Stories of Photographing Monumental People (from Michelle Obama to Stephen Hawking) | Platon | TED

41,912 views

2022-07-19 ・ TED


New videos

Stories of Photographing Monumental People (from Michelle Obama to Stephen Hawking) | Platon | TED

41,912 views ・ 2022-07-19

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:04
So here we are, together.
0
4626
2419
00:08
But we're in a technological trance.
1
8171
2378
00:11
Here we are together, but we're divided by tribalism.
2
11174
2711
00:14
Here we are together, but we're distracted by mass myths.
3
14636
3462
00:18
We've been separated by walls,
4
18515
2294
00:20
windows, computer screens, borders.
5
20809
2919
00:24
But we're united in our hearts.
6
24396
2627
00:27
Oh, we've argued and quarreled in the past.
7
27524
2878
00:31
But now we know we've got a common bond.
8
31069
2753
00:33
Humanity.
9
33863
1127
00:35
So why are we all here?
10
35615
1669
00:38
Maybe we're all looking for a key.
11
38034
1961
00:40
A key to unlock this political, economic, social, cultural paralysis.
12
40453
6090
00:47
Maybe the answer is in a little word: empathy.
13
47210
4213
00:52
Empathy is not just walking in someone's shoes or feeling someone's pain.
14
52007
4045
00:56
Empathy is the secret ingredient
15
56094
3670
00:59
for finding a human connection.
16
59806
2795
01:03
So I want you to open up your hearts and open up your minds,
17
63226
4588
01:07
because in times of confusion,
18
67856
1877
01:09
we must not lose our capacity to dare to be kind to each other.
19
69774
5339
01:16
Some years ago,
20
76364
1502
01:17
I had the great privilege to be invited to the White House
21
77907
3587
01:21
to do this.
22
81536
1835
01:24
Now this has got nothing to do with politics.
23
84581
2127
01:27
This is a cultural moment in American history.
24
87500
2461
01:30
This is Michelle Obama's first portrait as First Lady.
25
90337
3086
01:35
(Applause)
26
95383
3712
01:39
So on this day, I was nervous.
27
99137
3253
01:42
And when I'm nervous, I get socially clumsy.
28
102849
2961
01:45
Know what I mean?
29
105852
1168
01:47
(Laughter)
30
107020
1460
01:48
So I picked up my camera, focused on her eyelash,
31
108521
4046
01:52
and in my clumsiness I shouted out,
32
112609
2335
01:54
"Right, my love, I want your soul.
33
114944
2420
01:57
Give it to me."
34
117405
1168
01:58
(Laughter)
35
118615
2044
02:00
Silence in the room.
36
120700
1418
02:02
(Laughter)
37
122160
1335
02:03
I'm sure the hairdresser almost dropped the hairspray in shock.
38
123536
3462
02:07
And as I took this picture,
39
127624
1334
02:08
this devastating look came over her face.
40
128958
2461
02:11
The eyebrow raises as if to say,
41
131461
2085
02:13
"How dare you?
42
133546
1168
02:14
But I quite like it at the same time."
43
134756
1835
02:16
(Laughter)
44
136591
1794
02:18
So then I realize what I just said.
45
138426
2086
02:20
And I said, "My goodness me, I'm an Englishman.
46
140512
3170
02:23
And in England we invented being polite.
47
143723
2670
02:26
I think Canadians and Americans do it better now, but we invented it.
48
146393
3586
02:30
And here I am in the White House,
49
150021
2044
02:32
calling you ‘my love’ and demanding your soul.
50
152107
2502
02:34
Please forgive my atrocities."
51
154609
2002
02:37
She stands up, gives me a hug and whispers in my ear,
52
157487
4254
02:41
"Platon, when all is said and done, I'm just Michelle."
53
161741
4546
02:48
This is Pussy Riot.
