How a Sanctuary for Self-Expression Can Change Lives | Lindsay Morris and Reed J. Williams | TED

11,991 views

2024-03-21 ・ TED


New videos

How a Sanctuary for Self-Expression Can Change Lives | Lindsay Morris and Reed J. Williams | TED

11,991 views ・ 2024-03-21

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:04
Reed J. Williams: I spent my early years stealing my baby sister's clothes,
0
4543
3545
00:08
teaching myself to braid hair on confused babysitters
1
8129
3129
00:11
and absolutely terrifying my mom and dad.
2
11258
2919
00:14
Any dish towel or scarf
3
14719
1836
00:16
within the limited reach of my three-year-old grasp
4
16596
2586
00:19
was quickly transformed into a makeshift wig of long hair
5
19182
3462
00:22
to be skillfully tossed over shoulder with dramatic flair.
6
22686
3336
00:27
My parents considered taking me to see a psychologist,
7
27023
3128
00:30
but finding a doctor in rural South Carolina
8
30193
3087
00:33
willing to even discuss gender with a three-year-old boy
9
33321
2920
00:36
proved challenging.
10
36283
2294
00:38
My parents had to actively avoid those who claimed to be able to fix me,
11
38618
3671
00:42
as we had received numerous offers
12
42289
1668
00:43
from local church leaders and school teachers.
13
43957
2586
00:47
For the most part, my parents were completely on their own
14
47085
3253
00:50
when it came to navigating my gender non-conforming childhood.
15
50338
3379
00:56
Lindsay Morris: I'm the mother of two sons who we raised on Long Island.
16
56511
4171
01:01
When our oldest son was three years old,
17
61141
2669
01:03
he found his way into the depths of my closet
18
63852
3295
01:07
and re-emerged triumphantly in a pair of dust-covered heels.
19
67147
5255
01:13
His father and I continued to watch this daily ritual
20
73278
4379
01:17
where Milo would layer on
21
77657
1919
01:19
and tear off the brightest garments that he could find in my wardrobe.
22
79576
4921
01:26
While his younger brother strived to land objects in baskets,
23
86666
4838
01:31
Milo, when taken to his first soccer clinic, asked innocently,
24
91504
5422
01:36
"Why would anyone want to chase a ball around a field?"
25
96968
3879
01:40
(Laughter)
26
100847
2836
01:43
It was a simple but profound question,
27
103725
3795
01:47
it definitely challenged gender stereotypes that were familiar to me.
28
107520
4421
01:52
And it was hard to disagree with him.
29
112692
2544
01:55
But still, I kept his hair buzzed short
30
115278
3045
01:58
and bought him more Matchbox cars to join the dozens of others
31
118365
4921
02:03
in his gem-encrusted suitcase.
32
123328
3170
02:06
(Laughter)
33
126539
1335
02:07
RJW: My mom found me hand-me-down clothes from friends with older daughters
34
127916
3670
02:11
that I was free to wear around the house.
35
131628
2377
02:14
But in public,
36
134047
1418
02:15
I was limited to a winter stocking cap that I used to cover my short hair.
37
135507
4504
02:20
I wore that hat constantly, even when I slept,
38
140053
2711
02:22
to the point where I began to develop a bald spot on the side of my head.
39
142806
3545
02:26
Thankfully, my dad made me a baseball cap with a little piece of rope
40
146726
3545
02:30
and a wooden bead tied to the end,
41
150271
1919
02:32
meant to mimic the swinging motion of a ponytail when I walked.
42
152190
3587
02:36
This both alleviated my frustration with short haircuts
43
156611
3378
02:39
and prevented premature baldness.
44
159989
1794
02:41
(Laughter)
45
161825
1126
02:42
For which I'm eternally grateful.
46
162992
1711
02:45
As I got older, I had to quickly adapt to the unspoken rules of gender
47
165453
5130
02:50
or face severe social fallout.
48
170583
1961
02:52
I can never forget the harsh glares from parents
49
172961
2669
02:55
at the preschool Halloween parade,
50
175672
1877
02:57
when I dared to show up wearing a homemade unicorn costume.
51
177590
3379
03:01
The teacher who told my mom, "No one agrees with what you're doing,
52
181428
4170
03:05
and you're going to hell for how you raise your child."
53
185640
2795
03:09
Before banning dress up for the entire class
54
189060
2336
03:11
because of what I chose to put on my body.
55
191438
2377
03:14
The efforts to police my gender
56
194274
2085
03:16
and somehow shape me into a "normal boy" were constant,
57
196401
3920
03:20
unavoidable and entirely ineffective.
