How to Deal with Criticism in English

20,815 views ・ 2021-11-09

Accent's Way English with Hadar


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Hey everyone, it's Hadar.
0
30
1110
00:01
Thank you so much for joining me.
1
1140
1620
00:02
Today I want to talk about receiving criticism.
2
2760
4320
00:07
Criticism is one of the hardest things to handle.
3
7620
2800
00:10
Because we want to be liked, we want to be accepted.
4
10420
3770
00:14
We want to be loved.
5
14370
1679
00:16
We want to please people.
6
16049
1771
00:17
And we don't like to feel like we are not good enough.
7
17820
4860
00:22
And usually, when we receive criticism - and it doesn't matter if there is a
8
22740
3900
00:26
source of truth in it or not - a lot of times it hits us deep in a place
9
26759
5691
00:32
that sort of confirms our preconceived notion of us not being good enough.
10
32450
6840
00:39
Now I'm not saying that it is true.
11
39320
2790
00:42
This is a psychological pattern that hits most of the population
12
42140
4920
00:47
called the impostor syndrome.
13
47060
1770
00:49
In fact, I talk a lot about the imposter syndrome on my podcast, and
14
49100
4080
00:53
I'm going to link to the episode below if you want to hear more about that.
15
53180
4565
00:58
So when we receive criticism, instead of just objectively considering it and
16
58075
4860
01:02
thinking whether or not it's right or what can you learn from it, it immediately
17
62935
5010
01:08
confirms our deepest fears and thoughts and feelings about not being good enough.
18
68065
7490
01:15
And especially when it comes to English, we're feeling like anyway our English
19
75625
3780
01:19
is not good enough cause we always compare it to our native language.
20
79405
2940
01:22
And of course, it's not going to feel good enough if you compare
21
82375
2670
01:25
it to your first language.
22
85045
990
01:26
Because you know, for most people, the first language is, you know,
23
86065
4020
01:30
so deeply rooted in them, and it's a part of their personality and
24
90085
4620
01:34
being that the second language will never be able to live up to it.
25
94705
3890
01:39
And that is okay.
26
99015
1200
01:40
We don't need it to be, we need to create new space for the second language,
27
100485
5790
01:46
and appreciate it for what it is.
28
106304
2221
01:48
Now, I decided to make this video because a few days ago one of my students
29
108585
3930
01:52
shared something that happened to her.
30
112515
1740
01:54
And I wanted to share it with you, and what I said to her, one piece of advice.
31
114645
4260
01:58
I said a lot of things, but one thing that I said to her and to
32
118905
4180
02:03
other students, and I think a really great way to handle such situations.
33
123105
6195
02:09
So, what happened was that she received a comment from a native speaker, telling
34
129390
6420
02:15
her that based on the amount of work that she's investing in her English and
35
135810
4020
02:19
the time she has lived in the US, she should sound or speak better by now.
36
139830
6045
02:26
First of all, I categorize it as microaggression and a mild case
37
146054
4530
02:30
of discrimination and even racism.
38
150584
2581
02:33
Because, you know, when you don't understand someone's journey and where
39
153435
4320
02:37
they come from, and you compare them to yourself - where you are the person
40
157755
4500
02:42
in power and you have the privilege of being born into English - and
41
162255
4949
02:47
you expect something from someone without having the experience of
42
167204
4121
02:51
having it yourself, I think it's very much detached and discriminatory.
43
171325
4470
02:56
Because you don't understand that people have different experiences,
44
176035
3330
02:59
different sounds, different Englishes, different colors, different
45
179365
3540
03:02
backgrounds, different cultures.
46
182905
1470
03:04
Not everyone is like you and not everyone needs to be and sound like you.
47
184375
4955
03:09
So that comment is irrelevant and insensitive.
48
189510
4110
03:13
And again, people with privilege don't know what it's like for people to learn a
49
193890
5010
03:18
second language, and to immerse themselves in a culture and in a language and in
50
198900
5040
03:23
a country that they weren't born into.
51
203940
3540
03:27
So let's begin with the fact that if you haven't mastered a second language
52
207750
4770
03:32
and you're able to speak fluently in that language and clearly, you have
53
212520
5310
03:37
no right to criticize or comment on someone else's accent, pronunciation,
54
217830
6390
03:44
fluency, or level of English or whatever language they're speaking.
55
224220
4080
03:48
Now, let's assume it happens.
