A New Understanding of Human History and the Roots of Inequality | David Wengrow | TED

388,067 views

2022-07-26 ・ TED


New videos

A New Understanding of Human History and the Roots of Inequality | David Wengrow | TED

388,067 views ・ 2022-07-26

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:04
In the summer of 2014,
0
4334
2794
00:07
I was in Iraqi Kurdistan with a small team of archaeologists,
1
7128
5798
00:12
finishing a season of field excavations near the border town of Halabja.
2
12926
5172
00:18
Our project was looking into something which has puzzled and intrigued me
3
18932
5797
00:24
ever since I began studying archeology.
4
24729
3045
00:28
We're taught to believe that thousands of years ago,
5
28233
3170
00:31
when our ancestors first invented agriculture
6
31444
3629
00:35
in that part of the world,
7
35073
1710
00:36
that it set in motion a chain of consequences
8
36783
3253
00:40
that would shape our modern world in a particular direction,
9
40078
4421
00:44
on a particular course.
10
44499
2503
00:47
By farming wheat,
11
47419
2294
00:49
our ancestors supposedly developed new attachments to the land they lived on.
12
49754
5297
00:55
Private property was invented.
13
55093
2085
00:57
And with that, the need to defend it.
14
57220
2711
01:00
Along with new opportunities for some people to accumulate surpluses,
15
60265
5339
01:05
came new labor demands,
16
65645
2169
01:07
tying most people to a hard regime of tending their crops
17
67856
5881
01:13
while a privileged few received freedom
18
73737
4004
01:17
and the leisure to do other things.
19
77741
3128
01:20
To think, to experiment,
20
80910
3003
01:23
to create the foundations of what we refer to as civilization.
21
83955
4880
01:29
Now, according to this familiar story,
22
89544
2252
01:31
what happened next is that populations boomed,
23
91838
3879
01:35
villages turned into towns, towns became cities,
24
95759
3670
01:39
and with the emergence of cities,
25
99471
2002
01:41
our species was locked on a familiar trajectory of development
26
101514
5464
01:46
where spiraling populations and technological change
27
106978
5089
01:52
were bound up with the kind of dreadful inequalities
28
112067
4546
01:56
that we see around us today.
29
116655
2627
02:01
Except, as anyone can tell you,
30
121242
2920
02:04
who's looked at the evidence from the Middle East,
31
124204
3462
02:07
almost nothing of what I've just been saying is actually true.
32
127707
5214
02:14
And the consequences I'm going to suggest
33
134756
3045
02:17
are quite profound.
34
137801
1543
02:20
Actually, what happened after the invention of agriculture
35
140428
3045
02:23
around 10,000 years ago,
36
143473
2461
02:25
is a long period of around another 4,000 years
37
145934
4004
02:29
in which villages largely remained villages.
38
149979
3504
02:33
And actually there's very little evidence for the emergence of rigid social classes,
39
153483
5839
02:39
which is not to say that nothing happened.
40
159364
2669
02:42
Over those 4,000 years,
41
162450
1543
02:44
technological change actually proceeded apace.
42
164035
4088
02:48
Without kings,
43
168623
1668
02:50
without bureaucracies, without standing armies,
44
170291
2795
02:53
these early farming populations fostered the development of mathematical knowledge,
45
173128
5422
02:58
advanced metallurgy.
46
178591
1836
03:00
They learned to cultivate olives, vines and date palms.
47
180468
4255
03:04
They invented leavened bread, beer,
48
184764
3712
03:08
and they developed textile technologies:
49
188476
2127
03:10
the potter's wheel, the sail.
50
190603
2253
03:13
And they spread all of these innovations far and wide,
51
193273
3336
03:16
from the shores of the eastern Mediterranean,
52
196609
2753
03:19
up to the Black Sea,
53
199362
1585
03:20
and from the Persian Gulf,
54
200947
2044
03:22
all the way over to the mountains of Kurdistan,
55
202991
4713
03:27
where our excavations were taking place.
