How "Second Chance" Laws Could Transform the US Justice System | Sheena Meade | TED

33,572 views ・ 2023-05-10

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:04
It was like any other peaceful afternoon in my home in 2004.
0
4501
5130
00:11
Cartoons were blaring,
1
11758
1710
00:13
kids were running around the house, yelling loudly,
2
13510
2627
00:16
"VeggieTales" on 100.
3
16137
2044
00:19
Well, maybe not so peaceful,
4
19015
2920
00:21
but for a young mother, it was perfect.
5
21977
2836
00:25
It was like music to my ears.
6
25230
1918
00:28
But then there was a loud knock at the door
7
28275
2002
00:30
that just disrupted that laughter.
8
30318
1961
00:32
And my kids yelled out to me, “Mommy,
9
32279
3044
00:35
The police are at the door!”
10
35323
1752
00:38
And as I walked up to talk to the police,
11
38410
2002
00:40
it's almost like I walked into the Charlie Brown movie.
12
40412
3211
00:43
Do you all remember the teacher when she just like, “Womp, womp, womp?”
13
43665
3503
00:47
Because the words were just getting lost, and I didn’t know what was going on.
14
47711
4337
00:54
And I just snapped out of it and I was like,
15
54134
2461
00:56
"Oh, shit.
16
56595
1418
00:58
I'm about to be arrested."
17
58805
1752
01:01
I was about to be arrested because two months prior
18
61099
3170
01:04
I had wrote a check for $87.26 for groceries.
19
64311
5797
01:11
And that check had bounced.
20
71067
1752
01:13
And let me be clear.
21
73528
1168
01:14
There is a thing called prosecutorial discretion,
22
74738
2544
01:17
meaning the district attorney did not have to prosecute me,
23
77324
3044
01:20
but they did.
24
80410
1251
01:23
And totally against my fashion statement, right,
25
83913
5339
01:29
the police placed
26
89252
2586
01:31
these silver bracelets on my arms.
27
91880
4963
01:36
Handcuffs.
28
96885
1126
01:39
And that day they handcuffed me in front of my babies.
29
99971
3045
01:43
And took me to jail.
30
103642
1501
01:47
You know, luckily I was able to come home pretty quickly
31
107187
2627
01:49
because it was my first offense.
32
109814
1627
01:51
And I promise, the first thing I did when I got home,
33
111483
2544
01:54
I borrowed some money so I could pay that check back.
34
114069
2877
01:56
And then I had to borrow some more money
35
116988
1919
01:58
to pay back the fees for getting arrested and going to jail
36
118907
2794
02:01
because, of course, I was loaded in cash because I was a young mom with four kids
37
121743
4046
02:05
bouncing 87-dollar checks.
38
125830
1961
02:09
And I just knew that that chapter of my life was closed.
39
129542
6298
02:17
Except it wasn't, because see, that arrest in that conviction,
40
137008
3420
02:20
it remained on my record.
41
140470
1793
02:23
And at that moment,
42
143014
1168
02:24
I realized that my true sentence had just begun,
43
144182
2628
02:26
because you know what?
44
146810
1167
02:28
I was no longer allowed to volunteer at my children’s school.
45
148019
3128
02:31
I could no longer rent where I want to rent
46
151189
2002
02:33
because it is legal for landlords to discriminate
47
153233
3628
02:36
against a person with a record.
48
156861
1544
02:38
I even faced barriers trying to go to college.
49
158405
3086
02:42
And still to this day I am excluded from certain certifications
50
162701
4879
02:47
and occupational license.
51
167580
1919
02:49
All I could keep asking myself was, "Damn,
52
169999
5089
02:55
when will my sentence end?”
53
175130
1751
02:59
And sadly, I am not alone.
54
179092
1668
03:00
There are more than 100 million Americans,
55
180802
5589
03:06
that is one in three people,
56
186391
1877
03:08
who have an arrest or conviction on their record.
57
188309
3838
03:13
And get this, more than 94 percent of employers,
58
193273
4296
03:17
more than 90 percent of landlords
59
197610
2878
03:20
and 72 percent of colleges and universities
60
200530
3420
03:23
use background checks to screen out applicants,
61
203992
3253
03:27
making it harder for millions of Americans to access jobs,
62
207287
3837
03:31
housing and education.
63
211166
2502
03:34
It's like, damn, how am I supposed to get out and do better
64
214627
3629
03:38
if no one will rent to me,
65
218298
1251
03:39
no one will hire me, and I can’t even go to school?
66
219591
2794
03:44
But I believe, I truly believe
67
224971
2002
03:47
that America is a nation of second chances.
68
227015
2753
03:49
And I say that
69
229768
1167
03:50
because just about every state has laws on the books
70
230977
2461
03:53
that allow a person to get their record cleared
71
233438
2252
03:55
once they're eligible.
72
235690
1460
03:58
And right now, there are more than 30 million people
73
238151
4379
04:02
who are eligible to get their record cleared.
74
242530
2127
04:05
But this is where it gets a little crazy.
75
245825
2127
04:08
Less than 10 percent of those people actually get it done.
76
248703
3754
04:13
Either they don’t know about it,
77
253750
2461
04:16
or, if they do, the process is so bureaucratic,
78
256211
3336
04:19
costly and full of red tape.