56
228329
1891
03:50
Because there are insensitive, entitled, rude people who will always have something
57
230250
6360
03:56
to say about other people's performance, especially people who they feel are not
58
236610
4530
04:01
as good as they are in certain areas.
59
241470
2340
04:04
Like what happened with my student and many other students of mine.
60
244080
5460
04:09
All right?
61
249930
330
04:10
So this is not an invented situation.
62
250260
2340
04:13
Let's assume this happens.
63
253110
2500
04:16
We can't control other people's actions, but we can control our reaction, our
64
256130
6775
04:22
emotional response, and our interpretation of what it is that they're saying.
65
262905
6170
04:29
Here's the problem with criticism and imposter syndrome.
66
269580
3209
04:33
When someone says something negative about something that you are so afraid
67
273090
3569
04:36
of and you believe that about yourself, what will end up happening is that
68
276659
4291
04:40
you will use it as a confirmation to prove to yourself that what you think
69
280950
6029
04:46
about yourself, your inner critic, the darkest part in you, is true.
70
286979
4996
04:52
Instead of saying, "That's not true" or "That's impossible" or "What is she
71
292215
5730
04:57
talking about?", you will say, "Oh, here.
72
297945
5190
05:04
This is proof that I'm not good enough, that my pronunciation is not good
73
304085
3940
05:08
enough, that I shouldn't be living here, or I don't deserve to live here
74
308025
5280
05:13
or to speak, and I don't belong."
75
313305
2130
05:15
So, one, you need to remember that how you respond to it is very much subjective.
76
315495
8220
05:24
And you can respond to it different.
77
324045
2400
05:28
So what I would encourage you to do is to decide that you have, one - your
78
328140
5880
05:34
inner critic that will agree with, you know, feedback and criticism,
79
334020
4980
05:39
negative feedback and criticism, unhelpful feedback and criticism.
80
339000
3480
05:43
But don't forget that inside of you, you also have your
81
343080
6000
05:49
guardian, or your supporter.
82
349080
2520
05:53
And your guardian is going to do whatever is possible in their power to protect you.
83
353070
7715
06:00
You can also think of it as your protector.
84
360785
3010
06:04
And when something happens that challenges you, you can choose who you want to hear
85
364155
5700
06:09
their voice - your inner critic that will agree with it, or your guardian
86
369855
5340
06:15
that will deflect it and fight it.
87
375285
2220
06:17
And it's up to you.
88
377685
1050
06:18
Because again, we can't change them, and it's not our job to change them,
89
378915
3270
06:22
they need to do their own work.
90
382215
1350
06:23
But it's your job to decide how you are going to respond to things, so
91
383595
4380
06:27
that you will keep on the right track and the right path to success, and not
92
387975
5970
06:33
deviate from it or stop or regress.
93
393945
3390
06:37
Because here's the thing.
94
397424
1081
06:38
When you receive feedback and you say, "Yes, it's true", and you
95
398565
4109
06:42
internalize it and you feel bad about it, you're actually agreeing with it.
96
402674
5101
06:48
But how about this?
97
408104
1380
06:49
Let's assume someone says, "How long have you lived here?
98
409604
3361
06:52
Four years?
99
412965
839
06:54
Oh, your English should be better by now."
100
414164
2461
06:56
Or, "Based on all the hard work that you're doing, I don't know why you don't
101
416835
3930
07:00
sound like a native speaker just yet."
102
420765
1649
07:02
So, option one: "That is so true.
103
422445
3075
07:05
I can't believe it."
104
425520
1050
07:06
And then from that feeling, you will feel defeated and you would want to quit.
105
426989
6630
07:13
Instead, what if you fight back, and what if you deflect that criticism?
106
433769
6960
07:20
And what if you let your guardians step up and do the work?
107
440969
4801
07:26
And instead of saying, "Yes, you're right", say, "Who do you
108
446039
4020
07:30
think you are telling me this?
109
450059
1920
07:32
You have no right commenting on my English.
110
452130
3900
07:36
My English is none of business."
111
456239
3351
07:39
So, that way, instead of internalizing it, you're fighting it.
112
459705
4650
07:44
Instead of agreeing with it, you're rejecting it.
113
464535
3180
07:47
Instead of letting it stop you or hold you back, you're using it as fuel to
114
467775
6390
07:54
motivate you to do it despite or they think, to prove them wrong, to prove
115
474165
5430
07:59
to yourself that you are capable of doing anything you put your mind to.
