I’m a Conservative — and I Care About the Climate, Too | Danielle Butcher Franz | TED

7,674 views

2025-01-20 ・ TED


New videos

I’m a Conservative — and I Care About the Climate, Too | Danielle Butcher Franz | TED

7,674 views ・ 2025-01-20

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:08
So I'm curious.
0
8556
1600
00:10
And if you'll all indulge me, could I please see a show of hands
1
10156
4320
00:14
of how many of you have ever disagreed with your political party of choice?
2
14516
5360
00:20
OK, so it looks like we are in pretty good company here.
3
20676
3840
00:24
I grew up in the US,
4
24556
2160
00:26
in a small town in rural northern Minnesota,
5
26756
4480
00:31
and my hometown was so small, in fact,
6
31236
2440
00:33
that it was a big deal when our population hit 300.
7
33716
4200
00:38
As you can imagine, in a town that small people spend a lot of time outdoors.
8
38876
5600
00:44
Summers are typically spent in the water,
9
44516
2600
00:47
swimming, fishing and kayaking.
10
47116
2360
00:49
And winters are typically spent on the water,
11
49516
2280
00:51
snowmobiling, snowshoeing and ice skating.
12
51836
3120
00:54
As for me, I spent a lot of time in the woods hunting with my dad,
13
54956
3720
00:58
which is where my passion for the environment was born.
14
58716
3680
01:02
Dad and I agreed early on that conservation was a shared value.
15
62436
4200
01:06
We agreed that climate change was happening.
16
66676
2320
01:08
And we agreed that something needed to be done about it.
17
68996
2800
01:13
As I got older, however,
18
73596
1680
01:15
in terms of politics,
19
75316
1280
01:16
my views began to shift away from those of my progressive family,
20
76636
3920
01:20
and I found myself aligning a little bit more closely
21
80596
3040
01:23
with the Republican Party on issues like abortion, the economy,
22
83676
3560
01:27
regulations and markets.
23
87236
2280
01:29
While these views didn't change my commitment
24
89556
2360
01:31
to environmental stewardship or climate change,
25
91916
2480
01:34
they did often put me at odds with my progressive family members
26
94436
3560
01:37
and left me feeling out of place in environmental circles.
27
97996
3800
01:41
Around the family dinner table,
28
101836
1520
01:43
Republicans were often referred to in a derogatory way,
29
103396
3360
01:46
and while I love my family,
30
106796
1560
01:48
I'm sure I'm not the only one here who's ever had to tune out
31
108396
3080
01:51
the political rantings of another family member
32
111516
2200
01:53
at the dinner table.
33
113756
1680
01:56
Now in my view,
34
116156
2200
01:58
my family dinner table became emblematic of a larger cultural problem that we face.
35
118396
4840
02:03
I often felt that environmentalists were overlooking or outright rejecting
36
123236
4280
02:07
the concerns of very important constituencies, like farmers, hunters,
37
127556
5040
02:12
traditional energy workers and rural Americans.
38
132636
3320
02:15
They certainly were engaging productively with industry,
39
135956
2840
02:18
and it felt that they were quick to point fingers at the right
40
138836
3160
02:21
instead of trying to find ways that we could work together.
41
141996
3240
02:25
Now despite my frustration with the left,
42
145236
2880
02:28
I admit my newfound political party had a lot of work to do.
43
148116
4680
02:32
Republicans were increasingly engaging in debating climate science,
44
152836
4960
02:37
oftentimes skeptical
45
157836
1560
02:39
or outright antagonistic toward climate change.
46
159436
2760
02:42
And comments about climate change being a “Chinese hoax”
47
162196
3720
02:45
did very little to encourage constructive dialogue across the aisle.
48
165916
4920
02:50
It was then that it hit me that both the left and right
49
170876
2760
02:53
were stalling climate change in their own ways.
50
173676
2800
02:56
On the left, we saw purity tests
51
176516
2840
02:59
and an unwillingness to engage with different ideas,
52
179396
2440
03:01
and on the right we saw outright rejection.
53
181876
3280
03:05
And I soon realized that we couldn't leave climate change
54
185156
3320
03:08
to one political party alone.
55
188516
3080
03:11
In fact, climate change will not be solved by one political party,
56
191636
3520
03:15
one ideology or one movement.
57
195156
2880
03:18
Between now and 2050,
58
198036
2400
03:20
the US will decide six presidential elections
59
200476
3240
03:23
and several more congressional turnovers.
60
203756
2440
03:26
I know other countries will also have their own transitions of power,
61
206196
3280
03:29
which means that between now and then,
62
209476
3240
03:32
it would be so foolish to assume
63
212756
2560
03:35
that one party could retain power through it all
64
215356
2760
03:38
and single-handedly solve climate change.
65
218116
2520
03:40
So what does that mean for us?
66
220676
1480
03:42
Well, it means we have to find ways to work together,
67
222156
2520
03:44
or climate change will continue to be an issue that we face and get worse.
68
224716
4920
03:49
This is what led me in 2017 to cofound the American Conservation Coalition.
69
229676
6000
03:55
We were founded by a group of young Republicans
