Conversational English - What are Embedded Questions?

419,759 views ・ 2012-10-17

Learn English with Rebecca


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:03
Hi. My name is Rebecca, and in today's lesson, we're going to talk about something called:
0
3078
5021
00:08
"Embedded Questions". Okay? Now, many English learners have a difficult time when they're
1
8099
6981
00:15
framing questions, because you have to change the word order. But embedded questions actually
2
15080
6614
00:21
require you to change the order back again, so they can be even more confusing, unless
3
21720
5940
00:27
you understand the principle. So, please make sure you pay attention to this one. A lot
4
27660
5180
00:32
of English students don't recognize that they're making a mistake because they've taken so
5
32840
4769
00:37
much trouble to learn the regular way of asking questions, that they don't realize that when
6
37609
5980
00:43
you have an embedded question, you need to change that order all over again. Okay?
7
43589
5230
00:48
So, what is an embedded question? An embedded question is not a question that you ask somebody
8
48819
5531
00:54
in bed. An embedded question is a question that is found inside another question, or
9
54350
7273
01:01
inside a sentence or statement. All right? So that's enough theory for now. Let's look
10
61649
6191
01:07
at the actual reality.
11
67840
2069
01:10
Okay, so let's take this regular question: "Where is the bank?" Right? You see I've written
12
70053
7121
01:17
the verb, "is" in red, and that's the regular way you would ask the question. You would
13
77200
6129
01:23
take the sentence, "The bank is somewhere", and say: "Where is the bank?"
14
83329
4731
01:28
However, when you add something like this before that, then the order at the end is
15
88060
7953
01:36
going to change. Let me show you what I mean. "Where is the bank?" Or: "Can you tell me
16
96039
7695
01:43
where the bank is?" That's the correct way to ask this question. We do not say:
17
103760
9077
01:52
"Can you tell me where was", or: "where is the bank?" All right? The original question by
18
112863
7237
02:00
itself if you ask it is: "Where is the bank?" But if you add something before it, like:
19
120100
6659
02:06
"Can you tell me", or: "Do you know", or: "Could you tell me", "Would you know", "Would
20
126759
7895
02:14
you happen to know", right? If you add one of these expressions before the rest of the
21
134680
5835
02:20
question, then the order changes back.
22
140541
3269
02:23
So, for example, you would say: "Do you know where the bank is?",
23
143836
4772
02:28
"Could you tell me where the bank is?",
24
148796
2964
02:31
"Would you happen to know where the bank is?" All right? So instead of saying:
25
151786
5715
02:37
"Where is the bank?" You say: "Where the bank is", if you have one of these expressions
26
157527
7223
02:44
before that. If you don't, then you stay with the regular question format.
27
164750
5220
02:49
Let's take another example. "Who was that man?" Okay? If you're only asking that much,
28
169970
7334
02:57
then that's fine. "Who was that man?" But if you're going to add one of these expressions
29
177330
5989
03:03
before, then we cannot say: "Would you know who was that man?" No. That's wrong. You would
30
183319
8215
03:11
need to say: "Would you know who that man was?" Okay? I know it seems a little bit confusing
31
191560
7674
03:19
if you haven't come across this before, but believe me, it's right. A lot of my students
32
199260
4336
03:23
ask me: "Are you sure?" Yes, I am sure.
33
203622
3531
03:27
So, let's look at it again. Now, one point, this happens not only when we add question
34
207179
8144
03:35
tags like this-okay?-but also in sentences. An embedded question can be in a sentence.
35
215349
7601
03:42
For example, you could say: "I know where the bank is." Or: "I don't know where the
36
222976
7508
03:50
bank is." We do not say: "I don't know where is the bank.
37
230517
5836
03:56
" You say: "I don't know where the bank is."
38
236379
3989
04:00
Or: "I don't remember who that man was." Okay? Or: "Would you know who that man was?"
39
240493
9450
04:09
You see what's happening? The order is changing. All right?
40
249969
4731
04:14
Now, let's take a couple of examples so that you can practice. Okay? I'm going to ask you
41
254700
4599
04:19
a question in the regular format, and you practice in your mind or wherever you are,
42
259299
5565
04:24
changing it to the way it should be because it's an embedded question. So let's take the
43
264890
4840
04:29
regular question: "How much was that cellphone?" Okay? "How much was that cellphone?" So now,
44
269730
8114
04:37
if we make it into an embedded question:
45
277870
2685
04:41
"Could you tell me how much the cellphone was?" Right?
46
281227
9775
04:51
"Could you tell me how much the cellphone was?"
47
291142
3977
04:55
Let's take another question. "How old is he?" That's a regular question. "How old is he?"
48
295145
8099
05:04
If you ask it as an embedded question, you could say:
49
304569
2933
05:07
"Would you happen to know how old he is?"
50
307528
5176
05:12
Not: "How old is he?" But: "Would you happen to know how old he is?" Okay?
51
312891
7444
05:20
One more practice question. "What time is the flight?" All right? By itself, that's
52
320506
6284
05:26
a regular question. "What time is the flight?" Or you could say:
53
326790
5234
05:32
"Do you know what time the flight is?" Okay?
54
332050
7574
05:40
Don't worry if you're feeling a little bit confused; it is a kind of a different kind
55
340015
4235
05:44
of concept to get your mind to wrap around, but you can do it. And I do recommend that
56
344250
6270
05:50
you practice that a lot. And if you go to our website you can find a quiz on this, www.engvid.com.
57
350520
10487
06:01
You'll see a quiz on this, you'll also find videos on various other topics in English.
58
361033
5237
06:06
Okay? So good luck with your English. I'm sure you can do it. All the best.
59
366296
5348
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7