58
200321
2878
03:25
LM: It was almost Halloween,
59
205618
1919
03:27
a grueling time of costume negotiations
60
207537
3462
03:31
for the parents of gender-creative children.
61
211040
2837
03:34
At our local Target, Milo,
62
214461
2961
03:37
with all the conviction of a seasoned attorney,
63
217422
2878
03:40
directed me to the shoe department,
64
220300
2711
03:43
where we would yet again visit the coveted ruby slippers.
65
223052
6549
03:52
With each step, our anxieties grew,
66
232520
3712
03:56
his mood mirroring my uncertainty as I wavered.
67
236232
4213
04:00
There were tears and a public tantrum over those ruby slippers.
68
240820
4922
04:05
And yet I denied him this simple wish,
69
245742
3795
04:09
leaving him confused and deflated.
70
249579
3629
04:14
What was I so afraid of?
71
254375
2294
04:16
Was it the judgmental glances of the other moms
72
256711
4004
04:20
as my son paraded perfectly in discount heels at play dates?
73
260715
4963
04:25
(Laughter)
74
265720
1627
04:27
Their expressions were very memorable.
75
267388
3504
04:30
Or maybe it was the grim statistics that were looming in the background.
76
270934
5463
04:36
I was well aware of the rising suicide rates of LGBTQ teens.
77
276439
6006
04:43
Or perhaps it was a new territory.
78
283530
3253
04:47
Navigating this expression of gender that I had no vocabulary for.
79
287367
6131
04:55
These denials left our son miserable.
80
295291
3754
05:00
It was a low point for me in my motherhood
81
300421
3045
05:03
but also a turning point for us as a family.
82
303466
3921
05:07
We all agreed it was time to stop overanalyzing gender norms:
83
307762
5756
05:13
his toys, his clothing, his haircuts.
84
313518
3378
05:18
And let Milo take the lead,
85
318106
1877
05:20
embracing choices that rang true to him.
86
320024
3629
05:24
(Applause)
87
324487
5381
05:29
RJW: My first psychologist introduced us to a highly protected listserv
88
329868
4045
05:33
where my mom discovered a support group
89
333955
2127
05:36
looking to create in-person opportunities
90
336124
2085
05:38
for families with gender non-conforming kids to gather together.
91
338209
4004
05:42
That summer,
92
342547
1168
05:43
my mom packed her kids into a minivan
93
343756
1877
05:45
and drove from Greenville, South Carolina to Washington, DC,
94
345633
3170
05:48
where we stayed in a small hotel with four other families
95
348845
2836
05:51
who allowed their sons to dress and act however they wanted.
96
351681
3337
05:55
This was the first summer of Camp I Am.
97
355685
3670
06:00
At just four years old,
98
360398
1543
06:01
I was too young to swim in the deep end of the hotel pool
99
361983
2753
06:04
without floaties,
100
364736
1459
06:06
but I relished in slumber parties and fashion shows
101
366237
3587
06:09
with kids who acted just like I did,
102
369824
2628
06:12
if not more flamboyantly.
103
372493
2253
06:15
For the first time in my life,
104
375204
1919
06:17
I was free to wear a dress in front of people
105
377165
2127
06:19
who weren't my immediate family.
106
379292
2127
06:22
I could paint my fingernails
107
382211
1460
06:23
without having to remove the polish an hour later.
108
383671
3128
06:27
I remember feather boas and friendship bracelets,
109
387800
3671
06:31
American Girl dolls and makeovers,
110
391512
2378
06:33
and a pillowcase signed with notes of encouragement from all my new friends.
111
393932
4295
06:38
I slept with that pillowcase every single night
112
398728
2920
06:41
after that first camp weekend ended.
113
401648
2460
06:46
LM: "I think I'm the only one like this," Milo said.
114
406486
4212
06:51
Those words hit hard,
115
411991
1460
06:53
but they also motivated me to seek families like Reed's family
116
413451
5088
06:58
facing similar circumstances.
117
418581
2961
07:01
In 2008, in the early days of the internet,
118
421542
2753
07:04
I typed "my son loves pink" into a search engine
119
424337
5922
07:10
and found myself on the website
120
430301
2211
07:12
of the Children's National Medical Center in Washington, DC,
121
432553
4296
07:16
where I would discover a carefully vetted listserv
122
436849
3754
07:20
where parents could discuss the challenges and triumphs
123
440645
4463
07:25
of raising gender-creative children.
124
445108
3086
07:29
The day our family stepped into the meet and greet room
125
449153
5506
07:34
of the modest hotel in Washington, DC,
126
454701
3378
07:38
we saw parents with a mix of hope and relief on their faces.
