What They Really Mean: Questions as Warnings

38,338 views ・ 2018-03-30

BBC Learning English


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Sometimes the things people say
0
840
2520
00:03
don't mean what we think they do.
1
3360
2220
00:05
and that can lead to misunderstandings.
2
5580
2660
00:08
Thinking about context is essential
3
8240
2440
00:10
if you want to understand what people really mean.
4
10680
2940
00:16
Mark's not very good at this,
5
16100
1800
00:17
but luckily I'm here to help him
6
17900
1980
00:19
work out what people really mean.
7
19880
3440
00:29
Chloe: Are you really wearing that hat?
8
29320
2340
00:31
Claire: Of course Mark is wearing that hat,
9
31760
2380
00:34
it's on his head.
10
34200
1700
00:36
So why is Chloe asking
11
36200
1540
00:37
him that question.
12
37740
1740
00:39
Any ideas?
13
39480
1800
00:41
Let's watch and find out.
14
41340
1440
00:44
Mark: Well, I'll be off to Dave's party.
15
44840
1880
00:47
Chloe: Oh right.... Where did you get that hat?
16
47620
3640
00:51
Mark: I just picked it up down the market.
17
51260
2660
00:54
Chloe: Have you looked in the mirror?
18
54340
1740
00:56
Mark: Well, of course
19
56200
2380
00:58
it means that I can really admire my new hat.
20
58580
2180
01:01
Chloe: Are you really wearing that hat?
21
61220
2200
01:03
Mark: Well...
22
63740
1060
01:05
it's on my head isn't it?
23
65020
1860
01:06
So yes, I am wearing this hat.
24
66880
3540
01:10
Well, I'm off to the party.
25
70520
1680
01:15
Chloe: What's up?
26
75880
1000
01:17
Mark: Everyone was laughing at my hat.
27
77140
1920
01:19
They said it looked ridiculous.
28
79500
1140
01:21
Why didn't you tell me?
29
81560
1099
01:23
Chloe: But, I tried.
30
83160
1000
01:25
You did?
31
85320
1460
01:27
I don't understand.
32
87280
2000
01:31
Mark: I don't understand.
33
91620
1420
01:33
Chloe said that she tried to warn me,
34
93360
2460
01:35
but all she did was just ask me some questions.
35
95920
2640
01:38
Claire: No, Chloe did...
36
98560
2800
01:41
those questions she asked...
37
101480
1760
01:43
they weren't really questions.
38
103240
2180
01:46
Mark: What do you mean?
39
106260
760
01:47
Claire: These were questions used as warnings.
40
107800
3460
01:51
Chloe wasn't looking for an answer.
41
111260
2280
01:53
In fact, the answers were obvious.
42
113740
2240
01:56
She knew that he was wearing that hat,
43
116420
2460
01:58
she could see that he was looking in the mirror.
44
118880
2560
02:03
She was just trying to draw his attention
45
123100
3420
02:06
to the hat...
46
126520
1860
02:08
and it's a lot politer than saying
47
128580
2240
02:11
take off that hat, it's ridiculous!
48
131720
3600
02:16
Now, these questions are written in the same way
49
136280
3460
02:19
as normal questions,
50
139740
1360
02:21
so to spot them try asking yourself this:
51
141700
3720
02:26
is this information that
52
146360
2280
02:28
the other person really needs?
53
148640
2000
02:31
Are the answers obvious?
54
151780
2940
02:35
Listen for their tone of voice,
55
155460
2800
02:38
questions that are used as warnings
56
158260
2380
02:41
often use the same intonation as a statement.
57
161000
3260
02:45
Listen to:
58
165260
1780
02:47
Where did you get that hat?
59
167160
3980
02:51
And
60
171300
1000
02:53
Where did you get that hat?
61
173180
2940
02:57
In this case, Chloe was warning about
62
177820
3040
03:00
his hat looking silly,
63
180940
1680
03:02
but they can be about lots of different things
64
182620
2340
03:04
the weather,
65
184960
2320
03:07
time,
66
187280
1040
03:08
people's ideas.
67
188320
1280
03:09
You'll see more examples
68
189820
1580
03:11
at the end of the programme.
69
191560
1060
03:13
Mark: I feel like I want to try that again.
70
193500
2260
03:21
Chloe: Are you still off to Dave's party?
71
201620
1680
03:23
Mark: Yes... I'm off now.
72
203300
1320
03:25
Chloe: Are you really wearing that hat?
73
205600
2220
03:28
Mark: You don't think it's a good idea?
74
208560
1860
03:30
Chloe: Erm...
75
210580
1760
03:32
I'm not sure it's your colour.
76
212340
1600
03:34
Mark: Oh...
77
214800
920
03:35
um...
78
215720
1160
03:37
Alright, well...
79
217620
1540
03:39
Maybe I'll leave it at home then.
80
219160
2000
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7