56
207746
3586
03:32
I've often referred, half jokingly, to this long period of human history
57
212208
4630
03:36
as the era of the first global village.
58
216880
3628
03:40
Because it's not just the technological innovations that are so remarkable,
59
220925
4171
03:45
but also the social innovations
60
225138
1835
03:47
which enabled people to do all these things
61
227015
3003
03:50
without forming centers
62
230059
2086
03:52
and without raising up a class of permanent leaders over everybody else.
63
232145
5797
03:58
Now, oddly enough,
64
238860
1627
04:00
this efflorescence of culture is not what we usually refer to
65
240528
5714
04:06
as civilization.
66
246284
1752
04:08
Instead, that term is usually reserved for harshly unequal societies,
67
248995
6673
04:15
which came thousands of years later.
68
255668
2336
04:18
Dynastic Mesopotamia. Pharaonic Egypt.
69
258046
3420
04:21
Imperial Rome.
70
261508
1334
04:22
Societies that were deeply stratified.
71
262884
3629
04:26
So in short,
72
266930
2210
04:29
I've always felt that there was basically something very weird
73
269182
3670
04:32
about our concept of civilization,
74
272852
3170
04:36
something that leaves us lost for words, tongue tied.
75
276064
3712
04:39
When we're confronted with thousands of years of human beings,
76
279818
3420
04:43
say, practicing agriculture, creating new technologies,
77
283238
4588
04:47
but not lording it over each other
78
287826
2544
04:50
or exploiting each other to the maximum.
79
290370
3044
04:54
Why don't we have better words?
80
294207
1501
04:55
Where is our lexicon for those long expanses of human history
81
295750
4671
05:00
in which we weren't behaving that way?
82
300421
2420
05:04
Over the past ten years or more,
83
304634
1960
05:06
I worked closely together with the late,
84
306594
3504
05:10
great anthropologist David Graeber
85
310139
4046
05:14
to address some of these questions.
86
314185
2795
05:17
But we did it on a much larger scale
87
317021
1836
05:18
because from our perspective as an archaeologist and an anthropologist,
88
318857
5171
05:24
this clash between theory and data,
89
324070
3670
05:27
between the standard narrative of human history
90
327782
2586
05:30
and the evidence that we have before us today
91
330368
3045
05:33
is not just confined to the early Middle East.
92
333413
3211
05:37
It’s everything:
93
337458
1335
05:38
out whole picture of human history that we’ve been telling for centuries,
94
338835
4087
05:43
it’s basically wrong.
95
343381
1835
05:45
I'm going to try and explain a few more of the reasons why.
96
345216
4046
05:49
Let's go back to some of those core concepts,
97
349637
2836
05:52
the stable reference points around which we've been organizing
98
352515
4630
05:57
and orchestrating our understanding of world history for hundreds of years.
99
357186
5005
06:03
Take, for instance, that notion that for most of its history,
100
363026
3879
06:06
the human species lived in tiny egalitarian bands of hunter gatherers,
101
366905
5338
06:12
until the advent of agriculture ushered in a new age of inequality.
102
372285
5547
06:18
Or the notion that with the arrival of cities came social classes,
103
378875
5964
06:24
sacred kings and rapacious oligarchs trampling everyone else underfoot.
104
384881
6715
06:32
From our very first history lessons,
105
392055
2544
06:34
we're taught to believe that our modern world,
106
394641
3378
06:38
with all of its advantages and amenities,
107
398061
3295
06:41
modern health care, space travel,
108
401397
2211
06:43
all the things that are good and exciting,
109
403650
2794
06:46
couldn't possibly exist
110
406486
2169
06:48
without that original concentration of humanity
111
408655
3378
06:52
into larger and larger units
112
412033
2753
06:54
and the relentless buildup of inequalities that came with it.