54
168581
2753
02:52
You probably know them as the hardcore feminist punk rock group
55
172627
3712
02:56
who spoke truth to power against Putin's excessive nationalism.
56
176339
4046
03:00
And consequently,
57
180719
1501
03:02
they were sent to a Siberian prison for two years.
58
182262
3545
03:06
But what happens if we remove those colorful, aggressive masks?
59
186558
4671
03:11
You see something different.
60
191730
1501
03:13
This is Nadia and Masha
61
193732
2669
03:16
photographed after they were released from prison.
62
196401
2794
03:19
Look at their faces, you can see the vulnerability on their faces.
63
199904
3420
03:23
You can see that they've paid a heavy price
64
203366
2544
03:25
for their support of LGBTQ rights
65
205952
2628
03:28
and women's rights in Russia.
66
208621
1836
03:31
Now during their trial in the courtroom, before jail,
67
211541
5672
03:37
they were kept in a big cage as if they're wild animals.
68
217213
3796
03:42
Nadia, the woman with dark hair, the co-founder of Pussy Riot,
69
222427
5130
03:47
she was constantly scribbling handwritten notes on a scrappy piece of paper.
70
227599
4504
03:52
Eventually, the judge said to her,
71
232771
2210
03:55
"I want you to stand up and make your closing statement
72
235023
3295
03:58
before I sentence you."
73
238318
1585
04:00
I'm sure Nadia must have known she's about to go to jail.
74
240320
3879
04:05
Nevertheless, she stood up.
75
245074
2712
04:08
Nervously clutching her piece of paper,
76
248495
3253
04:11
took a deep breath and read out from her notes.
77
251790
3378
04:15
And what she said to the judge and to the world, I believe,
78
255210
3670
04:18
will go down as one of our generation's greatest speeches.
79
258922
4379
04:23
She said,
80
263301
1752
04:25
"I wouldn't give people labels.
81
265094
2503
04:28
There are no winners or losers here,
82
268223
2335
04:30
injured parties or accused.
83
270600
2044
04:32
We just need to make contact,
84
272644
2752
04:35
to establish a dialogue and a joint search for truth,
85
275396
3337
04:38
to seek wisdom together, to be philosophers together,
86
278775
3462
04:42
rather than stigmatizing and labeling people.
87
282278
2878
04:45
That is one of the worst things people could do."
88
285198
3503
04:50
I believe Nadia thinks one of the worst things we could do
89
290119
4171
04:54
is to judge each other.
90
294332
1668
04:56
Maybe we need to be less judgmental
91
296626
3086
04:59
and more curious.
92
299712
1377
05:01
When you look at one of my pictures,
93
301756
2753
05:04
you might find yourself making judgments about that person.
94
304551
3586
05:08
So what happens if I strip away your capacity to make those judgments?
95
308972
4045
05:13
I take away 95 percent of the picture,
96
313059
2795
05:15
and I leave you with just five percent that you can't recognize.
97
315895
4088
05:20
But maybe it's the most important part.
98
320775
2211
05:23
The window to someone's character.
99
323403
2252
05:25
The eye.
100
325697
1168
05:28
Whose eye is this?
101
328157
1585
05:29
Always watching us.
102
329742
1669
05:32
Is it someone you love?
103
332078
1627
05:33
Is it someone you hate?
104
333746
1585
05:35
It belongs to this man.
105
335915
2461
05:40
This man.
106
340962
1877
05:45
At this moment,
107
345133
1918
05:47
I would like to pay tribute to all the courageous, brave,
108
347093
5297
05:52
resilient heroes
109
352432
1835
05:54
who fight against oppression,
110
354267
2252
05:56
who fight for human rights,
111
356519
2503
05:59
dignity, freedom and justice around the world.
112
359063
3128
06:02
Let's give them a round of applause.
113
362233
2336
06:04
Come on.
