The hidden history found in your teeth | Carolyn Freiwald

82,473 views ・ 2021-03-11

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Transcriber:
0
0
7000
00:14
I want you to think about the image that you see when I say one word, Migrante.
1
14662
5584
00:22
You may have pictured a crowded boat in rough waters,
2
22788
2416
00:25
people clinging to the top of a freight train or crossing
3
25371
2667
00:28
a desert wearing worn out shoes.
4
28038
1916
00:30
This is what we see in the news cycle, 24 hours, day after day, story after story,
5
30329
5875
00:36
people who are desperate, fleeing wars, fleeing climate change, fleeing poverty.
6
36204
4125
00:41
But in reality, most people move for more common reasons to get
7
41163
4083
00:45
a good education, to find a job, to find family members or to fall in love.
8
45246
5583
00:51
And this is nothing new. Archaeologists like me have been studying migration
9
51287
5084
00:56
and finding that people for hundreds
10
56371
1916
00:58
and even thousands of years have been moving around
11
58287
2167
01:00
the globe from Europe's earliest farmers to Vikings to Pirates,
12
60454
4583
01:05
Roman gladiators and even Neanderthal cavemen and people like you and me.
13
65037
4667
01:10
Mobility is one of the things that makes us human. People move.
14
70287
3875
01:15
And we know this because of something that you brought with you here tonight.
15
75246
2875
01:18
You carry it with you to many places to work, to the gym, to bed,
16
78496
3583
01:22
and even in the shower. It's not your cell phone and it's not in your purse
17
82079
4250
01:26
or your pockets. It's you. It's your body and your bones, all 206 of them.
18
86329
4917
01:31
I brought mine and in case for some reason you didn't bring yours along,
19
91246
3250
01:34
we do have an extra one here because your bones will tell
20
94496
2958
01:37
the story of your life, even a single tooth.
21
97454
2875
01:40
And we know that teeth tell us many things for your dentist, for example.
22
100996
3833
01:44
He or she can see if you floss or if, like me,
23
104996
2583
01:47
really like candy and you might end up with some cavities.
24
107579
2709
01:50
And if my dentist is here tonight, yes, I will see you Monday.
25
110288
2750
01:53
And I've been very good. But your teeth also tell you something about migration.
26
113163
4000
01:57
If you take your tongue and run it along your incisors, these front teeth,
27
117704
4292
02:02
the back of those will be flat.
28
122329
1750
02:04
If you have European or African ancestry,
29
124204
2292
02:06
if you feel a sort of scoop or shovel shape,
30
126871
2458
02:09
your ancestors may have been Native American or migrated from Asia.
31
129579
3000
02:12
If we go inside the tooth to the pulp cavity,
32
132996
2333
02:15
we may be able to extract the DNA and see if your ancestors came from Egypt
33
135579
4084
02:19
or England or both. But we're not interested
34
139746
3208
02:22
as much in your family's migration history as yours.
35
142954
3000
02:26
And we're that's where we go to the tooth enamel,
36
146538
1916
02:28
what it's made out of to try and find out if a person moved
37
148454
2875
02:31
and even if when they moved.
38
151913
1750
02:33
And it's based on one simple idea that you are what you eat,
39
153954
3167
02:37
all the minerals and the elements in the food, like calcium, oxygen,
40
157496
3583
02:41
which is the own H2O, sodium and salt, can tell us something about your diet.
41
161079
4250
02:45
So we know if you like cornbread or white bread, if you prefer pork,
42
165329
3875
02:49
chicken, or if you really like seafood,
43
169204
2459
02:52
there are other elements that tell us where that food came from
44
172121
2500
02:54
and that includes sulfur, strontium, oxygen and even lead, which of course,
45
174788
3458
02:58
you don't want very much of.
46
178246
1250
02:59
But these tell us where the food comes from
47
179746
1917
03:01
and that can tell us where you were when you were eating it.
48
181996
2333
03:04
And that is what archaeologists use to identify ancient migration.
49
184329
3709
03:09
If we look inside the tooth enamel, we can see, for example, in your first molar,
50
189163
4333
03:14
this is the one that was forming along with your baby teeth,
51
194204
2125
03:16
but it's the only one you still have.
52
196329
1459
03:17
And that tells us where you were living as an infant.
53
197954
2542
03:20
If we look at the wisdom tooth, which is the last tooth,
54
200954
2834
03:23
the form that enamel would have been mineralized.
55
203788
2333
03:26
And just before you hit your teenage years.
56
206121
1958
03:28
So we know where you're living then. If we look at your bones.
57
208079
4209
03:33
And in that pause, you just form some new cells that's telling us what you're
58
213663
3541
03:37
eating and what you're doing and just about the past decade of life,
59
217204
3084
03:40
so we can really track where people moved.
60
220288
2708
03:43
And we've looked at this for hundreds
61
223413
2083
03:45
and thousands of individuals to identify migration in the past.