113
414786
5547
07:00
Inequality, we're taught to believe,
114
420333
3920
07:04
was the necessary price of civilization.
115
424253
3838
07:09
Well, if so, then what are we to make of the early Middle East?
116
429217
3962
07:13
Perhaps one might say there was just a very, very, very long lag time,
117
433221
3754
07:17
4,000 years,
118
437016
1794
07:18
before all these developments took place.
119
438851
2086
07:20
Inequality was bound to happen, it was bound to set in.
120
440937
3003
07:24
It was just a matter of time.
121
444273
1669
07:26
And perhaps the rest of the story still works
122
446693
2877
07:29
for other parts of the world.
123
449570
1794
07:32
Well, let's think a bit about what we can actually say today
124
452532
4588
07:37
about the origin of cities.
125
457161
2127
07:40
Surely, you might think, with the appearance of cities
126
460289
3379
07:43
came the appearance of social classes.
127
463710
2961
07:46
Think about ancient Egypt with its pyramid temples.
128
466671
4713
07:51
Or Shang China with its lavish tombs.
129
471426
3753
07:55
The classic Maya with their warlike rulers.
130
475179
3212
07:59
Or the Inca empire with its mummified kings and queens.
131
479142
4045
08:03
But actually, the picture these days is not so clear.
132
483938
3003
08:06
What modern archeology tells us, for example,
133
486983
3378
08:10
is that there were already cities
134
490403
2419
08:12
on the lower reaches of the Yellow River
135
492822
2586
08:15
over 1,000 years before the rise of the Shang.
136
495408
3670
08:19
And on the other side of the Pacific,
137
499495
1961
08:21
in Peru’s Rio Supe,
138
501497
2545
08:24
we already see huge agglomerations of people
139
504083
3128
08:27
with monumental architecture 4,000 years before the Inca.
140
507253
5380
08:33
In South Asia, 4,500 years ago,
141
513926
2753
08:36
the first cities appeared at places like Mohenjo-daro
142
516721
4338
08:41
and Harappa in the Indus Valley.
143
521059
2335
08:43
But these huge settlements present no evidence of kings or queens.
144
523895
6506
08:52
No royal monuments, no aggrandizing art.
145
532487
3670
08:56
And what's more, we know that much of the population
146
536199
3670
08:59
lived in high-quality housing with excellent sanitation.
147
539911
4087
09:04
North of the Black Sea,
148
544415
2044
09:06
in the modern country of Ukraine,
149
546459
2461
09:08
archaeologists have found evidence of even more ancient cities
150
548961
3838
09:12
going back 6,000 years.
151
552840
2294
09:15
And again,
152
555635
1251
09:16
these huge settlements present no evidence
153
556928
4004
09:20
of authoritarian rule.
154
560973
3087
09:24
No temples, no palaces,
155
564560
2628
09:27
not even any evidence of central storage facilities
156
567230
2627
09:29
or top-down bureaucracy.
157
569899
2127
09:32
Actually what we see in those cases are these great concentric rings of houses
158
572944
4963
09:37
arranged rather like the inside of a tree trunk
159
577949
3128
09:41
around neighborhood assembly halls.
160
581119
2502
09:44
And it stayed that way for about 800 years.
161
584038
5297
09:51
So what this means is that long before the birth of democracy in ancient Greece,
162
591838
6214
09:58
there were already well-organized cities
163
598094
3045
10:01
on several of the world's continents
164
601139
2335
10:03
which present no evidence for ruling dynasties.
165
603474
4213
10:08
And some of them also seem to have managed perfectly well without priests,
166
608146
4963
10:13
mandarins and warrior politicians.
167
613151
2669
10:16
Of course, some early cities did go on
168
616362
2878
10:19
to become the capitals of kingdoms and empires.
169
619282
3378
10:23
But it's important to note that others went
170
623161
2252
10:25
in completely the opposite direction.
