It’s Time To Rethink the Role of First Lady | Irina Karamanos Adrian | TED

73,517 views ・ 2023-11-10

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:04
In 2021, Gabriel Boric became the elected President of Chile.
0
4501
6173
00:11
He was one of the youngest worldwide
1
11132
3546
00:14
and one of the most voted in the country's history.
2
14719
3254
00:18
He was supported by a political party
3
18598
2920
00:21
called Convergencia Social.
4
21518
2252
00:23
And by the time of the election,
5
23812
2085
00:25
I was in charge of the feminist front of that party.
6
25939
3670
00:30
So even though I was very confident our candidate was going to win,
7
30277
5088
00:35
the night itself of the election was still very overwhelming,
8
35407
4045
00:39
especially so when we got to walk through the crowds, held by security.
9
39494
5631
00:45
You know, it suddenly all felt so real
10
45166
2253
00:47
because we were walking to a stage
11
47460
2545
00:50
in front of where thousands of people had gathered to celebrate the victory.
12
50005
4796
00:54
Because Gabriel Boric was not just a candidate I was supporting,
13
54843
3754
00:58
he was also my partner.
14
58638
1543
01:00
So soon enough,
15
60849
2461
01:03
this meant for people that I was about to become a First Lady.
16
63310
3962
01:08
And now I come to you, this great audience,
17
68189
3212
01:11
and want to ask you,
18
71443
1376
01:12
have you ever thought of becoming a First Lady?
19
72861
4254
01:17
Is it something you thought of growing up or lately, I don't know?
20
77991
4296
01:22
(Laughter)
21
82329
1126
01:23
Well, I didn't think so.
22
83997
1376
01:25
Me neither.
23
85832
1126
01:27
Until I was about to become one.
24
87000
2127
01:29
Because really, whatever your partner does, you know,
25
89919
5047
01:35
do you picture yourself getting up in the morning
26
95008
2544
01:37
and accompanying him or her to his or her job?
27
97552
3629
01:41
(Laughter)
28
101181
1626
01:42
You know?
29
102807
1168
01:44
And now picture that job being to rule over a country.
30
104309
4171
01:48
(Laughter)
31
108521
1919
01:50
But as much as it comes as a surprise to me,
32
110440
3837
01:54
imagine what a surprise it might be to the voters that don't elect you.
33
114319
6673
02:00
They elected the president, right?
34
120992
2252
02:03
And the president chose me,
35
123244
1919
02:05
but surely not thinking of me becoming an authority one day.
36
125163
4254
02:09
And so I first rejected the idea
37
129417
4546
02:13
of becoming a First Lady,
38
133963
3629
02:17
and all of, you know, what that meant.
39
137634
3712
02:22
And so, many people criticized me,
40
142263
2503
02:24
but many feminists applauded me, right.
41
144766
2628
02:27
Because, as a feminist,
42
147686
2794
02:30
I can see that feminist beliefs
43
150522
2669
02:33
seem contradictory or incompatible with being a First Lady.
44
153233
4504
02:37
On the one hand,
45
157737
1835
02:39
OK, what does a feminist possibly want to do
46
159614
4379
02:43
in such a conservative space?
47
163993
1961
02:46
But on the other hand,
48
166538
1793
02:48
ain't the pursuit of taking feminist action,
49
168373
4296
02:52
even more so in such an unlikely place,
50
172711
3420
02:56
something that is worth doing
51
176131
2711
02:58
more than caring about your coherent image as a feminist?
52
178883
4255
03:03
So I decided to meet up with former First Ladies
53
183138
3420
03:06
of the last decades
54
186558
1543
03:08
and talk to them about their achievements, about their experiences.
55
188143
3878
03:12
So I talked to them, and that was very important.
56
192063
2711
03:14
It was crucial.
57
194816
1209
03:16
And I also made meetings with feminists from different generations
58
196067
4713
03:20
to talk it all through.
59
200822
1418
03:22
But the point and the moment that really struck me
60
202866
3920
03:26
was my meetings with attorneys,
61
206828
2044
03:28
because they told me the following.
62
208913
2503
03:31
They were like, "Well, this is great for you.
63
211458
3169
03:34
You will have so many opportunities
64
214961
2669
03:37
and the chance to do whatever you want with your interests."
65
217672
4254
03:41
And I was like, this doesn't sound right.
66
221968
2336
03:44
You know, he was like, "Yes, because you can create projects,
67
224804
3462
03:48
you can create new foundations, because this is not regulated
68
228308
4171
03:52
and there are many gray zones."
69
232479
1835
03:54
(Laughter)
70
234355
3796
03:58
I realized what this construction was all about.