79
259589
1960
04:22
For instance, in some states people have to wait just about five to 10 years
80
262967
4922
04:27
just to even qualify to get their record cleared.
81
267931
2627
04:31
Then you have to appear in person to petition.
82
271893
3170
04:35
That means you need to take time off work,
83
275104
2336
04:37
and let's keep it real,
84
277440
2294
04:39
it was hard enough to find a job in the first place.
85
279734
2586
04:42
You have to file a mountain of paperwork
86
282320
2461
04:44
and then sometimes you have to pay processing fees
87
284823
2335
04:47
up to 500 dollars per charge.
88
287200
3003
04:51
And then if you're smart,
89
291329
1376
04:52
you may want to just get a lawyer to help you navigate that whole process.
90
292747
3587
04:56
So that means if your crime was being poor like mine,
91
296334
4379
05:00
record clearance is not even accessible.
92
300755
2044
05:07
I'm looking at some of your faces.
93
307220
1710
05:09
You seem really bummed out and discouraged.
94
309305
2878
05:13
But I promise I didn't come all the way to Vancouver, TED, to tell you bad news.
95
313017
3796
05:16
(Laughter)
96
316813
1376
05:18
I got some good news.
97
318231
1335
05:19
(Applause)
98
319566
2627
05:22
This record clearance problem is solvable and it's fixable
99
322193
3462
05:25
and we're doing the damn thing.
100
325655
1835
05:27
And the key is automatic record clearance for those who are eligible.
101
327532
4338
05:31
We are removing all that red tape,
102
331870
2252
05:34
and we do that by passing what we call “clean slate” laws.
103
334122
3170
05:37
And what that is, is laws that say once a person has remained crime-free
104
337667
4838
05:42
for a set period of time and they're eligible,
105
342547
2836
05:45
a set period of time by the state’s definition, remaining crime-free,
106
345425
3879
05:49
that their record is automatically cleared.
107
349304
2377
05:52
Red tape cut.
108
352223
1794
05:54
And this is the beautiful thing about it.
109
354893
2043
05:57
We shift the burden from the person who made the mistake
110
357478
3421
06:00
to the system that tries to trap them in that mistake.
111
360899
2752
06:04
(Applause)
112
364193
6215
06:10
And y'all, these policies are working.
113
370450
1960
06:12
And I know that because I am the proud CEO
114
372452
3253
06:15
of the Clean Slate Initiative.
115
375705
1460
06:17
And in just the last three years,
116
377165
1626
06:18
we've been able to help six states pass clean slate laws.
117
378791
3462
06:22
I'm talking about red states, blue states and even purple states, OK?
118
382295
5088
06:27
(Applause)
119
387383
2044
06:29
That has resulted in three million people getting their records cleared.
120
389469
5672
06:35
That's millions of people who no longer have to walk around with stigma
121
395183
3336
06:38
and shame attached to their name.
122
398561
1710
06:41
I even, one time y'all, met this older fellow.
123
401564
2878
06:44
I mean, he was in his 80s, but he was a fragile 80-year-old man.
124
404442
3295
06:48
I met him in Miami, Florida, at an expungement clinic,
125
408613
3045
06:51
and I could not fathom why this man was there.
126
411699
2670
06:55
He was there to get his record cleared.
127
415203
1877
06:57
And all I could think about was, he wasn't there to get a job,
128
417455
3587
07:01
find housing.
129
421084
1126
07:02
He didn't want to die being defined by his record.
130
422877
2377
07:07
Clean slate laws will even help people like him too.
131
427548
2628
07:10
It's like with a stroke of a governor's pen,
132
430969
2168
07:13
we were able to unlock dreams for millions.
133
433137
3379
07:19
And because it’s an Audacious Project,
134
439602
1835
07:21
we're on a pathway to make automatic record clearance a reality.
135
441479
4546
07:26
A reality in all 50 states.
136
446067
1710
07:27
We're building a pathway that automatic record clearance
137
447777
2669
07:30
is a reality in all 50 states
138
450446
1669
07:32
that will unlock second chances for additional 14 million people.
139
452156
5297
07:38
(Cheers and applause)
140
458121
6923
07:45
I just want to leave you all with this.
141
465461
1877
07:48
And I even invite some of you to close your eyes when I ask you this.
142
468506
4880
07:54
Because it's really important.
143
474220
1460
07:57
I want you to think about all the second chances that you've received.
144
477724
3461
08:03
Whether it was from your teachers,
145
483229
2961
08:06
your parents,
146
486190
1585
08:07
your community,
147
487817
2169
08:10
even your kids.
148
490028
1209
08:13
Think about what that felt like.
149
493072
1919
08:16
Think about what that did for you.
150
496451
2002
08:20
I know for me,
151
500079
2336
08:22
it enabled me to be able to change,
152
502457
2627
08:25
like turn my pain into purpose.
153
505084
2461
08:27
It enabled me to be able to walk into a room and feel seen,
154
507545
3045
08:30
not as damaged goods, but as untapped potential.
155
510590
2961
08:34
(Applause)
156
514343
2712
08:37
That is the power of a second chance.
157
517096
3253
08:41
That is the power of a clean slate.
158
521267
3086
08:45
And there's no greater gift than that.
159
525688
2044
08:47
Thank you.
160
527732
1168
08:48
(Cheers and applause)
161
528941
5798
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7