Who is a native speaker?

80,098 views ・ 2022-10-20

Adam’s English Lessons


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Hi everybody, Adam here at www.engvid.com.
0
0
3240
00:03
A little bit of an unusual lesson type, but it's not really a lesson.
1
3240
4440
00:07
I just want to talk to you about what it means to be a native speaker.
2
7680
5160
00:12
Now, we've had some comments on our pages, a few of the teachers, that some people are
3
12840
6360
00:19
a little bit offended that we say "learn how to speak like a native speaker", "learn how
4
19200
5240
00:24
to listen like a native speaker", or "write like a native speaker".
5
24440
3600
00:28
So, I want to just address this little debate, controversy, whatever you want to call it.
6
28040
6400
00:34
I want to tell you what it means to be a native speaker.
7
34440
3640
00:38
There are three elements to being a native speaker; geography, idioms and slang or dialect,
8
38080
7880
00:45
and cultural references.
9
45960
1560
00:47
Now, am I a native speaker?
10
47520
3000
00:50
Yes.
11
50520
1000
00:51
I'm a Canadian English native speaker.
12
51520
4100
00:55
If I go to England, am I a native British English speaker?
13
55620
5140
01:00
No, I'm not.
14
60760
1780
01:02
There are many things in the British language, the British English language that I don't
15
62540
4660
01:07
actually know or understand.
16
67200
2120
01:09
There are many things that I say that they don't know or understand.
17
69320
3200
01:12
I lived in a few different countries.
18
72520
2760
01:15
I've taught English in a lot of different places.
19
75280
2600
01:17
I've had co-workers from all kinds of English-speaking countries, from England, Australia, New Zealand,
20
77880
6800
01:24
Ireland, etc.
21
84680
2280
01:26
All of us spoke a little bit differently.
22
86960
2920
01:29
Are we all native speakers?
23
89880
1960
01:31
Yes, in our native land.
24
91840
2520
01:34
So, that's what basically being a native speaker means.
25
94360
3280
01:37
So, when I say I'm going to teach you how to speak like a native speaker, and you know
26
97640
3800
01:41
I'm Canadian, you should understand that I'm going to teach you how to speak like a Canadian.
27
101440
4880
01:46
I can't even say I'm going to teach you how to speak like a North American, because how
28
106320
4320
01:50
they speak in Texas is not how they speak in Toronto, in Ontario, right?
29
110640
5320
01:55
Very different.
30
115960
1000
01:56
So, geography.
31
116960
1600
01:58
In England, even.
32
118560
1480
02:00
How they speak in London is not how they speak up in Birmingham or other places.
33
120040
6420
02:06
Every area has its own little bit of accent and dialect.
34
126460
3940
02:10
Every area has slightly different nuances to the language.
35
130400
4440
02:14
They use different idioms, they use different slang.
36
134840
2400
02:17
So, if you're brand new to a different part of your own country, there are certain things
37
137240
5520
02:22
that you will not understand because you're not from there, especially cultural references.
38
142760
7560
02:30
Certain things happen in certain areas, and the local population knows about it, and they
39
150320
5160
02:35
refer to it when they're making a joke or when they're making a statement.
40
155480
3720
02:39
And if you're not from there, you might not know what they're talking about.
41
159200
4480
02:43
Does this mean that you're not a native English speaker?
42
163680
2840
02:46
No.
43
166520
1000
02:47
You're still a native English speaker in your native area, right?
44
167520
3280
02:50
So, if I go to the east coast of Canada, they will say certain things that I will not understand,
45
170800
6520
02:57
and that's okay.
46
177320
1600
02:58
And if you're thinking native speaker is all about accent, it's not that either.
47
178920
4640
03:03
There are people who come to English-speaking countries as children and become native speakers,
48
183560
6200
03:09
but retain some of their accent from wherever they came from.
49
189760
4880
03:14
In fact, I had a co-worker once, and I won't say where she was from, but one day we were
50
194640
6160
03:20
sitting in the teacher's lounge, we were teaching at a language school here in Toronto, and
51
200800
4320
03:25
I asked her, "Oh, where's your accent from?"
52
205120
3840
03:28
And she got so upset.
53
208960
1000
03:29
She got all angry at me, and she goes, "I'm a native English speaker, I've been speaking
54
209960
4100
03:34
English my whole life."
55
214060
1860
03:35
And I said, "Yeah, okay.
56
215920
1000
03:36
I'm not - you know, I'm not saying you're not a native English speaker, but you certainly
57
216920
4000
03:40
have an accent."
58
220920
1000
03:41
Eventually, she told me where she was born and where her parents came from and all that,
59
221920
5800
03:47
and it wasn't Canada, and that little bit of accent stayed in her speech, but she got
60
227720
6320
03:54
so upset at it.
61
234040
1000
03:55
I didn't say she wasn't a native speaker, I just said she had an accent.
62
235040
4200
03:59
People always think that I have an accent, like they don't know where to place me, but
63
239240
4080
04:03
they think I have an accent.
64
243320
1560
04:04
I don't really have an accent, I enunciate.
65
244880
3760
04:08