114
364569
1168
06:05
(Applause)
115
365778
6966
06:12
So I was driven through the streets of Moscow,
116
372952
3045
06:15
past the gates of the Kremlin,
117
375997
1960
06:17
and we continued out of the streets of Moscow
118
377999
2252
06:20
into a dark, bleak, Gothic forest.
119
380293
2711
06:23
We arrived at one of the most sinister buildings I've ever seen in my life.
120
383713
4379
06:28
His private residence, his private dacha.
121
388134
2711
06:31
And it was surrounded by a two-story high security wall
122
391346
3378
06:34
with snipers all the way along the top.
123
394766
2586
06:37
As I get out of the limo,
124
397352
2210
06:39
I'm escorted into the building at gunpoint.
125
399562
3212
06:43
I'm led into a room.
126
403733
1585
06:46
I waited, and he comes in with a giant entourage.
127
406361
2919
06:49
And I said, "Mr. President,
128
409322
2002
06:51
before I capture this moment of history on film,
129
411366
3378
06:54
I've got a question I'd like to ask you."
130
414786
2043
06:57
I said, "I was brought up by my mom and dad
131
417455
2753
07:00
listening to the music of The Beatles.
132
420249
2628
07:03
I want to know if you ever listened to The Beatles.”
133
423586
2961
07:07
His two translators whisper in his ear.
134
427006
2294
07:09
There's some confusing looks amongst the entourage,
135
429676
3169
07:12
and then his mood drops.
136
432845
1710
07:15
And in Russian, he orders the two translators
137
435181
2669
07:17
and all his political advisers out of the room, immediately.
138
437850
4046
07:22
The bodyguards stay.
139
442730
1752
07:25
And then Putin turns to me
140
445441
2044
07:27
and in perfect English, he says,
141
447485
3045
07:30
“I love The Beatles.”
142
450571
1377
07:31
(Laughter)
143
451990
1209
07:33
I said, "I didn't know you spoke English."
144
453241
2002
07:35
He said, "I speak perfect English."
145
455284
1711
07:36
I said, "In that case, who's your favorite Beatle?"
146
456995
2419
07:39
He said, "Paul."
147
459455
1168
07:40
I said, "What's your favorite song?
148
460623
1710
07:42
Is it 'Back in the USSR?'"
149
462333
1669
07:44
(Laughter)
150
464043
2252
07:46
Yeah, he didn't like that very much.
151
466295
1794
07:48
And then he said, "No.
152
468798
1710
07:51
My favorite song is ‘Yesterday.’
153
471676
2461
07:54
Think about it."
154
474178
1252
07:56
And I thought about it.
155
476305
1627
07:58
And I realized I'm being sent a subliminal message
156
478516
3837
08:02
about the old days of power and authority of the Soviet Union
157
482395
3962
08:06
through a Paul McCartney song.
158
486357
1877
08:09
Now, that human connection I had with him allowed me in,
159
489318
5339
08:14
and I ended up about an inch and a half away from his nose as I took this picture.
160
494699
4087
08:18
I could feel his cold breath on my hand as I focused the lens,
161
498828
3503
08:22
and that's how I got the truth.
162
502373
2002
08:25
The truth is that this is the cold face of power and authority in Russia.
163
505043
4546
08:30
And then he performs power for me in his chair.
164
510048
3670
08:35
Now the LGBTQ community and the human rights community in Russia,
165
515762
4546
08:40
many of their members have adopted my pictures of Putin,
166
520308
4045
08:44
and they used them as a banner
167
524395
1710
08:46
to show everything that they believe is wrong with power in their country.
168
526147
4796
08:50
I've been told recently
169
530985
1877
08:52
that anyone in Russia who is caught circulating my pictures online
170
532904
4588
08:57
in connection with human rights violations
171
537533
2628
09:00
will be arrested
172
540203
1418
09:01
and they will go to jail immediately.
173
541621
2461
09:07
Whose eye is this?
174
547001
1585
09:09
Someone you love?
175
549128
1210
09:10
Someone you hate?