127
458079
5672
07:44
This is where I would also meet Reed at age seven.
128
464502
3378
07:47
(Laughter)
129
467922
3087
07:51
Though her gender had not yet been determined.
130
471009
3253
07:55
There we took in a room filled with little boys,
131
475930
4088
08:00
most in hues of pink and purple,
132
480059
3921
08:04
and almost all with American Girl dolls dangling at their sides
133
484022
4254
08:08
or clutched tightly to their chests.
134
488317
2336
08:12
The eyes of parents welled up as they entered this room.
135
492155
3545
08:15
And I remember one father with the baseball cap saying,
136
495700
3962
08:19
"Whoa,
137
499662
1752
08:21
I guess he's found his tribe."
138
501456
2002
08:23
(Laughter)
139
503458
1668
08:26
Up until this moment, we had all felt so isolated.
140
506502
5589
08:33
RJW: It wasn't until I was eight years old
141
513217
2294
08:35
that I met an openly trans girl
142
515511
2253
08:37
who refused to hide who she was in front of others.
143
517764
3044
08:41
She was the only other camper from South Carolina,
144
521350
2586
08:43
and she wore intricate lace tights and the most gorgeous high heels
145
523936
3671
08:47
I had ever seen in my entire life.
146
527648
1919
08:50
She embodied Y2K vampy glam effortlessly,
147
530318
4254
08:54
and I followed her around like a lost puppy,
148
534572
2711
08:57
marveling at her grace and freedom to be herself.
149
537325
3920
09:02
She let me try on her treasured high heels for a day.
150
542163
3462
09:06
At Camp I Am,
151
546417
1335
09:07
I literally walked a mile in the shoes of a trans girl for the first time.
152
547752
3795
09:13
In 2015, over three years later,
153
553925
2961
09:16
I finally told my parents that I'm a girl.
154
556928
3086
09:20
At the time, everyone had a different opinion on the correct path forward.
155
560765
3795
09:25
One mother from Camp I Am told my mom that her son had also come out as trans,
156
565103
4421
09:29
but she had no responsibility to pay for hormone blockers
157
569524
3003
09:32
or navigate social transition at their age.
158
572568
2753
09:36
She advised my mom to wait until I was 18
159
576114
2836
09:38
and I could make the decision for myself.
160
578950
2252
09:42
My mom was horrified by the idea
161
582745
3128
09:45
of leaving me to suffer for six more years on my own.
162
585915
3587
09:50
It was then that she knew she could never inflict the hardship
163
590628
2961
09:53
of continuing to be misperceived as a boy on me.
164
593631
3378
09:58
As terrifying as it felt for my parents to consent to trans health care
165
598177
4463
10:02
on my behalf,
166
602682
1460
10:04
we knew that it promised the best possible outcome.
167
604183
3212
10:08
By this point, we had already moved to Virginia,
168
608688
2627
10:11
and we began taking monthly four-hour road trips to Richmond
169
611357
3796
10:15
for gender affirming therapy
170
615194
1627
10:16
and, eventually, endocrinology appointments.
171
616821
2794
10:20
I socially transitioned that summer,
172
620658
2461
10:23
and I haven't looked back since.
173
623161
1543
10:24
(Applause)
174
624745
6966
10:31
I don't know if I would have reached that happy conclusion
175
631711
2794
10:34
without my time and the community
176
634547
2377
10:36
at Camp I Am.
177
636966
1210
10:40
LM: I became the de facto photographer
178
640386
2711
10:43
of the closely-knit Camp I Am community in 2009,
179
643097
5089
10:48
capturing the kids' moments of freedom
180
648227
3045
10:51
where they could run and twirl and sing
181
651272
4421
10:55
and express their interpretations of gender
182
655735
3628
10:59
alongside their parents and their siblings.
183
659363
3420
11:03
For the kids,
184
663910
1209
11:05
the photos provided vibrant mementos to reassure them throughout the year.
185
665161
5547
11:12
It took a lot of courage in 2012,
186
672710
3170
11:15
when camp parents and children agreed to have their photographs published
187
675922
4337
11:20
in the New York Times Magazine cover story,
188
680259
3045
11:23
"What's Wrong with a Boy Who Wears a Dress?"
189
683304
3003
11:27
I'll never forget the evening.
190
687433
1835
11:29
The kids were standing in front of the red barn,
191
689560
3128
11:32
excitedly preparing for the annual camp fashion show,
192
692730
3629
11:36
and the parents stood behind me and my tripod,
193
696359
3128
11:39
mesmerized by their children's joy.
