What They Really Mean: Suggestions as instructions

33,666 views ・ 2018-04-06

BBC Learning English


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:04
Emily: It looks a bit complex,
0
4000
2980
00:06
you could take some out
1
6980
1400
00:09
Claire: "You could..."
2
9000
1260
00:10
that sounds like a suggestion.
3
10740
1980
00:13
Well, let's see if that's what Emily meant.
4
13620
2420
00:18
Emily: Have you finished that app design?
5
18980
1260
00:21
Mark: I've just been putting some more features in it
6
21120
2260
00:23
It's got 200 now.
7
23380
2000
00:25
Emily: Hmmm. It looks a bit complex.
8
25680
2960
00:28
You could take some out.
9
28640
2000
00:31
Mark: I suppose but...
10
31040
2200
00:33
I quite like it like this.
11
33860
1380
00:36
Emily: If you'd like to ask the team
12
36600
1360
00:37
they might be able to help..
13
37960
1520
00:40
Mark: I'm not really sure I would like to
14
40900
1280
00:42
ask them to be honest.
15
42180
920
00:44
Emily: You might want to look at it again
16
44740
1700
00:46
before we show the director.
17
46440
1720
00:51
Emily: Ok, are you ready
18
51100
1440
00:52
to show it to the director?
19
52540
940
00:53
Did you take out some of the features like I asked?
20
53980
1960
00:57
Mark: No actually. I've put a few more in there.
21
57020
2160
00:59
It's got 250 now.
22
59380
1460
01:01
Emily: Weren't you listening?
23
61400
1820
01:03
Didn't I tell you to make it simpler?
24
63220
2260
01:07
Mark: You said I could. But I didn't want to,
25
67060
3020
01:10
so I didn't.
26
70080
580
01:10
Emily: The director's just going to laugh at this.
27
70660
1920
01:12
I know this business.
28
72780
1800
01:14
You really need to listen to me.
29
74740
2120
01:16
Mark: But...
30
76880
1120
01:22
Claire: Ouch, you don't look happy.
31
82440
2920
01:25
Mark: I just don't get it.
32
85360
2020
01:27
Emily made some suggestions,
33
87380
1760
01:29
and fine, I didn't agree with them,
34
89140
2000
01:31
but now she's acting as though they were orders.
35
91620
2020
01:34
Claire: Ah, well you see...
36
94220
1640
01:36
Sometimes we word things as suggestions,
37
96060
2720
01:38
when we mean them as instructions.
38
98780
2140
01:41
It's a way of being polite.
39
101420
1660
01:43
It can be tricky to spot these instructions.
40
103320
3320
01:47
The expressions that Emily used all had modal verbs
41
107280
3640
01:51
that we usually use for suggestions.
42
111280
2360
01:54
We had could, if you'd like to,
43
114380
2080
01:57
and you might want to.
44
117220
2340
01:59
What you have to do is think about the context.
45
119920
2440
02:03
If it's someone who often gives you instructions
46
123260
2180
02:05
like your manager,
47
125440
1540
02:07
then you might want to double check
48
127260
1420
02:08
whether they are just making suggestions
49
128960
2180
02:11
or actually telling you what they want you to do.
50
131660
3079
02:16
They are quite common in a lot of work situations
51
136580
3100
02:20
and you'll see some more
52
140180
1940
02:22
at the end of the programme.
53
142120
1320
02:23
Mark: Thanks, I feel as though I want to go back
54
143540
2540
02:26
and try that again with Emily.
55
146080
1700
02:29
Mark: I've just been putting some more features
56
149700
2160
02:31
on that app.
57
151860
1020
02:32
It's got 200 now.
58
152880
1960
02:35
Emily: Hmmm. It looks a bit complex
59
155060
3240
02:38
you could take some out.
60
158300
1180
02:41
Mark: Now, you said could.
61
161060
2120
02:43
Do I have a choice or do you need me to do that?
62
163180
3420
02:46
Emily: Good questions
63
166600
1940
02:48
I need you to do that.
64
168540
2040
02:50
If you'd like you could ask the team,
65
170580
1460
02:52
they can help you.
66
172140
1040
02:53
Mark: If I'd like to?
67
173180
1630
02:54
Emily: I did it again didn't I?
68
174810
3110
02:57
Yes, I need you to do that as well.
69
177920
2840
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7