116
479595
4920
08:04
And that you are good enough, wherever you're at.
117
484905
4470
08:09
Your English is good enough.
118
489705
1650
08:11
This is the job of your guardian that is inside of you.
119
491595
3480
08:15
You just need to give it more space, instead of giving more
120
495405
4350
08:19
space to the inner critic.
121
499755
1410
08:21
That is the best way to deflect criticism.
122
501255
4830
08:26
And I'm not saying that you have to respond on the spot, but you
123
506955
3240
08:30
could, like saying something like, "Oh, tell me how you did it.
124
510195
6719
08:36
What other language do you speak, remind me?
125
516944
2100
08:40
How did you do it that you got so fluent in...
126
520025
3110
08:43
what was that?
127
523224
1041
08:44
What's the second language that you're learning?
128
524265
1709
08:46
I'd be happy to learn from you."
129
526425
1409
08:49
Okay.
130
529724
600
08:51
Usually, and this is why I'm saying that this is a legit response,
131
531464
3630
08:55
people who comment on your English and criticize your English - they
132
535125
5459
09:00
have no idea what it's like.
133
540584
1451
09:02
Otherwise, they wouldn't be criticizing.
134
542805
1889
09:04
Now, yes, I know.
135
544935
1370
09:06
You might say, "No, but fellow non-native speakers might say that",
136
546895
4189
09:11
or "People from my own country, they always criticize each other."
137
551295
3690
09:15
I know that sometimes this is a trend.
138
555015
2069
09:17
And here I would categorize it as 'people who gain power by
139
557385
4469
09:21
making other people feel crappy'.
140
561854
2581
09:24
But again, the response should be the same.
141
564464
2791
09:27
Who do you think you are?
142
567285
1439
09:29
Who are you to tell me how I'm supposed or not supposed to sound like?
143
569025
4559
09:33
Who are you to tell me who do I need to sound like?
144
573675
3029
09:36
Become a fighter.
145
576765
660
09:38
Reject, deflect, and move forward.
146
578280
4169
09:42
And that is my advice to you on how to deal with criticism and
147
582750
4830
09:47
comments about your English.
148
587580
2340
09:50
What is your piece of advice for people who struggle with criticism,
149
590340
4109
09:54
who get comments on their English or pronunciation or intonation or a voice?
150
594630
4830
09:59
So I would love to hear from you.
151
599760
1710
10:01
Put it in the comments and give us more ideas as to ways to deal with
152
601470
7379
10:08
it mentally, technically, if you have specific sentences that you say to people.
153
608849
5490
10:14
Because I think we can definitely all learn from each other.
154
614579
3721
10:18
When it comes to me, and you know I often get criticism, I have learned
155
618390
4920
10:23
to deflect that and to reject that.
156
623310
3420
10:27
And I usually make a joke about the comment, this is my way of handling it.
157
627030
4560
10:31
I use humor because I have already taught myself to or trained myself to use the
158
631620
6360
10:37
'who do you think you are?' pattern, thinking pattern, whenever I get feedback.
159
637980
5910
10:43
And no matter who that person is, right?
160
643950
2700
10:46
Native speakers, not native speakers, teachers, non-teachers - I don't care.
161
646890
5385
10:52
You can't tell me how I should sound or what I should sound like.
162
652365
4290
10:56
And I hope that you got that from this episode.
163
656865
2640
10:59
All right.
164
659925
480
11:00
So thank you so, so much.
165
660435
1980
11:02
And I hope that discussion in the comments is going to be fruitful.
166
662445
3750
11:06
And as I said, I've added a bunch of useful videos in links to my
167
666495
4890
11:11
podcast and other YouTube videos where I talk about similar things.
168
671385
5230
11:16
So, if you want to build up your confidence and your resilience as an
169
676615
4060
11:20
English speaker as a second language, then make sure to check those out.
170
680675
3810
11:24
And if you haven't subscribed to my channel just yet,
171
684545
2310
11:27
what are you waiting for?
172
687485
990
11:28
Click 'subscribe' and hit the bell to get notifications
173
688475
3570
11:32
whenever I release a new video.
174
692045
1590
11:33
Thank you so much for being here.
175
693725
1170
11:35
And I'll catch you next time.
176
695195
1080
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7