171
625454
2962
10:29
To take one well-documented example,
172
629584
2419
10:32
around the year 250 AD,
173
632003
3545
10:35
the city of Teotihuacan, in the valley of Mexico,
174
635590
4087
10:39
with a population of around 100,000 people,
175
639719
3837
10:43
turned its back on pyramid temples and human sacrifices
176
643598
5130
10:48
and reconstituted itself
177
648728
2919
10:51
as a vast collection of comfortable villas housing most of the city's population.
178
651689
6924
10:59
When archaeologists first investigated these buildings,
179
659488
3963
11:03
they assumed they were palaces.
180
663492
1836
11:05
Then they realized that just about everyone in the city
181
665328
3253
11:08
was living in a palace with spacious patios
182
668623
3253
11:11
and subfloor drainages,
183
671876
1668
11:13
gorgeous murals on the walls.
184
673586
2502
11:16
But we shouldn't get carried away.
185
676631
1960
11:19
None of the societies that I've been describing
186
679383
3003
11:22
was perfectly egalitarian.
187
682428
3003
11:26
But then we might also remember that fifth-century Athens,
188
686641
3753
11:30
which we look to as the birthplace of democracy,
189
690394
3379
11:33
was also a militaristic society founded on chattel slavery,
190
693773
6631
11:40
where women were completely excluded from politics.
191
700404
4129
11:45
So maybe by comparison,
192
705368
1293
11:46
somewhere like Teotihuacan was not doing so badly
193
706702
3170
11:49
at keeping the genie of inequality in its bottle.
194
709872
4004
11:53
But maybe we can just forget about all that, we can look away.
195
713918
2961
11:56
Perhaps all of these things I'm talking about are basically outliers.
196
716879
4755
12:03
Maybe we can still keep our familiar story of civilization intact.
197
723052
4463
12:08
And after all,
198
728933
1209
12:10
if cities without rulers were really such a common thing in human history,
199
730142
6048
12:16
why didn't Cortéz and Pizarro and all the other conquistadors
200
736190
4922
12:21
find any when they began their invasion of the Americas?
201
741153
3504
12:24
Why did they find only Moctezuma and Atahualpa
202
744699
4337
12:29
lording it over their empires?
203
749078
2085
12:32
Except that's not true either.
204
752498
2085
12:35
Actually, the city where Hernan Cortéz found his military allies,
205
755042
4546
12:39
the ones who enabled his successful assault
206
759588
2837
12:42
on the Aztec capital of Tenochtitlán,
207
762466
3504
12:45
was exactly one such city without rulers:
208
765970
4421
12:50
an indigenous republic by the name of Tlaxcala,
209
770975
4338
12:55
governed by an urban parliament,
210
775354
2169
12:57
which had some pretty interesting initiation rituals
211
777565
3086
13:00
for would-be politicians.
212
780693
1585
13:02
They'd be periodically whipped
213
782320
1960
13:04
and subject to public abuse by their constituents
214
784322
3420
13:07
to sort of break down their egos and remind them who's really in charge.
215
787742
6840
13:14
It's a little bit different from what we expect of our politicians today.
216
794999
4338
13:19
And archaeologists, by the way, have also worked at this place Tlaxcala,
217
799337
4546
13:23
excavating the remains of the pre-conquest city,
218
803924
3045
13:27
and what they found there is really remarkable.
219
807011
2210
13:29
Again, the most impressive architecture is not temples and palaces.
220
809263
4546
13:33
It's just the well-appointed residences of ordinary citizens
221
813809
4046
13:37
arrayed along these grand terraces overlooking district plazas.
222
817855
6298
13:44
And it's not just the history of cities
223
824820
2503
13:47
that modern archaeological science is turning on its head.
224
827365
4671
13:52
We also know now that the history of human societies
225
832995
2795
13:55
before the coming of agriculture
226
835831
1794
13:57
is just nothing like what we once imagined.