176
550379
1377
09:12
It belongs to a man who was prepared to go to jail for his beliefs.
177
552215
4421
09:17
The late, great Muhammad Ali.
178
557178
3128
09:21
I said to him, "Muhammad, you are the greatest.
179
561432
4463
09:26
Teach me to be great.
180
566437
1669
09:28
How can my generation be as great
181
568147
2086
09:30
as your generation had to be during the civil rights era?"
182
570233
3461
09:34
He couldn't speak very well because of Parkinson's.
183
574570
2711
09:37
So I had to get close, and he whispered,
184
577615
2753
09:40
"I have a confession to make."
185
580368
1877
09:42
"What is it?" I said.
186
582286
1335
09:43
He said, "I wasn't as great as I said I was."
187
583663
2836
09:46
(Laughter)
188
586499
1209
09:47
"Holy shit," I said.
189
587750
1585
09:49
(Laughter)
190
589377
1501
09:50
"That's the biggest confession I ever heard in my life.
191
590878
2628
09:53
The whole world knows you as Ali, the greatest."
192
593506
2628
09:56
And then he said,
193
596884
1627
09:58
"I think you misunderstand me.
194
598553
2252
10:01
I'll tell you what was great," he said.
195
601806
2210
10:04
"It wasn't me.
196
604433
1293
10:06
It was the people, saw themselves in my struggle,
197
606185
4463
10:10
in my story."
198
610648
1460
10:12
And then he turned it to me,
199
612900
1377
10:14
And now I've got the great honor to turn it to you.
200
614318
3963
10:18
And he said,
201
618948
1627
10:20
"If you can get people to see themselves in the story that you put forward,
202
620616
4547
10:25
then you have a chance of achieving greatness.
203
625204
2252
10:27
But that greatness is never you personally.
204
627498
2586
10:30
That's something much bigger, called bridge building."
205
630459
3462
10:34
A light bulb went off in my brain, so I took this picture.
206
634881
3753
10:38
My last ever portrait of Muhammad Ali.
207
638676
2461
10:41
Not as a prizefighter or a champion,
208
641470
2128
10:43
but as a compassionate bridge builder,
209
643639
1919
10:45
thinking of the underdog.
210
645558
1710
10:48
Whose eye is this?
211
648686
1418
10:50
Someone you love, someone you hate?
212
650980
2044
10:53
A different type of underdog.
213
653649
1919
10:56
Belongs to this man.
214
656235
1585
10:58
So I said to him, "Donald,
215
658738
2210
11:00
"Let's be human with each other just for a few minutes.
216
660990
3045
11:04
We've all followed your career," I said.
217
664076
2086
11:06
"No one can doubt, it's an extraordinary career path you've had.
218
666162
4254
11:10
But there's always something about you.
219
670458
1877
11:13
There's always an air of tension and controversy
220
673002
2586
11:15
about things you say and do in public.
221
675630
2586
11:18
And I'm sure that's intentional on your part.
222
678257
2920
11:21
But it feels to me as if you're in the middle of an emotional storm.
223
681219
3545
11:24
Personally, I couldn't live with that anxiety all the time.
224
684764
3378
11:28
I want to know how you weather the storm."
225
688184
2335
11:31
He calmly looks at me and he says,
226
691270
2795
11:34
"I am the storm."
227
694065
1793
11:35
(Audience murmurs)
228
695900
1960
11:39
The eyes are always watching us.
229
699237
3169
11:43
But how do we use our eyes?
230
703324
2920
11:46
Do we look?
231
706827
1127
11:48
Or do we see?
232
708788
1334
11:51
When you look at this picture,
233
711457
2211
11:53
you might find yourself thinking about the politics of war.
234
713709
4088
11:58
But when you see the person in this picture,
235
718381
2919
12:01
you get to know Jessica.
236
721342
1668
12:03
Jessica holds a flag they draped over her husband's coffin,
237
723886
3670
12:07
who had recently been killed fighting in Iraq for America.