71
238193
3336
04:01
In Chile, First Lady's institutionalized version looks like this,
72
241529
4838
04:06
because they got progressively more and more functions, alright?
73
246367
3379
04:09
So they are anchored in the state through diverse set of things.
74
249746
6173
04:15
On the one hand,
75
255960
1168
04:17
you've got foundations, a set of foundations,
76
257170
3128
04:20
for example, for childhood education.
77
260340
2794
04:23
Then you’ve got a foundation for recycling computers.
78
263134
3379
04:26
Then you’ve got a foundation for empowering women.
79
266513
3545
04:30
Then you've got a museum with a focus on interactive approach.
80
270058
5756
04:36
Then you’ve got education and music.
81
276606
3545
04:40
But they were all formed by former First Ladies.
82
280151
3545
04:44
And you get to preside [over] all of these foundations,
83
284072
3462
04:47
regardless of your professional background.
84
287575
3087
04:50
(Laughter)
85
290662
1585
04:52
And through them, you can do your projects or make more foundations, right?
86
292247
4504
04:56
(Laughter)
87
296751
1835
04:58
And then you've got protocol, OK?
88
298586
2503
05:01
Protocol is accompanying the president
89
301130
2128
05:03
to several events, ceremonies, engagements.
90
303258
3753
05:07
And then you've got something very important.
91
307470
2795
05:10
Or at least I find it very important because it's so symbolic.
92
310265
3211
05:13
They give you an office right inside of the presidential palace.
93
313935
5130
05:19
But it's not just an office, it's the most beautiful one.
94
319107
3253
05:23
Like, people actually call it Versailles, OK?
95
323027
4088
05:27
And you get to choose a team,
96
327448
3337
05:30
which I would publicly like to thank.
97
330785
2169
05:32
And so I decided to make a plan.
98
332996
2586
05:35
And my approach would be to tackle both issues,
99
335623
3754
05:39
the democratic illegitimacy of having the institution of marriage
100
339419
4463
05:43
so embedded in state,
101
343923
2252
05:46
and on the other hand, you know --
102
346217
2044
05:48
(Laughter)
103
348303
2002
05:50
the gender-biased imaginary around this figure, OK?
104
350346
4713
05:55
But this meant making a turn again, towards action this time,
105
355518
5005
06:00
because I thought, OK, on the one hand,
106
360523
2461
06:03
if I do nothing, if I don't take the job,
107
363026
2252
06:05
nothing will change.
108
365320
1459
06:06
If I do take the job,
109
366779
2044
06:08
at least I have the chance to change something.
110
368823
3295
06:12
And we all know how traditions work.
111
372744
1835
06:14
They repeat in time until something or someone interrupts it.
112
374621
4087
06:18
So this meant making a new press conference
113
378750
3211
06:22
where I would say that I was to take office
114
382003
4922
06:26
in order to transform the figure of First Ladies.
115
386966
3754
06:31
Of course, I got criticism again,
116
391095
1961
06:33
and a lot of people actually didn't understand this.
117
393056
3086
06:36
But something a bit painful was, of course,
118
396142
2628
06:38
that many feminists criticized me too.
119
398811
2962
06:41
So in that criticism, you know, is bad press
120
401773
3336
06:45
when you come from a feminist party or a progressive party, for sure.
121
405109
4213
06:50
But while it was super uncomfortable
122
410782
3461
06:54
and I knew I was going to be,
123
414285
2044
06:56
I was very convinced that I should use my power this way.
124
416329
3629
06:59
That's what I felt, at least.
125
419999
1627
07:02
So I started presiding [over] the existing foundations.
126
422210
3879
07:06
So I wanted to know if they were still, you know,
127
426381
5088
07:11
following their social goals.
128
431469
2169
07:13
And in order to have that diagnosed,
129
433638
2961
07:16
I talked to the unions, to the workers,
130
436599
2628
07:19
I wanted to understand if they still felt valued,
131
439227
3628
07:22
if they still felt that they were taken, you know,
132
442855
3671
07:26
into account as professionals
133
446526
2252
07:28
or if, you know,
134
448778
2461
07:31
politics were making something else out of them.
135
451280
3337
07:34
And I talked to them. I improved salaries.
136
454659
3920
07:38
I, you know, I made job listings public.
137
458621
4004
07:42
We made processes more transparent.
138
462625
3253
07:45
And we also tried to make standards higher in general.
139
465878
4505
07:50
So after all of this was done,
140
470425
2836
07:53
we were ready for the next step,
141
473261
1960
07:55
which was
142
475263
1793
07:57
the First Lady not presiding over these foundations anymore.
143
477098
4588
08:01
(Laughter)
144
481728
1126
08:02
So ...
