Past Simple or Present Perfect?

935,753 views ・ 2011-10-22

Learn English with Rebecca


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:03
Hi, my name is Rebecca and in today's lesson
0
3620
3200
00:06
We're going to talk about a common error made by students when they use two tenses in English
1
6820
6779
00:14
These are the past simple and the present perfect
2
14179
3410
00:18
Now in case you're not sure exactly what those are let's review, and then I'm going to point out
3
18349
5780
00:24
What's the mistake that students often make when they start using these two tenses. All right?
4
24440
6480
00:31
So let's look at the board
5
31100
2000
00:33
So let's think first about time
6
33140
2659
00:36
We can divide time into two categories
7
36649
3139
00:40
Time which is finished and over and time which is unfinished. What do I mean by that?
8
40760
7069
00:48
Time which is finished is easier to understand. It's things like
9
48640
4620
00:53
yesterday last week, last year
10
53800
3240
00:57
and so on right. It's over. It's fairly finished
11
57040
2720
00:59
Unfinished time could be for example today
12
59760
3380
01:05
Today is still going on. It's not over this year is
13
65320
5480
01:11
Still going on. It's unfinished
14
71329
2450
01:14
So what you have to keep in mind is that when we are talking about finished times?
15
74600
6979
01:22
we need to use the past simple and
16
82700
2720
01:26
when we are talking about
17
86149
1891
01:28
unfinished times
18
88040
1350
01:29
We should use present perfect
19
89390
2180
01:32
Let's look at an example. So you understand more specifically, okay?
20
92119
4069
01:37
Let's take this sentence. I worked hard
21
97250
2750
01:41
yesterday
22
101030
1350
01:42
That would be fine to say because yes finish time or I could say I worked hard last week
23
102380
6930
01:50
also finished
24
110220
1740
01:51
I could say I worked hard last month right those are all correct because we're using the past simple and
25
111960
7729
02:00
we're using a finished time with them which would be correct
26
120090
4909
02:05
we can also say if we're talking about
27
125610
2900
02:09
present and present perfect, we could say I have worked hard, right?
28
129119
4790
02:13
I have worked hard. Which is the present simple.
29
133910
3839
02:19
This week I have worked hard this week
30
139020
3139
02:22
Now I'm using an unfinished time because the week is not over so it's unfinished
31
142680
5869
02:28
I have worked hard this semester
32
148550
2849
02:32
Let's say you're in university, right ?
33
152070
2660
02:35
I have worked hard since
34
155550
2089
02:38
January
35
158280
1080
02:39
Since January means from January till now and including now
36
159360
5930
02:45
so it's an unfinished time right so we can use this with present perfect or
37
165780
5360
02:51
I have worked hard since 6:00 a.m.
38
171840
3110
02:55
Since 6 o'clock this morning right and now it's still today, so it's an unfinished time all right
39
175680
7340
03:03
So this is what you need to keep in mind regarding
40
183180
2600
03:06
Time and it's one small way in which you can
41
186420
3500
03:10
Know whether to use past simple or the to use present perfect. The most common error is that?
42
190590
6950
03:18
When students learn the present perfect they sometimes like it a lot and they want to start using it
43
198090
7130
03:25
But then they use it with a time which is finished
44
205320
5000
03:30
so if we look at the example here of Niagara Falls the
45
210320
4440
03:35
correct example would be I visited Niagara Falls on
46
215340
4160
03:40
Saturday let's say today day is Sunday or Monday so at Saturday in the past. It's over. It's finished
47
220020
7780
03:48
So I could say I visited Niagara falls on set for I visited Niagara falls last summer
48
228380
7180
03:55
Right last weekend anything like that
49
235800
2880
04:00
Or if I want to talk about, Niagara falls here
50
240030
3229
04:03
I could say I have visited Niagara falls many times in my life
51
243260
5610
04:09
now presumably
52
249390
2000
04:12
My life is unfinished right now. I'm still alive
53
252000
3679
04:15
So we're talking about an unfinished time, so you could say I have visited Niagara falls many times in my life
54
255810
7850
04:24
So that would also be correct what happens is that sometimes students start to say I have visited, Niagara Falls
55
264300
7429
04:32
last Saturday
56
272699
1741
04:34
or I have visited Niagara falls last summer that would be wrong because you're
57
274440
6320
04:41
mixing present perfect with the finished and that's
58
281220
4639
04:46
The mistake that we want to avoid okay, if you'd like some more practice on this please feel free to visit our website
59
286650
7040
04:54
www.engvid.com
60
294000
3600
04:57
you'll see a quiz there, and that will help you to master this little point that might cause you some problems in English
61
297810
7279
05:05
Okay, all the best with your English bye for now
62
305250
2839
05:18
63
318240
2000

Original video on YouTube.com
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7