to let them do this?
208
523000
1880
08:45
I don't know --
209
525640
1255
08:46
I didn't know at that moment,
210
526919
1736
08:48
but I thought this:
211
528679
1777
08:50
Is failure really that bad?
212
530480
1960
08:53
I'm not saying we should celebrate failure.
213
533320
2096
08:55
There's a lot of talk in Silicon Valley that says, "Let's celebrate failure."
214
535440
3656
08:59
No, I don't know if we would go all the way there,
215
539120
2376
09:01
because like, in our board meetings,
216
541520
1856
09:03
our board members are never like, "Hey, Chieh, you failed last quarter,
217
543400
3376
09:06
keep doing that, buddy, OK?"
218
546800
1376
09:08
No one's ever said that.
219
548200
1256
09:09
If you're part of an organization like that,
220
549480
2096
09:11
give me a call, I want to sit in on that meeting.
221
551600
2336
09:13
In private, I don't think many people celebrate failure,
222
553960
2656
09:16
but failure, I posit, is actually pretty necessary
223
556640
2576
09:19
for the folks truly in the long-term,
224
559240
2176
09:21
for the smart and imaginative people
225
561440
1776
09:23
truly trying to fulfill the mission that you give them at hand.
226
563240
3856
09:27
And so failure can actually be seen as a milestone
227
567120
3016
09:30
along that mission towards success.
228
570160
2680
09:33
And if the downside of not micromanaging
229
573400
2096
09:35
is potentially this perceived notion that you might fail more often,
230
575520
3336
09:38
and if it's really not that bad,
231
578880
2256
09:41
what is the upside?
232
581160
1216
09:42
Well, we saw the upside and it's pretty great.
233
582400
2256
09:44
We tasked our engineers and said,
234
584680
1616
09:46
"Hey, some of our fulfillment centers cost millions of dollars to build,
235
586320
3616
09:49
there's miles and miles of conveyor,
236
589960
1936
09:51
and so, can you do the same thing,
237
591920
1656
09:53
can you make them efficient without spending millions of dollars?"
238
593600
3136
09:56
So, they got to work:
239
596760
1256
09:58
they actually did this -- this is not photoshopped,
240
598040
2416
10:00
the guy is really grinding.
241
600480
1536
10:02
They built an autonomous guided vehicle.
242
602040
1936
10:04
We didn't tell them what to build, what format it needed to be.
243
604000
2976
10:07
In 90 days they produced the first prototype:
244
607000
2136
10:09
powered off Tesla batteries, stereoscopic cameras, lidar systems.
245
609160
3096
10:12
It basically replicates the efficiency of a conveyor belt
246
612280
2696
10:15
without the actual capex of a conveyor belt.
247
615000
3256
10:18
So it doesn't actually just stop with engineers.
248
618280
2336
10:20
Our marketing department --
249
620640
1336
10:22
we told them, "Hey, get the word out; do the right thing."
250
622000
3256
10:25
We have this wonderful lady, Nitasha, on the marketing team.
251
625280
2976
10:28
She stopped me in the morning,
252
628280
1456
10:29
she's like, "Chieh, what are we doing about the pink tax?"
253
629760
2736
10:32
I went and got my coffee, I sat down,
254
632520
1816
10:34
I said, "OK, Nitasha, what is this pink tax?"
255
634360
2136
10:36
And so she told me, it's really interesting.
256
636520
2056
10:38
So, some of you might know that in 32 states across America,
257
638600
2856
10:41
we actually charge a luxury goods tax on women's products
258
641480
3176
10:44
like feminine care products,
259
644680
1376
10:46
so tampons and pads are taxed like luxury goods items.
260
646080
2536
10:48
So I would never dare call my wife --
261
648640
1816
10:50
or if she called me and said, "Hey, hon, bring some pads on the way home,"
262
650480
3496
10:54
and I said, "Babe, you know, there's a trade war going on,
263
654000
2736
10:56
the economy's not that good,
264
656760
1376
10:58
so no luxury goods this month but next month I promise --
265
658160
2816
11:01
(Laughter)
266
661000
1016
11:02
I'll take a look at it."
267
662040
1256
11:03
I'd be single pretty quickly, right?
268
663320
1736
11:05
But what's super interesting is now --
269
665080
2696
11:07
we didn't tell them what to do --
270
667800
1616
11:09
but now, working with finance, they rebate the tax
271
669440
2376
11:11
back to customers all around the country that we unfairly have to collect.
272
671840
3496
11:15
And so at this point in time, you might be thinking,
273
675360
2456
11:17
"OK, what is the real, real upside of not micromanaging?"
274
677840
3936
11:21
and it's this:
275
681800
1656
11:23
I didn't do any of these projects.
276
683480
1656
11:25
I didn't make the AGV.
277
685160
1256
11:26
I didn't do the "Rethink the Pink Tax" campaign.
278
686440
2416
11:28
I didn't do any of this,
279
688880
1216
11:30
but I'm standing here on a TED stage taking all the credit for it.
280
690120
3456
11:33
(Laughter)
281
693600
2240
11:36
"This guy does nothing and takes all the credit for it.
282
696960
2616
11:39
He's a real CEO, this guy. He's really got it down."
283
699600
2456
11:42
(Laughter)
284
702080
1216
11:43
But the reality is this.
285
703320
1736
11:45
I don't have the CEO thing down 100 percent pat,
286
705080
2416
11:47
but I've actually learned the most fundamentally challenging lesson
287
707520
4616
11:52
I've ever had to learn,
288
712160
2456
11:54
and that's this.
289
714640
1536
11:56
There is only one solution to micromanagement ...
290
716200
3616
11:59
and that's to trust.
291
719840
1456
12:01
Thank you.
292
721320
1216
12:02
(Applause)
293
722560
4200
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7