145
482895
1127
08:05
Now you've got the ministries making the decision.
146
485106
5213
08:10
So, for instance,
147
490319
1419
08:11
now that we do have a Ministry for Women and Equality,
148
491738
4004
08:15
she decides who will be the president
149
495742
3169
08:18
of the foundation about empowerment for women, right?
150
498953
2920
08:21
The Minister of Education is the one who decides
151
501914
3087
08:25
who will be the president of the foundation for childhood education.
152
505001
4671
08:29
Makes sense, right?
153
509672
2628
08:33
All these changes took about nine months.
154
513217
2920
08:36
Now I'm just me.
155
516137
1668
08:38
I have no team, no office, and no official role.
156
518389
4338
08:42
I don't take any resources from state.
157
522769
2377
08:45
And I still have a lot of public exposure,
158
525730
3795
08:49
and I would still attend meaningful events with my partner.
159
529525
3337
08:52
Which brings me to the next issue I wanted to tackle,
160
532862
5214
08:58
which is gender stereotypes, right?
161
538076
2377
09:01
Because it turns out we actually still look at masculine authorities
162
541079
5880
09:06
as people that need to be complemented by a feminine other.
163
546959
6715
09:15
But if you think about a woman
164
555760
4713
09:20
that has just been elected, or a woman in power,
165
560515
3336
09:23
we expect her to have both male and female qualities.
166
563893
4254
09:29
So this not only tells you
167
569148
3087
09:32
that relationships in such high rank,
168
572276
4880
09:37
like in a visible platform,
169
577156
3796
09:40
are expected to be heteronormative and traditional,
170
580993
4505
09:45
but it also tells you how embedded marriage is in state.
171
585540
3545
09:49
Turns out it was very normal to have the wife around.
172
589877
4630
09:55
So I thought
173
595174
1502
09:56
this kind of condescending constellation around the president
174
596717
5423
10:02
is something that will not be well-received
175
602181
3879
10:06
from the new generations of politicians.
176
606102
3962
10:10
Because if you think about it,
177
610439
1752
10:12
women accompanying presidents are still seen as assets.
178
612233
4838
10:17
They are seen as someone who gives the president an image of more stability,
179
617113
6006
10:23
of completeness and of balance.
180
623119
3253
10:27
But that is because of our accustomed view of duality.
181
627039
3629
10:31
And I think we were already past that.
182
631502
3128
10:34
I mean, church and state,
183
634672
2211
10:36
state and love,
184
636883
1710
10:38
state and marriage.
185
638634
1544
10:40
Doesn't it sound antiquated already when you say it out loud?
186
640595
2961
10:44
When it comes to women in politics,
187
644015
2043
10:46
yes, of course we want as many as possible.
188
646100
2711
10:48
But the good news is, we can vote for them, right?
189
648853
3628
10:52
(Laughter)
190
652523
1377
10:53
(Cheers and applause)
191
653941
3712
10:57
Yeah.
192
657695
1335
11:00
I say we keep marriage out of the presidential must-haves
193
660031
3628
11:03
and legitimize the person we vote for.
194
663659
3379
11:07
My goal for taking on the institutional side of First Lady was to make change.
195
667079
6715
11:15
To take away power from a position that is a result of affection
196
675046
5380
11:20
and not of democratic process.
197
680468
2419
11:23
Some people may think
198
683763
3420
11:27
that this is a personal rejection of a privilege.
199
687183
3754
11:32
Instead, it's a political rejection of power
200
692605
4630
11:37
from where it doesn't belong.
201
697235
1918
11:39
I am not to have --
202
699987
1377
11:41
(Applause)
203
701405
2086
11:43
Thank you.
204
703532
1127
11:45
I am not to have power that people have not given me.
205
705952
3420
11:50
So I see state innovations as crucial to turn the game around
206
710915
5505
11:56
when it comes to the devaluation of our democracies.
207
716420
3087
12:01
Because when you think about it,
208
721008
2086
12:03
making changes in governmental institutions,
209
723094
2961
12:06
updating them, making them more legit again,
210
726097
3086
12:09
and taking away parts
211
729225
2252
12:11
that don't represent contemporary needs anymore
212
731519
4880
12:16
might make people feel more close, more reflected
213
736440
4630
12:21
in the instrument of democracies.
214
741112
2669
12:23
And that's what it's there for.
215
743823
1626
12:26
So if making symbolic, cultural and institutional changes
216
746367
5547
12:31
increases our attachment to democratic values,
217
751956
3962
12:35
then I say it's worth a try.
218
755918
2044
12:38
Thank you very much.
219
758004
1209
12:39
(Applause)
220
759255
5589
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7