Are trees intelligent? 6 Minute English

107,173 views ・ 2020-12-17

BBC Learning English


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:07
Hello. This is 6 Minute English from BBC Learning English. I’m Neil.
0
7566
3865
00:11
And I’m Georgina.
1
11431
1190
00:12
How did you spend your free time during the weeks
2
12621
2307
00:14
of lockdown, Georgina? Repainting the living room?
3
14928
2813
00:17
Or doing exercise classes in the kitchen?
4
17741
2704
00:20
Actually, Neil, I’ve been doing some online research
5
20445
2606
00:23
into my family history.
6
23051
1556
00:24
I’m investigating my family tree – you know,
7
24740
2917
00:27
a drawing showing all the relationships between the
8
27657
2666
00:30
different members of my family.
9
30323
1630
00:31
Ah, how interesting!
10
31953
1379
00:33
And how appropriate - because trees are the subject of this programme –
11
33332
4094
00:37
not family trees but real, living-in-the-forest trees.
12
37426
3815
00:41
Well, Neil, this might surprise you but according to some people,
13
41241
3627
00:44
trees also have families.
14
44868
2266
00:47
There are mother trees who support and help feed child trees.
15
47252
3813
00:51
That’s right. According to Suzanne Simard,
16
51169
2541
00:53
one of the world’s leading tree researchers,
17
53710
2355
00:56
trees should be seen as intelligent.
18
56065
2414
00:58
They communicate with each other. They help each other.
19
58479
2710
01:01
And as you mentioned, Georgina, they can even tell their family members.
20
61381
4070
01:05
So a tree can have its own family tree – amazing! Tell me more.
21
65525
4434
01:09
OK, Georgina, but first let me ask you my quiz question.
22
69959
3509
01:13
The largest trees in a wood or forest are called ‘mother trees’.
23
73586
4286
01:18
As they’re the biggest, mother trees usually have the longest,
24
78138
3361
01:21
most connected roots.
25
81499
1491
01:23
So my question is this – what is the world’s largest currently living tree?
26
83108
5860
01:28
Is it: a) a baobab tree?, b) a giant redwood tree?,
27
88968
5558
01:34
or, c) a sequoia tree?
28
94526
3073
01:37
Hmmm… I’ve seen photos of redwood trees in California and
29
97599
3877
01:41
they’re huge, so I’ll say b) a giant redwood.
30
101476
3302
01:44
OK Georgina, I’m sure you only chose that cause it’s
31
104778
2444
01:47
the easiest one to pronounce but we’ll find out the answer at
32
107222
2947
01:50
the end of the programme.
33
110169
1231
01:51
Now let’s get back to that tree researcher, Suzanne Simard.
34
111400
3894
01:55
Her big idea was the ‘wood wide web’ –
35
115294
2837
01:58
a way of describing the network of underground roots
36
118131
2977
02:01
linking trees to other trees of the same family.
37
121108
2852
02:03
Here’s Suzanne explaining more about tree families
38
123960
2689
02:06
to BBC World Service programme, The Big Idea:
39
126649
2961
02:09
We found that the parent trees would favour
40
129610
3553
02:13
those seedlings that were of their own kin versus the strangers.
41
133163
3154
02:16
That’s extraordinary – and when you say they favour their own
42
136317
2739
02:19
family members, you mean they’ll send more nutrients to
43
139056
3775
02:22
their offspring than they would to, as it were, a stranger tree?
44
142831
4071
02:27
That’s right.
45
147287
751
02:28
Mother trees send food and nutrients to their own seedlings –
46
148112
3932
02:32
young plants that have been grown from a seed.
47
152044
2562
02:34
In this way, parent trees help their offspring –
48
154606
2949
02:37
another word for their children, or young.
49
157555
2429
02:40
Mother trees can recognise and feed other trees of their own kin –
50
160161
3872
02:44
an old fashioned word meaning family.
51
164033
2000
02:46
With the extra nutrients and carbon they receive,
52
166033
3050
02:49
the offspring can extend their own root network
53
169083
3250
02:52
and suck up even more nutrients…
54
172333
2311
02:54
…which in turn increases their own growth,
55
174644
2606
02:57
turning some of them into the giants we see growing in
56
177442
3242
03:00
California and other parts of the world.
57
180684
1675
03:02
Amazing! With trees behaving in clever ways like this
58
182359
3435
03:05