62
225496
3125
03:48
So I'd like to introduce you to some ancient migrants. If we go back in time.
63
228788
3916
03:52
Six hundred years, we can go to the city of Kapone,
64
232704
2667
03:55
where the Maya people lived in what's now Honduras.
65
235371
2167
03:58
If we came around the year 400 A.D. ,
66
238121
2125
04:00
we might have walked into broad plazas under
67
240496
1875
04:02
a really hot tropical sun that was shining onto bright red painted buildings
68
242371
3875
04:06
that had altars and carved statues in front of them.
69
246371
2208
04:08
If we'd come on the right day,
70
248996
1375
04:10
we might have seen the inauguration of ruler Kenichi Cookman roughly translated.
71
250704
4750
04:15
That means faced first MCCA.
72
255454
2042
04:17
The Maya rulers had really great names for Jaguar Dark Son, Lady, Great Skull.
73
257746
4875
04:23
But what was really neat about Yash Kumar is that he established
74
263246
4000
04:27
a dynasty that lasted for more than 400 years.
75
267246
2875
04:30
And every depiction we have of him, as you see here,
76
270454
2750
04:33
shows him in foreign clothing.
77
273704
1709
04:35
This is what people wore in central Mexico,
78
275413
1958
04:37
which was not in the Maya region and actually hundreds of miles away.
79
277663
3500
04:41
So for a long time, archaeologists thought that this was a foreign king,
80
281454
3667
04:45
but his teeth told a different story by sampling his first molar, his wisdom,
81
285704
3917
04:49
tooth and bone. We found that he, in fact,
82
289621
2542
04:52
probably came from somewhere in the Maya region.
83
292163
1875
04:54
So he was a migrant, but he may have lived in multiple places before coming to
84
294038
4041
04:58
live at Kapone, even though he dressed like he was a foreigner,
85
298079
3917
05:02
someone from Mexico. And I was think about when the Chicago Cubs were in
86
302621
3750
05:06
the World Series and people went out and bought Cubs gear,
87
306371
2208
05:08
even though maybe they'd never been to Chicago. It's a good look.
88
308579
3500
05:13
But let me take you to another Maya city. And this is where our culture continues.
89
313079
3667
05:17
In 2016, archaeologists found the largest team ever discovered in
90
317288
3541
05:20
the country in Belize. That question, Anthony Chiz.
91
320829
2584
05:23
And inside that tomb, there was the remains, the remains of a ruler,
92
323413
3541
05:27
but also gayed, the kind of plates and
93
327079
2417
05:29
the kind of vessels that you might see in a museum and Jagwar Bones,
94
329496
3125
05:32
which symbolize possibly royal power.
95
332621
2208
05:34
This person may have actually even been wearing a Jaguar pelt cape,
96
334871
3417
05:38
but she was a fairly small city.
97
338954
2167
05:41
So there was a possibility that this was a foreign ruler.
98
341121
3167
05:44
But in fact, looking at the DNA and looking at the tooth enamel,
99
344954
2875
05:48
this was no foreign king. She was a Maya queen
100
348454
3917
05:52
or some other royalty who was probably local.
101
352371
2542
05:55
We actually don't usually find foreign kings and queens.
102
355454
3292
05:59
But I told you the story was about migrants.
103
359288
1875
06:01
And it is because, in fact,
104
361163
1791
06:02
it was the commoners who moved up to 25 percent of
105
362954
3000
06:05
the population of every village and every city consisted of migrants, men,
106
365954
4042
06:09
women and children who'd moved sometimes from multiple places to live in
107
369996
3875
06:13
the same household. Migration seemed to be common among the Maya
108
373871
3500
06:17
and many ancient civilizations.
109
377371
1833
06:19
But we can move forward in time to the A14 93,
110
379704
3042
06:22
when Christopher Columbus set off on his second voyage to establish
111
382746
3167
06:25
a trading outpost, he left with 17 ships and twelve hundred men, nobility, clergy,
112
385913
5666
06:31
sailors and craftsmen to establish what we now know is like Isabella,
113
391746
4208
06:35
named after Queen Isabella in the northern part of
114
395954
2500
06:38
the Dominican Republic, or La Spagnola, as they called it then.
115
398496
3000
06:42
Things were not good, food was scarce, disease was rampant in Columbus,
116
402663
4458
06:47
may not have been the best manager, so mortality rates were high.
117
407121
3667
06:50
And by the 1980s and 90s, when archaeologists began to excavate
118
410913
3500
06:54
the settlement and then the cemetery, they started to wonder,
119
414663
2583
06:57
did the ships rosters leave?
120
417663
1541
06:59
Include everyone who is buried here who actually lived at LA Isabella.
121
419496
3958
07:04
My job came a bit later as a graduate student when
122
424621
2208
07:06
I was tasked with going around the island to try
123
426829
2250
07:09
and collect samples that could serve as proxies for human teeth,
124
429079
2875
07:12
what would the enamel look like of the people who are living at Isobella?