238
727598
3712
12:11
I took this picture in her home.
239
731686
1918
12:14
Now she has his wedding ring around her neck on a chain.
240
734563
3546
12:18
When you're killed in combat,
241
738901
1794
12:20
the US military sends your clothes and personal belongings
242
740736
2920
12:23
back to the family in a big box.
243
743698
2419
12:26
Jessica had recently received the box
244
746534
2919
12:29
but had not yet had the courage to open it.
245
749453
2378
12:32
There it lay, closed, at the base of her bed, in her bedroom.
246
752456
3546
12:37
I said to her, "Jessica, maybe you should wear one of his army T-shirts
247
757044
3587
12:40
as a tribute to him in the picture."
248
760673
2044
12:42
She said, "I would.
249
762758
1502
12:44
But all his T-shirts are in the box.
250
764802
2711
12:48
Maybe now," she said,
251
768347
1877
12:50
"it's time for me to face that emotion."
252
770224
2669
12:54
So we both walked into her bedroom.
253
774061
2044
12:56
We both knelt at the base of her bed,
254
776772
2628
12:59
and we undid a latch each of the box and lifted the lid.
255
779442
3587
13:04
And she burst into tears.
256
784030
1751
13:07
And I felt ashamed of myself.
257
787241
2753
13:10
For the first time in my life,
258
790995
1668
13:12
I had put a photograph above the well-being of a person.
259
792705
3629
13:17
As I apologized, she said,
260
797043
1543
13:18
"You don't understand why I'm crying.
261
798627
2753
13:22
I'm crying," she said,
262
802173
1960
13:24
“because I just realized they washed his clothes,
263
804175
3003
13:27
and I wanted to smell him again."
264
807219
2211
13:36
Did you feel that?
265
816562
1460
13:41
Did you feel that?
266
821734
2377
13:47
If you felt that ...
267
827656
1877
13:51
then something beautiful just happened.
268
831702
2086
13:55
We all came into this room defined by our differences.
269
835456
4338
14:00
Men, women, old, young, Black, white.
270
840252
3295
14:03
Dare I say, members of the Left.
271
843589
2127
14:06
Dare I say, members of the Right.
272
846008
1794
14:08
Different genders,
273
848260
1502
14:09
different religious groups, cultures.
274
849804
2711
14:12
But we all felt that together.
275
852515
3253
14:16
What we felt is compassion.
276
856143
2169
14:18
Compassion for someone you've never even met.
277
858604
2628
14:21
That's the power of human connection.
278
861273
2545
14:23
And that's why we will not go down
279
863859
2962
14:26
as the generation of connectivity that disconnected itself, no.
280
866821
4296
14:32
I think we're going to rise up.
281
872284
1585
14:34
I think we're going to rekindle the spirit of optimism.
282
874328
3170
14:38
It seems to me they underestimated the resilience of humanity.
283
878040
4880
14:44
Whose eye is this?
284
884213
1460
14:46
Someone you love?
285
886090
1376
14:47
Someone you hate?
286
887800
1376
14:49
It belongs to a man who was robbed of the power of human connection.
287
889844
4796
14:55
Professor Stephen Hawking.
288
895683
1626
14:58
Now, he was very ill when I took this picture.
289
898519
2461
15:00
In fact, his whole body had essentially shut down.
290
900980
3044
15:04
There was only one muscle he could still work,
291
904024
3045
15:07
and that was underneath his eye.
292
907069
2294
15:09
His team of scientists placed a sensor at the base of his glasses.
293
909405
4546
15:13
You can see it here.
294
913951
1502
15:15
And that sensor picks up movement of that muscle.
295
915453
2752
15:18
And with that muscle,
296
918247
1168
15:19
he moves a cursor over each letter of the alphabet
297
919457
2836
15:22
on his laptop screen.
