Why Violence Is Rising With Global Temperatures | Peter Schwartzstein | TED

8,150 views ・ 2025-01-08

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:05
When, in late 2013,
0
5503
2869
00:08
ISIS recruiters first targeted the Tharthar area of central Iraq,
1
8406
3803
00:12
they arrived with a grimly effective plan in hand.
2
12243
2569
00:14
They went for some of the most drought-battered villagers,
3
14845
2770
00:17
conscious of how hard they would find it to resist the cash.
4
17648
2870
00:20
They made some of the most forceful pitches
5
20551
2002
00:22
to those whose small fields looked extra pitiful
6
22586
2336
00:24
after consecutive years of weak rains and fiercer heat.
7
24955
3637
00:28
Aware of the depth of distrust of government
8
28626
2135
00:30
after so many years of conflict,
9
30795
1968
00:32
recruiters even got adept at casting these conditions
10
32797
2636
00:35
as a product of state action.
11
35466
2069
00:37
That drought?
12
37568
1368
00:38
One villager remembered an ISIS member telling him
13
38969
2369
00:41
that it was because of government scientists'
14
41338
2169
00:43
manipulation of the weather,
15
43507
1402
00:44
just another immiserating middle finger from authorities out to get them.
16
44942
3537
00:48
ISIS varied its tactics elsewhere in Iraq and Syria.
17
48512
2503
00:51
Sometimes, they preyed on the most shabbily dressed men
18
51048
2603
00:53
at livestock markets.
19
53651
1168
00:54
On other occasions, they doled out gifts of food and cash
20
54819
2969
00:57
just as harvests failed.
21
57788
2002
00:59
However, in focusing on farming communities,
22
59790
2803
01:02
they were brutally consistent.
23
62593
1635
01:04
The more water-deprived the village, the more they visited it.
24
64261
3003
01:07
The poorer the farmers, the more relentless their pressure.
25
67298
3136
01:10
As I ultimately concluded after years of groundwork,
26
70434
2836
01:13
ideas might have jump-started the group,
27
73304
2135
01:15
but it was climate-related disorder that padded its ranks
28
75473
2769
01:18
and helped turn it into the thousand-strong force
29
78275
2303
01:20
it soon fielded.
30
80611
1168
01:21
I’ve spent more than a decade reporting on the links between climate and conflict.
31
81812
4171
01:26
And working out of umpteen countries and conflict zones,
32
86016
3037
01:29
I've come to see that there are increasingly few forms of violence
33
89053
3136
01:32
that don't have some sort of climate angle.
34
92223
2335
01:34
Take piracy in coastal Bangladesh.
35
94592
2035
01:36
These pirate crews are making a killing from kidnapping fishermen
36
96961
3370
01:40
who are sailing in ever-greater numbers
37
100364
1869
01:42
into their lairs.
38
102266
1301
01:43
Many of these fishermen are ex-farmers who’ve lost their lands to rising seas
39
103567
4305
01:47
and then felt they had no choice
40
107905
1568
01:49
but to seek an alternative living out on the water,
41
109473
2670
01:52
the dangers be damned.
42
112176
1568
01:53
Then, there are the clashes
43
113777
1335
01:55
between farmers and herders across Africa's Sahel.
44
115112
2703
01:57
Unsurprisingly, nothing good is coming from having more people with rival needs
45
117848
4405
02:02
competing for shrinking resources across a poorly governed landscape
46
122286
3337
02:05
that is less and less capable of providing them consistently.
47
125623
3169
02:08
Even within Western countries,
48
128792
1769
02:10
certain forms of violence appear to be rising in line with temperature.
49
130594
3537
02:14
According to research that colleagues and I are conducting in Greece,
50
134131
3303
02:17
the hotter the summer temperatures,
51
137468
1702
02:19
the greater the risk of women being attacked.
52
139170
2369
02:21
The examples are just coming thicker and faster.
53
141572
2669
02:24
Now, no one is claiming that this violence or any other
54
144241
2670
02:26
is down to climate change alone.
55
146911
2602
02:29
The relationship between the two is as inexact and as dependent on context
56
149547
4337
02:33
as the impacts of climate change in general.
57
153918
2135
02:36
And it’s almost always intermingling with other drivers of instability,
58
156086
3671
02:39
such as inequality or corruption.
59
159790
2603
02:42
But we have a few, often generalizable rules.
60
162426
2369
02:44
For one, climate change throws fuel on already smoldering fires.
61
164828
4805
02:49
If you have pre-existing conflict,
62
169633
1835
02:51
deep divisions across society and unresponsive institutions,
63
171468
4171
02:55
then these stresses are extra liable to spark violence.
64
175639
2836
02:58
For another, climate change eats away at the supports
65
178509
2903
03:01
that we as individuals, communities and nation-states
66
181445
3804
03:05
turn to in times of crisis.
67
185249
1935
03:07
For example, having lost many of their leading citizens to migration,
68
187184
3737
03:10
many communities now lack the wise old heads
69
190955
2669
03:13
needed to keep the peace when tougher times come.
70
193657
3404
03:17
Most importantly, climate change can just be a bridge too far,
71
197061
3870
03:20
the proverbial straw that breaks the camel's back
72
200965
2869
03:23
for many communities that are already up to their eyeballs
73
203834
2770
03:26
with trials of a different nature.
74
206637
1702
03:28
It's depressing, isn't it?
75
208806
1568
03:30
This is a planet that needs no more violence,
76
210407
2203
03:32
and here’s the potential for an awful lot more of it.
77
212643
2536
03:35
But there is room for optimism.
78
215212
1735
03:36
Every bit of stifled warming means fewer people exposed
79
216981
3103
03:40
to dangerous, possibly violent, triggering conditions.
80
220117
2836
03:42
Every dollar dedicated to well-conceived and effectively implemented adaptation
81
222987
4571
03:47
means more people with the tools to keep that peace
82
227591
2536
03:50
when those tougher times come.
83
230160
2103
03:52
Ultimately, if you're not motivated by melting ice caps,
84
232263
3636
03:55
I'm sure you'll be motivated by not being shot.
85
235933
2269
03:58
As faint a hopeful note as it might initially sound,
86
238235
2803
04:01
the grand reality is that most of this remains in our hands.
87
241071
2937
04:04
Thank you.
88
244675
1134
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7