125
432121
3167
07:15
Someone else got to go to Spain, but I rented a car, drove around,
126
435996
3917
07:19
went into the mountains, drove toward the river valleys.
127
439913
2833
07:22
And of course, I went to a beach or two
128
442746
1500
07:24
and everything was going really well until the last day when
129
444329
2459
07:26
I came to what was supposed to be a bridge and saw a river and
130
446788
2708
07:29
a herd of cows. So it was getting dark. I was by myself. I was low on gas.
131
449496
5875
07:35
And after I saw some cowboys on the other side of
132
455913
2333
07:38
the river kind of waving their hands,
133
458246
1833
07:40
I just rolled down the window and gunned it and I made it across and I had
134
460079
4000
07:44
the samples, which was a good thing because there were some surprises.
135
464079
3167
07:47
We did find soldiers and people from Spain , probably Andalusia,
136
467579
3500
07:51
where Columbus sailed from and maybe other parts of the Mediterranean.
137
471079
3125
07:54
But we also found an indigenous Taino woman,
138
474621
2625
07:57
a local one and other women who came from Europe, and one person who,
139
477246
4917
08:02
if we can get some DNA to see if this is actually true, may have been from Africa.
140
482163
5041
08:07
None of these people were on the ships rosters.
141
487579
2250
08:10
Teeth can tell us things that the history books leave out.
142
490413
2333
08:13
Our final story brings us back closer to Mississippi to
143
493579
2709
08:16
an abandoned cemetery just west of Jackson,
144
496288
2458
08:18
where we can learn about the lives of the settlers who lived here in
145
498746
2500
08:21
the early eighteen hundreds. Now, some of them came with wealth.
146
501246
2917
08:24
They could have tombstones and write the life histories
147
504454
3042
08:27
on their graves if they were married, whether they had children,
148
507496
3375
08:31
where they came from and sometimes even how they died.
149
511288
2541
08:33
As cholera and yellow fever epidemics swept through the region,
150
513829
2584
08:37
Richards lived until age 56. He died in 1849.
151
517246
3917
08:42
Charles had a shorter life in 1855, he'd survived only to age 29.
152
522163
4916
08:48
But these men were planters,
153
528204
1250
08:49
and we know that they bought enslaved people with them. Where were they buried?
154
529454
3792
08:53
And what about the poor farmers and the sharecroppers?
155
533662
2167
08:56
There were more than 350 graves in the cemetery.
156
536121
2958
08:59
And so we decided to do our best to solve these historic forensic cases
157
539496
4291
09:03
and reconstruct the lives of the people who lived there.
158
543787
2167
09:06
And one of these people, one of the migrants,
159
546454
2125
09:08
was a man buried in Grave three. He was of African descent.
160
548787
4000
09:13
He lived in the middle, maybe even old age by the time he died in
161
553496
3083
09:16
the early 1980s. He was probably born into slavery.
162
556579
3625
09:21
And so we wonder, was he brought to Mississippi,
163
561079
1875
09:23
was he taken from his family like so many enslaved children were,
164
563496
3000
09:26
or did he come after the civil war to make a new life for himself,
165
566996
3625
09:30
refined family? He and the men with similar life histories,
166
570621
3791
09:34
migrants who are buried in Graves 18 and grave 219.
167
574412
3625
09:38
They made a good enough living that their families were able to give them nice
168
578746
3708
09:42
burials, maybe even expensive ones.
169
582454
1917
09:44
So even if we can't say their names,
170
584704
1708
09:46
we can at least tell something of their stories.
171
586496
2166
09:49
And migration is part of my story, too, my grandparents came from Germany,
172
589537
3750
09:53
my grandpa in 1923, to join his uncle and my grandma.
173
593287
4084
09:57
A few years later, we just found their travel documents and
174
597371
2791
10:00
a picture of my grandma and a lounge chair on one of
175
600162
2625
10:02
the big ships that sailed across the Atlantic.
176
602787
2042
10:05
We actually don't know exactly why they came,
177
605746
2375
10:08
but I imagine it's for the same reason that people come today to
178
608454
3083
10:11
the United States because they had a hunger and a hope,
179
611537
3000
10:14
if not to make life better for themselves, to do it for their kids.
180
614746
3583
10:19
They met in Chicago, got married and had two boys, one of those was my dad,
181
619204
4333
10:24
I'm the third generation of my family to be here and I'm also a migrant.
182
624079
4083
10:28
I've come less than 10 years ago from the Midwest to live in Mississippi.
183
628496
3333
10:32
So whether your family has an ancient migration story or whether you look in
184
632912
5334
10:38
the mirror and see yours, remember that every time you smile and show your teeth,
185
638246
4083
10:42
you're sharing that. Thank you.
186
642579
1708
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7