298
922334
1544
15:24
He chooses a letter, builds a word,
299
924253
2628
15:26
constructs a paragraph,
300
926922
1168
15:28
and that's how he communicated those epic statements about space,
301
928132
4379
15:32
time and humanity to us.
302
932553
1752
15:35
At the end of the session, I said to him,
303
935514
3337
15:38
"Professor, what an honor it is for me to photograph you.
304
938893
5630
15:44
And I've seen how hard it is for you to even communicate.
305
944523
3754
15:48
But I'm going to ask for a big favor."
306
948319
2502
15:51
I said, "I want one word of wisdom from you.
307
951197
2836
15:54
One word from you,
308
954366
1627
15:55
it's going to be worth a million words from anyone else."
309
955993
2920
15:59
We all waited.
310
959580
1209
16:01
His nurse was a little concerned.
311
961123
2211
16:04
I had heard that that muscle was failing,
312
964001
2836
16:06
and most of the things he typed around this time
313
966879
2711
16:09
didn't mean anything.
314
969590
1710
16:11
Suddenly we heard, beep,
315
971884
3337
16:15
beep ... beep, beep, beep.
316
975262
2336
16:18
He was typing.
317
978432
1126
16:20
We all leaned in to the laptop screen to see where the cursor is going to go,
318
980267
4964
16:25
and he went all the way to the letter W.
319
985272
3045
16:28
And he starts the next letter,
320
988776
1960
16:30
beep, beep, beep, beep, beep.
321
990778
1710
16:32
All the way to the letter O.
322
992821
1877
16:35
And then the final letter.
323
995449
1835
16:37
Beep, beep, beep, beep, beep, beep.
324
997868
1919
16:40
All the way back to the letter W.
325
1000454
3587
16:44
Someone on the team said, "W-O-W what does that stand for?
326
1004542
4045
16:48
That's nonsense, it's a mistake."
327
1008629
1668
16:51
And I said, "Hold on a minute.
328
1011048
2085
16:53
That's not a mistake.
329
1013842
1961
16:55
He just typed the word, ‘Wow.’
330
1015803
2127
16:58
He just gave me a word my kids would use about the beauty and majesty of life.
331
1018305
4964
17:03
And isn't it amazing how the man who faces so much adversity
332
1023310
3629
17:06
still looks at the world through the eyes of wonder?"
333
1026981
3545
17:11
His nurse said, "He's exhausted.
334
1031151
2670
17:14
Let's give his eyes a rest.
335
1034238
1877
17:16
Let's take off his sensor,
336
1036115
1501
17:17
take off his glasses and replace them with his dark sunglasses."
337
1037658
4129
17:21
And then I saw it.
338
1041829
1626
17:23
A vision of a bad-ass rock star of hope.
339
1043872
3129
17:27
And I took this picture.
340
1047042
1752
17:28
This is my fitting tribute to a legend of our time,
341
1048836
3879
17:32
a man who believed that connection equals compassion.
342
1052715
4004
17:37
So I'm not going to leave you with an answer.
343
1057845
2377
17:41
I'm going to leave you with a question.
344
1061056
2336
17:44
Are we to be bystanders,
345
1064643
1710
17:46
like moths dancing around somebody else’s flame?
346
1066395
3295
17:49
Or are we to be upstanders,
347
1069732
2252
17:52
and we light darkness ourselves with our own torch of compassion?
348
1072026
3920
17:55
Because when there is light,
349
1075946
2211
17:58
we see each other not as strangers,
350
1078198
4380
18:02
not as opponents
351
1082620
1751
18:04
but as creative partners.
352
1084413
2377
18:06
And then together, we rebuild this troubled world.
353
1086832
3670
18:10
Together, we reconnect.
354
1090878
1960
18:12
Together, we earn the respect of history
355
1092838
3253
18:16
and transform this chaos into a beautiful cosmos.
356
1096133
5297
18:21
Thank you for listening to me.
357
1101430
1501
18:22
(Applause)
358
1102973
6757
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7