70
235716
2320
03:58
who wanted to see conservatives engaging productively on environmental issues
71
238036
3880
04:01
and provide them a platform where they could talk about these issues
72
241916
3240
04:05
in a way that didn't betray their dearly held values.
73
245156
2520
04:07
And as it turns out, young Republicans are already onboard.
74
247716
3280
04:10
In fact, 81 percent of young conservatives believe that the climate is changing
75
250996
5200
04:16
and want to see it addressed.
76
256196
2240
04:18
We knew that these young Americans deserved a seat at the table
77
258476
3480
04:21
and that their voices could be useful
78
261956
1840
04:23
in pushing the party forward on climate change.
79
263836
3240
04:27
We've decided that our work can be most effective in two ways:
80
267076
3560
04:30
changing the narrative and influencing those who have influence.
81
270676
4000
04:34
And I want to be clear that changing the narrative is twofold.
82
274716
3480
04:38
Because while many on the left believe that all Republicans are climate deniers,
83
278196
4200
04:42
many on the right also believe that all climate action is a Trojan horse
84
282436
4400
04:46
for big government policies that they don't support and don't agree with.
85
286876
3920
04:50
So at ACC, we combat these narratives by publishing op-eds, appearing in media
86
290836
5160
04:55
and amplifying the voices of conservatives
87
295996
2080
04:58
who believe these issues are serious and need to be taken seriously.
88
298076
3680
05:01
This helps reframe the way that Republicans view these issues
89
301796
3800
05:05
and shows the left that conservatives do care,
90
305636
2520
05:08
even if in their own way.
91
308156
1440
05:10
I knew our message was resonating and far-reaching
92
310796
3360
05:14
when conservative commentator Bill O'Reilly invited me on his show
93
314156
3960
05:18
to talk about conservative climate solutions,
94
318116
2400
05:20
and even noted that he was glad to see us changing hearts and minds.
95
320556
3840
05:24
Now since our founding, we’ve appeared in media over 3,000 times,
96
324436
4920
05:29
reached hundreds of millions across social media,
97
329396
3000
05:32
and oftentimes hear our talking points echoed
98
332436
2360
05:34
by other conservative leaders in the movement.
99
334836
2360
05:38
Politicians like Congressman John Curtis of Utah
100
338316
2880
05:41
helped prove that it's possible to be a Republican
101
341196
2400
05:43
who cares about climate change.
102
343636
1680
05:45
He recently won his senatorial primary in a landslide,
103
345356
3360
05:48
not just as a Republican who talks about climate change
104
348756
2680
05:51
but as a Republican who founded the Conservative Climate Caucus
105
351476
3520
05:54
and acts on climate change.
106
354996
2480
05:57
Many conservatives often view climate change
107
357516
2480
05:59
as an electoral liability,
108
359996
1760
06:01
and Congressman Curtis proves that it can be an asset.
109
361796
4000
06:05
So we work with policymakers like Congressman Curtis
110
365836
2920
06:08
to champion an innovative, market-driven approach to climate change.
111
368796
3920
06:12
We advocate for things like fewer regulations
112
372756
2400
06:15
and more emphasis on entrepreneurship,
113
375156
2400
06:17
knowing that we need all hands on deck to solve this problem.
114
377596
3680
06:21
We think that on the policy front, Republicans actually have a lot to offer.
115
381316
3760
06:25
Things like permitting reform to build cleaner energy projects,
116
385076
3480
06:28
things like embracing nuclear energy
117
388596
2080
06:30
and things like exporting clean American energy
118
390716
2240
06:32
to our friends and allies around the world
119
392956
2080
06:35
will not only help reduce global carbon emissions
120
395036
2960
06:37
but also grow the US economy.
121
397996
1840
06:40
To the surprise of many, we're not alone in this work,
122
400676
2600
06:43
and I'm proud to report that ACC now has over 60,000 members across the country
123
403316
5600
06:48
who are young conservatives that want to see action on this issue.
124
408916
3200
06:52
And we also work with a broad coalition of eco right groups,
125
412116
2960
06:55
such as DEPLOY/US, ClearPath and the Conservative Energy Network.
126
415076
4760
06:59
Internationally, we're proud to work with organizations
127
419876
2920
07:02
in the UK, Canada and Australia
128
422836
2320
07:05
who are doing similar work in their respective countries.
129
425156
3400
07:08
While conservatives and progressives may not always agree
130
428596
2680
07:11
on the best ways to address climate change,
131
431316
2040
07:13
we can find common ground in our shared commitment to the environment.
132
433396
3280
07:16
And while there's still work to be done,
133
436716
1920
07:18
there are Republicans who want to come to the table
134
438676
2440
07:21
and engage on climate in good faith.
135
441116
2040
07:23
All we're asking,
136
443156
1840
07:24
and all that I'm asking,
137
444996
1920
07:26
is that you meet us there.
138
446916
1720
07:28
Thank you.
139
448676
1040
07:29
(Applause)
140
449716
3520
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7