194
699528
3003
11:44
"We need to show our kids to the world,"
195
704367
3169
11:47
a mom said quietly.
196
707536
2336
11:49
And one of the dads said, "That would be terrifying.
197
709872
3212
11:53
But perhaps if we shared our normal with the public,
198
713084
4462
11:57
it would open a dialogue that was far overdue."
199
717546
3754
12:01
RJW: When I look back at Lindsay’s photos from Camp I Am,
200
721926
3587
12:05
I see children who possess an intimate understanding of who they are.
201
725554
4422
12:10
That many could only hope to someday experience.
202
730893
2669
12:14
We were among the earliest experts on queer youth,
203
734355
3712
12:18
running wild in the woods with glitter and flowers in our overgrown hair.
204
738109
4087
12:22
The kids of Camp I Am were some of the first
205
742989
2335
12:25
to openly question why we have to behave
206
745324
2544
12:27
in accordance with our sex assigned at birth?
207
747868
2545
12:30
The first kids with parents willing to fight for
208
750788
2544
12:33
rather than suppress our emerging identities.
209
753374
2836
12:37
When I look at these images,
210
757128
1918
12:39
I see liberation.
211
759088
1877
12:41
I see the future.
212
761674
1376
12:43
A world where kids are encouraged to express themselves
213
763759
3337
12:47
free from judgment.
214
767138
1543
12:49
Where parents are encouraged to ask questions and seek support
215
769056
4296
12:53
rather than compel their children to embody arbitrary gender roles.
216
773352
4421
12:57
LM: Although we parents shared a common thread,
217
777815
3504
13:01
our perspectives were diverse.
218
781360
3379
13:05
To put it mildly.
219
785573
1293
13:07
Parents came from across the country
220
787491
2086
13:09
with varying religious beliefs, political,
221
789577
3420
13:12
socioeconomic backgrounds.
222
792997
3253
13:16
And it wasn't easy.
223
796250
1960
13:19
Divorces happened,
224
799628
1669
13:21
a Mormon family was excommunicated.
225
801297
2878
13:25
And some are uprooted,
226
805343
1167
13:26
finding it simply impossible to live in unsupportive communities.
227
806510
4296
13:31
Today, like Reed,
228
811932
1210
13:33
many of these young adults are advocating for themselves and for their rights.
229
813184
5964
13:40
Some transitioned seamlessly thanks to a lot of courage,
230
820024
4254
13:44
and also thanks to parents who educated themselves,
231
824320
3295
13:47
seeking out the most appropriate care for their child,
232
827656
4839
13:52
no matter where they landed on the gender spectrum.
233
832536
2878
13:56
And like Reed today, there are so many success stories of the former campers.
234
836207
5005
14:02
Not everyone followed the same track.
235
842129
2711
14:04
Today, my son Milo identifies as a gay man
236
844882
4838
14:09
living in New York City
237
849720
1877
14:11
and studying fashion marketing and advertising at FIT.
238
851597
4463
14:16
RJW: Camp I Am was an oasis,
239
856102
3295
14:19
a brief reprieve from the endless harassment and judgment
240
859397
3503
14:22
from strangers who claimed to know what was in my best interest.
241
862900
3921
14:27
Attending camp didn't make me trans.
242
867238
2878
14:30
My parents did not make me trans.
243
870741
2294
14:33
(Laughter)
244
873077
1418
14:34
If anything, I never went out of my way to be different or unordinary.
245
874537
4796
14:39
I was just encouraged to be myself, whatever that may look like.
246
879333
4129
14:44
The early support that I received
247
884004
1710
14:45
made it possible for me to pursue a life worth living.
248
885756
3087
14:49
Today, I’m a fourth-year at the University of Virginia
249
889969
3503
14:53
studying political and social thought and poetry writing.
250
893514
3045
14:57
I'm an advocate on behalf of trans youth.
251
897017
2503
15:00
I've spent the past two summers working as a camp counselor,
252
900229
3837
15:04
helping to provide even more trans kids
253
904066
2503
15:06
with that same fulfilling summer camp experience
254
906610
2962
15:09
that helped make me the person I am today.
255
909613
2711
15:13
I can only hope that more parents see from my story
256
913325
3796
15:17
and the story of Camp I Am,
257
917163
2544
15:19
the importance of protecting and supporting
258
919748
2628
15:22
trans and gender non-conforming children
259
922376
2961
15:25
as my parents protected and supported me.
260
925337
2753
15:29
Thank you.
261
929008
1168
15:30
LM: Thank you.
262
930217
1126
15:31
(Applause)
263
931385
2002
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7