227
837666
2753
14:01
Far from this idea of people living all the time
228
841337
2586
14:03
in tiny bands of hunter-gatherers,
229
843964
2044
14:06
actually, what we see these days
230
846050
1835
14:07
is evidence for a really wild variety of social experimentation
231
847885
5547
14:13
before the coming of farming.
232
853474
1919
14:15
In Africa,
233
855393
1251
14:16
50,000 years ago,
234
856644
2210
14:18
hunter-gatherers were already creating huge networks,
235
858854
4421
14:23
social networks, covering large parts of the continent.
236
863317
3212
14:26
In Ice Age Europe, 25,000 years ago,
237
866946
3211
14:30
we see evidence of individuals singled out for special grand burials,
238
870199
6048
14:36
their bodies suffused with ornamentation,
239
876247
3295
14:39
weapons and even what looked like regalia.
240
879542
2961
14:42
We see public buildings constructed on the bones and tusks of woolly mammoth.
241
882503
5714
14:49
And around 11,000 years ago,
242
889051
2878
14:51
back in the Middle East, where I started,
243
891929
2836
14:54
hunter-gatherers constructed enormous stone temples
244
894807
5047
14:59
at a place called Göbekli Tepe in eastern Turkey.
245
899854
4337
15:05
In North America,
246
905234
1752
15:07
long before the coming of maize farming,
247
907027
2294
15:09
indigenous populations created the massive earthworks of poverty point
248
909363
4630
15:14
in Louisiana,
249
914034
1419
15:15
capable of hosting hunter gatherer publics in their thousands.
250
915494
3921
15:19
And then Japan, again, long before the arrival of rice farming,
251
919457
4295
15:23
the storehouses of Sannai Maruyama could already hold great surpluses
252
923794
5297
15:29
of wild plant foods.
253
929133
1835
15:30
Now what do all these details amount to?
254
930968
2753
15:33
What does it all mean?
255
933762
1836
15:35
Well, at the very least, I'd suggest
256
935639
2336
15:38
it's really a bit far-fetched these days to cling to this notion
257
938017
5297
15:43
that the invention of agriculture meant a departure from some egalitarian Eden.
258
943355
6882
15:50
Or to cling to the idea that small-scale societies
259
950863
3712
15:54
are especially likely to be egalitarian,
260
954617
2669
15:57
while large-scale ones must necessarily have kings,
261
957328
4171
16:01
presidents and top-down structures of management.
262
961540
2461
16:05
And there are also some contemporary implications.
263
965127
2795
16:07
Take, for example, the commonplace notion
264
967963
2836
16:10
that participatory democracy is somehow natural in a small community.
265
970799
5464
16:16
Or perhaps an activist group,
266
976597
2085
16:18
but couldn't possibly have a scale up for anything like a city,
267
978682
5089
16:23
a nation or even a region.
268
983812
2128
16:26
Well, actually, the evidence of human history,
269
986732
2461
16:29
if we're prepared to look at it,
270
989193
2169
16:31
suggests the opposite.
271
991362
1668
16:33
If cities and regional confederacies,
272
993948
2961
16:36
held together mostly by consensus and cooperation
273
996951
4546
16:41
existed thousands of years ago,
274
1001539
3336
16:44
who's to stop us creating them again today
275
1004875
4046
16:48
with technologies that allow us to overcome the friction
276
1008921
4046
16:52
of distance and numbers?
277
1012967
2460
16:56
Perhaps it's not too late to begin learning from all this new evidence
278
1016053
6089
17:02
of the human past,
279
1022142
1627
17:04
even to begin imagining
280
1024144
2002
17:06
what other kinds of civilization we might create
281
1026188
4254
17:10
if we can just stop telling ourselves
282
1030442
4463
17:14
that this particular world is the only one possible.
283
1034947
5088
17:21
Thank you very much.
284
1041328
1168
17:22
(Applause)
285
1042538
5130
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7