it’s no wonder Suzanne thinks they have intelligence.
59
185794
3494
03:09
And that’s not all.
60
189288
950
03:10
Listen again as Suzanne discusses the question of
61
190238
2532
03:12
whether trees are ‘alive’ with BBC World Service’s, The Big Idea.
62
192770
4263
03:17
See if you can hear her opinion.
63
197033
1778
03:18
Alive in the sense of having agency in their destinies,
64
198811
3976
03:22
instead of being you know… I think a lot of people think of trees as
65
202787
3094
03:25
just sort of like these sticks that grow out of the ground,
66
205881
2799
03:28
they’re kind of these inert things that don’t have agency in their destiny,
67
208680
4174
03:32
that they don’t change behaviours and make decisions
68
212854
2858
03:35
but what we’re finding is that they do all that.
69
215712
3288
03:39
And you know what step back and think trees have evolved over
70
219000
4301
03:43
a long long long time, way longer than human beings and they've evolved
71
223301
3849
03:47
in communities and they have to grow and survive.
72
227150
3315
03:50
I think Suzanne believes trees are alive and intelligent,
73
230583
3612
03:54
because she says they have agency –
74
234195
2621
03:56
a concept meaning having the ability to act and effect your environment.
75
236816
4485
04:01
Dying trees even seem to know the future – before they die,
76
241301
3931
04:05
they warn their offspring to start making new root connections.
77
245232
3350
04:08
Showing that trees have some understanding of their destiny –
78
248582
3760
04:12
everything that happens in someone’s life and what will happen in the future.
79
252342
3982
04:16
So it seems that trees are much more intelligent
80
256324
2586
04:18
than we thought, Georgina.
81
258910
1172
04:20
It’s certainly going to change how I feel about going for a walk
82
260082
3257
04:23
in the woods, surrounded by all those intelligent trees
83
263339
3458
04:26
chatting to each other.
84
266797
1379
04:28
I wonder if they have family arguments.
85
268176
2112
04:30
Ha. Well, I wouldn’t argue with one of those really gigantic trees,
86
270288
3916
04:34
such as… well, Georgina, you tell me.
87
274204
2917
04:37
Ah, you mean your quiz question - about the largest living tree?
88
277121
4567
04:41
Exactly. What did you say?
89
281688
1594
04:43
I said the largest currently living tree was,
90
283282
2644
04:45
b) a giant redwood. Was I correct, Neil?
91
285926
3162
04:49
Well, you got the ‘giant’ part right, Georgina,
92
289088
2851
04:51
but in fact the answer was c) a giant sequoia named General Sherman.
93
291939
4818
04:56
He lives in California’s Giant Forest,
94
296757
3020
04:59
he’s a whopping 83 metres tall and measures a massive
95
299777
3864
05:03
33 metres around the trunk!
96
303641
1905
05:05
Wow! And I bet he has a huge family tree!
97
305546
3059
05:08
Ha-ha. Right then, Georgina, let’s recap the vocabulary we’ve
98
308605
3961
05:12
used discussing intelligent trees, starting with family tree –
99
312566
4041
05:16
a diagram showing the relationships between family members.
100
316607
3701
05:20
Trees are intelligent enough to communicate with their children,
101
320308
3414
05:23
or offspring.
102
323722
1512
05:25
These young plants which have grown from seeds are also known as seedlings.
103
325234
4292
05:29
Another word we learned is kin – an old-fashioned way of saying family
104
329526
4115
05:33
According to tree expert Suzanne Simard, trees have agency –
105
333641
4248
05:37
a term describing the ability to act and influence your surroundings.
106
337889
4455
05:42
And the fact that trees make all kinds of decisions about
107
342344
2787
05:45
their lives suggests they understand their destiny -
108
345131
2976
05:48
everything that happens to someone during their life,
109
348107
2497
05:50
including in the future.
110
350604
1373
05:51
Thank you for joining our walk through the woods of English vocabulary.
111
351977
3390
05:55
Remember you can find more topical discussion on our website…
112
355456
3414
05:58
…as well as a whole forest of English language resources at
113
358870
3399
06:02
bblearningenglish.com.
114
362269
1728
06:03
Goodbye for now.
115
363997
1003
06:05
Bye!
116
365000
500
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7