I say each syllable clearly because I'm an English teacher.
66
248640
4960
04:13
I want my students to understand me, so I speak very clearly, and some people mistake
67
253600
6280
04:19
that for an accent, okay?
68
259880
2080
04:21
So that's a little bit interesting as well.
69
261960
2480
04:24
And then there's the idioms.
70
264440
1000
04:25
Again, I mentioned the idioms.
71
265440
1520
04:26
One time I was living in Japan, I was teaching there, and I had a British co-worker, and
72
266960
6400
04:33
one time her boyfriend and I went to the store to get some things, and I was having a cigarette,
73
273360
8640
04:42
and he said to me, "Can I bum a fag?"
74
282000
4960
04:46
Now, I looked at him, and I was like, "If you want, yeah, who am I to tell you what
75
286960
8360
04:55
to do, right?"
76
295320
1480
04:56
Because my understanding of the word "fag" and his understanding of the word "fag" were
77
296800
4280
05:01
completely different.
78
301080
2160
05:03
In England, a fag is a cigarette, but I had never heard this before, so this was brand
79
303240
4640
05:07
new to me.
80
307880
1000
05:08
So, it was a little bit of a funny situation.
81
308880
3240
05:12
Another time, I was at a bar with my Australian friend, and we were just talking, and his
82
312120
5360
05:17
friend, also Australian, came in right from work, and he was wearing a nice suit, and
83
317480
5560
05:23
he was holding a plastic bag.
84
323040
1880
05:24
So, my friend said to his friend, "Nice bag of fruit.
85
324920
5240
05:30
Nice bag of fruit."
86
330160
2040
05:32
So, of course, I looked at the bag to see the fruit, the nice fruit.
87
332200
5480
05:37
I was looking, "Oh, I want to see some nice fruit", and I look in the bag, and there's
88
337680
3320
05:41
nothing in the bag.
89
341000
1000
05:42
There's some papers and things like he was using for teaching, and they both looked at
90
342000
5080
05:47
me and started laughing because they realized I didn't understand what they were saying.
91
347080
5300
05:52
In Australian slang, "nice bag of fruit" means "nice suit" because they like to rhyme things.
92
352380
8580
06:00
If you saw the movie Ocean's Eleven, the guy - I think Basher is his name - he goes to
93
360960
6120
06:07
the sewer, he wants to blow up the hotel, and he tells them that they're in Barney,
94
367080
5580
06:12
and they don't understand.
95
372660
1860
06:14
Barney Rubble, they still don't understand.
96
374520
2960
06:17
Trouble.
97
377480
1000
06:18
So, Barney is short for Barney Rubble, which is a cartoon character, but it rhymes with
98
378480
5760
06:24
"trouble", and that's what he was saying to them, right?
99
384240
4280
06:28
Being a native speaker is not about having a particular accent or speaking in a particular
100
388520
8320
06:36
speed or knowing a particular number of words.
101
396840
3080
06:39
It's about communicating with the people who are from the same place without trouble.
102
399920
5600
06:45
As soon as you go out of your area, you are no longer a native English speaker.
103
405520
5600
06:51
On the other hand, a person born in Mumbai and has spoken English his or her whole life,
104
411120
6720
06:57
but has a very noticeable Indian accent, is still a native English speaker in Mumbai,
105
417840
6440
07:04
but not in Canada.
106
424280
1000
07:05
A Canadian is not a native English speaker in Mumbai, right?
107
425280
4000
07:09
So, that's the basic gist of what I want to say here.
108
429280
4320
07:13
Oh, and don't forget the cultural references, of course.
109
433600
3640
07:17
You have to know what the other person is speaking about.
110
437240
2200
07:19
So, if those of you out there who are getting upset because we say "speak like a native
111
439440
5160
07:24
English speaker", just understand, when I say "speak like a native English speaker",
112
444600
5120
07:29
I want you to speak like a Canadian.
113
449720
2240
07:31
If you don't want to speak like a Canadian, watch one of our British teachers and learn
114
451960
4240
07:36
how to speak like a British native English speaker.
115
456200
3260
07:39
If you want to speak like an Australian, find an Australian teacher.
116
459460
3380
07:42
If you want to speak like whoever you want to speak with, that's the native you need
117
462840
4440
07:47
to look for.
118
467280
1360
07:48
And otherwise, your aim should not to try to be a native speaker, it should try to be
119
468640
6080
07:54
fluent, with or without the accent, okay?
120
474720
4280
07:59
I hope that clears things up a little bit.
121
479000
3160
08:02
If you have to comment back to me, if you're upset, let me know you're upset.
122
482160
3700
08:05
If you're happy that I said all this, let me know that you're happy I said all this.
123
485860
3780
08:09
I won't get offended.
124
489640
2160
08:11
It's up to you to deal with the world you're living in, okay?
125
491800
4800
08:16
Until next time, I hope you liked this video.
126
496600
2680
08:19
Like the video if you liked it, subscribe to my channel, and come back next time for
127
499280
3400
08:22
more hopefully useful English tips to help you improve.
128
502680
4560
08:27
See you then.
129
507240
1000
08:28
Bye for now.
130
508240
23320

Original video on YouTube.com
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7